14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Cyber Law

A Data Breach at a Company You Deal With

When a company that holds your personal data is breached, you are not helpless, but the remedies are spread across three instruments: the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, which imposes duties on the entity that holds your data; Section 43A of the Information Technology Act, 2000, which allows compensation for a failure to maintain reasonable security practices; and the ordinary law of contract and negligence, which applies to the relationship you had with the company. Which one to use depends on what you want: information, a correction, an apology or money.

Who owes you what under the DPDP Act

The Act applies to digital personal data and creates two roles. The person whose data it is, is the data principal. The entity that determines the purpose and means of processing is the data fiduciary. A company that collects your KYC, your medical history or your order history is a data fiduciary in relation to that data.

A data fiduciary must give you a notice describing the data it wants and the purpose, obtain your consent, use the data only for that purpose, keep it accurate, and implement reasonable security safeguards. Where a personal data breach occurs, the fiduciary must give notice of the breach to the Data Protection Board and to each affected data principal, in the form and manner the rules prescribe. That obligation is the one that matters most to an affected person, because a company that stays silent has breached a statutory duty.

Your rights as a data principal include the right to obtain a summary of the personal data being processed and the identities of the fiduciaries with whom it has been shared; the right to correction, completion and erasure; the right to a grievance redressal mechanism; and the right to nominate someone to exercise the rights in the event of death or incapacity. You also have duties, including not to file a false or frivolous complaint.

The penalties, and the reality of enforcement

The Act's Schedule sets out the penalties. A failure to take reasonable security safeguards to prevent a breach may attract a penalty of up to ₹250 crore, and a failure to notify a breach may attract a penalty of up to ₹200 crore, among other entries. Those figures are ceilings, and the Board takes into account the nature, gravity and duration of the breach, the gains made, and the mitigation. The penalties are paid to the government, not to the affected individual. There is no provision under the Act for the Board to award you compensation.

The framework is being brought into force through rules, so the practical position in any given month depends on what has been notified. An affected person who wants money rather than a penalty therefore looks to the other two remedies, while relying on the Act to establish the standard of care the company owed.

Section 43A of the IT Act

Section 43A provides that where a body corporate possessing, dealing or handling sensitive personal data fails to implement and maintain reasonable security practices and procedures, and that failure causes wrongful loss or wrongful gain, the body corporate is liable to pay compensation to the affected person. The reasonable security practices may be those prescribed by the government or those agreed by the parties.

The claim is made before the adjudicating officer under the IT Act, who has the powers of a civil court for summoning witnesses and requiring documents. This is the route that can produce compensation for an individual, and it is underused because complainants do not know it exists. The claim must identify the sensitive personal data, the failure, and the loss: money taken from an account, a loan sanctioned in your name, an insurance premium increased, or the cost of protecting yourself after the breach.

Section 72A of the IT Act punishes the disclosure of personal information in breach of a lawful contract without consent, with imprisonment or fine or both, which is a remedy against an insider rather than the company.

What to do in the first fortnight

  1. Preserve the evidence: the breach notice, the emails, the screenshots, the SMS alerts, the bank and card statements, and the dates of each.
  2. Write to the company's grievance officer or data protection officer, quoting the Act, demanding information about what was exposed, when, and to whom it has been notified, and asking for the steps taken to contain the harm.
  3. Change the passwords and, where the breached data is financial, ask the bank to put a watch on the account and to record the complaint in writing.
  4. If identity documents were exposed, file a complaint on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal, because it creates a record and can lead to a police investigation.
  5. Where the entity is regulated, complain to the sector regulator: the Reserve Bank for a bank or an NBFC, the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority for an insurer, the Securities and Exchange Board for a broker, and the telecom regulator for an operator. Sector regulators respond to documented complaints and can direct remediation.
  6. Keep a running account of the losses, with documents, because compensation is awarded on proof.

Reading the company's own policy

Most companies publish a privacy policy. A privacy policy is a representation, and a company that says it encrypts data, restricts access and notifies promptly, and then does none of those things, has made a statement on which a claim can rest. The policy is therefore evidence, and it should be downloaded and kept before it is quietly amended.

Standard form contracts often contain a clause excluding liability for data loss or limiting it to a small sum. Such clauses are read strictly, and a clause that purports to exclude liability for a statutory duty is of doubtful effect, but a consumer who has accepted the terms electronically should expect the point to be raised.

Other claims that arise from the same breach

Where the breach led to a fraudulent transaction, the bank's liability under the Reserve Bank's customer protection framework is a separate question, and the reporting timelines in that framework decide who bears the loss. Where the breach led to a loan being sanctioned in your name, the first step is a written dispute with the lender and a police complaint, and the second is a consumer complaint if the lender reports you to a credit bureau without resolving the fraud.

Where the breach led to a defamatory publication, or to the release of private material, a criminal complaint and a civil action for damages are available, and they are dealt with under the cyber law practice.

For a Kolkata claimant, an application under Section 43A goes to the adjudicating officer appointed under the IT Act, a consumer complaint goes to the District or State Commission at Kolkata, and a suit for damages goes to the City Civil Court at Kolkata or the Calcutta High Court's original side, depending on the value. Our data privacy practice and cyber law practice handle these claims, and consumer protection covers the sector where the loss was financial.

Common questions

Does the DPDP Act give me compensation for a breach?

No. The penalties under the Act are payable to the government. Compensation for your loss comes from Section 43A of the IT Act or from a civil or consumer claim, using the Act's obligations to show the standard of care that was breached.

Must the company tell me about the breach?

It must notify the Data Protection Board and the affected data principals in the manner the rules prescribe. If it has not, that failure is itself a breach, and it should be recorded in your complaint and in any regulator complaint.

What counts as sensitive personal data?

Under the rules made under the IT Act, it includes passwords, financial information, health data, sexual orientation, medical records and biometric information. The DPDP Act uses the broader category of personal data. Both matter, depending on the claim.

Can I complain if I only suspect my data was in a breach?

You can ask for information, and the company's silence is itself a matter to raise with the regulator. A claim for compensation is stronger once you can show the loss.

Act quickly, in writing, and keep everything. A data breach claim is a documentary claim, and the documents are easiest to collect in the first fortnight. To have your position assessed, contact the office; the consultation fee is published.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422