14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Criminal Law

A complaint against a police officer: the route through the SP

A complaint against a police officer in West Bengal does not begin with a lawsuit. It begins with a written complaint to the officer's superior, and the higher you go, the more likely it is to be examined — to the officer in charge for a constable, to the deputy commissioner or the superintendent of police for an inspector, and to the commissioner for a senior officer. A complaint against police officer conduct that is recorded, dated and specific is the one that gets an enquiry; a complaint made verbally at the counter is the one that disappears.

There are four tracks, and they do different things. The departmental track punishes the officer. The criminal track prosecutes him, and needs sanction in most cases. The magistrate's track addresses the failure to investigate. The writ track addresses illegality by the police as a public authority. Choosing the right track depends on what the complainant wants — an enquiry, a prosecution, an FIR, or the release of a person in custody.

The departmental complaint

The first step is a written complaint to the officer in charge of the police station where the officer is posted, and a copy to the sub-divisional police officer or the deputy commissioner of the division. The complaint should state the date, time and place of the incident, the name and buckle number of the officer if known, the words used and the acts done, the names of witnesses, and the relief sought — an enquiry, a copy of the general diary entry, or action against the officer.

Where the complaint is against the officer in charge himself, it goes to the sub-divisional police officer or the deputy commissioner, and where it is against a senior officer, to the commissioner of police for Kolkata or the director general of police for the state. Send it by registered post with acknowledgement due, and keep the receipt, because the record of sending is often the only proof that the complaint was made.

West Bengal has a police complaints authority constituted under the directions that followed the Supreme Court's guidelines on police reform, and a complaint of serious misconduct can be made to it. The authority examines the complaint and can recommend action, though it does not itself punish. The route is useful where the departmental enquiry has been closed without reasons.

The criminal complaint, and the sanction problem

Where the officer's conduct amounts to an offence — extortion, wrongful confinement, assault, fabrication of evidence, destruction of a document — a criminal complaint can be filed. The obstacle is the requirement of sanction for the prosecution of a public servant for acts done in the discharge of his official duty. The sanction is granted by the authority competent to remove the officer, and the complaint must therefore be accompanied by a request for sanction, or the court will stay the proceeding until it is produced.

Where the act complained of is not connected with official duty — a personal assault at a wedding, an extortion at a market — the sanction requirement does not apply, and the complaint can proceed directly. The distinction is fact-specific, and the complaint should plead the facts that take the act outside official duty.

The criminal complaint is filed before the magistrate having jurisdiction, either as a complaint case or, where the police refuse to register an FIR against their own officer, under Section 175(3) of the Sanhita. A complaint against a police officer that names a section of the penal law, and attaches the medical report and the witnesses, is a different document from a letter of grievance.

The magistrate's track for a failure to investigate

Where the grievance is not misconduct but inaction — a refused FIR, a case not investigated, a witness not examined — the remedy is the application to the magistrate under Section 175(3), asking for a direction to investigate. The application should set out the information given to the police, the refusal or the inaction, and the evidence, and it should name the officer whose inaction is complained of.

The magistrate can also be moved for a direction to the police to produce the general diary, or to register the case. Where the police have registered a case and then closed it without investigation, the magistrate can call for the case diary and examine it, and can direct further investigation.

This track does not punish the officer, but it achieves the result the complainant usually wants — an investigation. The departmental and criminal tracks can run alongside it.

The writ petition

Where the police act illegally as a public authority — a detention without production, a refusal to register a case in the face of a cognizable offence, the sealing of premises without authority, a failure to protect a person who has complained of a threat — a writ petition before the Calcutta High Court is available. The petition is filed under Article 226, and it asks for a direction to the police to act, or to refrain from acting, and for compensation where the illegality has caused loss.

Writs are quick where the facts are sharp and the illegality is patent, and slow where the court has to decide disputed questions of fact. A habeas corpus petition, in particular, is heard urgently, and it is the remedy where a person is detained without being produced before a magistrate.

For a compensation claim arising from police action, the writ route can produce an award, but the civil suit in the City Civil Court is the more usual forum for damages. Our page on writ petitions sets out the format and the material.

What to preserve

  • The written complaint and its acknowledgement, or the postal receipt.
  • The general diary entry number, or the refusal to give one.
  • The names and buckle numbers of the officers involved, and the names of the witnesses.
  • The medical report, where there is an injury, obtained the same day.
  • Photographs and video of the scene, the injuries and the premises, with the date and time visible.
  • Any money receipt, seizure memo or notice handed over by the officer.

A complaint that is backed by these documents is examined. A complaint that rests on recollection is answered with a denial, and the denial is the end of it.

The limits, stated plainly

A complaint against a police officer is not a way to escape a lawful investigation. Where a case has been registered on evidence, complaining about the officer does not stop the case, and a false complaint is itself an offence. The complaint should be about the conduct, not about the fact that the police are doing their job.

Nor does a departmental complaint produce an apology or compensation. It produces an enquiry, and at most a punishment for the officer. The compensation route is a civil suit or a writ, and the two should be pursued with different expectations.

Where the complaint concerns a person in custody, the first priority is the person's release or his production before a magistrate. The complaint about the officer can wait a week; the production cannot wait a day.

Common questions

Can a complaint be filed anonymously?

It can, and the authority may act on it where the allegations are specific and verifiable. But an anonymous complaint is harder to pursue, because the enquiry needs a complainant to produce the documents. A complaint with a name and a request for confidentiality is better than an anonymous one.

Does the officer get to see the complaint?

In a departmental enquiry, the officer is given the substance of the allegations and an opportunity to reply. The identity of the complainant may be protected in a serious case, but the enquiry cannot proceed on a secret accusation without any disclosure. Where confidentiality is essential, say so in the complaint and ask the authority to consider it.

How long does the departmental enquiry take?

There is no fixed period in the rules. A straightforward complaint against a constable may be closed within weeks; a complaint against an inspector may take months. The complainant is entitled to be informed of the outcome, and a written request for the result after a reasonable period is the way to keep the file moving.

Can a police officer sue the complainant for defamation?

He can, but a complaint made in good faith to a lawful authority is protected, and the officer would have to show that the complaint was made with knowledge of its falsity. A complaint that states facts honestly and seeks an enquiry is not defamation, even if the enquiry finds nothing.

If the complaint concerns a refusal to register a case, the papers to assemble are the same as those for the magistrate's application, and the two can be prepared together. Bring the complaint, the acknowledgements and the medical papers to a consultation, or read criminal law and FIR quashing for the related remedies. The office can advise which track fits the facts.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422