An internal committee under the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 conducts a disciplinary inquiry, not a trial: it must finish within ninety days, it must hear both sides, and it must keep the identities and the record confidential. A complainant can demand a hearing, interim relief during the inquiry, and a copy of the report; she cannot demand a criminal standard of proof, a cross-examination in the courtroom sense, or the punishment of her choice. The posh inquiry process is meant to be quick, and the committee's findings are recommendations to the employer.
The committee that must exist
Every employer with ten or more employees must constitute an Internal Committee at each workplace under Section 4 of the Act. The committee is chaired by a senior woman employee and must include not fewer than two members from among employees committed to the cause of women, and one member from outside the organisation with experience in social work or legal knowledge. Not less than one half of the members must be women. The external member is not a formality; committees that omit her have had their inquiries questioned.
Where the establishment has fewer than ten employees, or where the complaint relates to the unorganised sector, the Local Committee constituted by the district officer is the forum. A domestic worker can complain to the Local Committee, which is one of the Act's less used provisions and the only one open to her. Both committees must observe the same procedure.
The life of a complaint
- Filing. A written complaint within three months of the incident, extendable by a further three months for reasons recorded. Six copies of the complaint and the supporting documents are required.
- Assistance. The committee must help the complainant reduce an oral complaint to writing, and may arrange for her to be accompanied by a person of her choice at the hearings.
- Conciliation. At the complainant's request the committee may attempt conciliation, but money may not be part of a settlement. If conciliation fails or is refused, the inquiry proceeds.
- Inquiry. The committee examines the complaint, the reply, the witnesses and the documents, applying the principles of natural justice. It may call any person, and it may seek the employer's assistance for the production of records.
- Interim relief. During the inquiry the committee may recommend transfer of the complainant or the respondent, leave for the complainant, or a restraint on the respondent from reporting on or supervising her work.
- Report and action. The inquiry must be completed within ninety days and the report submitted within ten days of completion. The employer then acts on the recommendation within sixty days, and the complainant is entitled to a copy of the findings.
What a complainant can insist on
The right to be heard is the core. A committee that decides on the file without giving the complainant an opportunity to respond to the respondent's version has conducted no inquiry. She is entitled to know the substance of the reply, to produce her witnesses, and to have the documents she relies on taken on record.
She is also entitled to interim relief where the situation warrants it, and to protection from retaliation — Section 18 requires the employer to ensure that no employee is victimised for having made a complaint. Where the respondent is her supervisor, a change of reporting line is the least that the committee should consider. Confidentiality under Section 16 protects her identity, and a breach by a committee member or an employer attracts a penalty.
What a committee will not do
The inquiry is not a criminal trial. The standard is preponderance of probabilities, not proof beyond reasonable doubt, and the committee does not have to produce a witness for every element. Equally, the respondent is not entitled to a confrontation with the complainant; the Act deliberately keeps the two apart where the committee considers it necessary, and a demand for direct cross-examination is often refused.
- The committee cannot award compensation to itself; it recommends, and the employer acts. Where the recommendation is not implemented, the remedy is a complaint to the district officer and, in a public establishment, to the writ court.
- It cannot decide title, property or money claims between the parties.
- It cannot impose a criminal punishment; prosecution, where the conduct also constitutes an offence, is separate and goes through the police and the magistrate.
- It cannot ignore the respondent's right to be heard either. An inquiry that denies him a hearing is as vulnerable as one that denies her.
The false complaint provision, used carefully
Section 14 provides for action against a woman who makes a complaint that she knows to be false or malicious. The provision is narrow on purpose: a complaint that is not proved is not thereby false, and the Act requires a finding that the allegation was made with knowledge of its falsity. Committees that treat an unproved complaint as a malicious one do so at the risk of the inquiry being set aside, and the employer risks a claim from the complainant.
Confidentiality, and what it actually covers
Section 16 prohibits publication of the identity of the complainant, the respondent, the witnesses, and the contents of the complaint and the inquiry. The prohibition is on publication, not on disclosure to those who must act on the report — the employer's disciplinary authority, and the parties themselves, are within the circle. A respondent who publishes the complaint on a social platform commits a breach, and so does an employer who circulates the report in the office.
Where the process breaks down
The recurring failures are structural. A committee without the external member, or with an internal member who is the respondent's subordinate, produces an inquiry that cannot survive scrutiny. A committee that does not record its reasons, or that finishes in a week without examining witnesses, produces a report the employer cannot act on. An employer that constitutes the committee but never meets, or that lets the ninety days pass without explanation, exposes itself to a complaint before the district officer and to a writ where it is a public body.
For the individual employee the practical route after a defective inquiry is a representation to the district officer, who can inquire into the employer's compliance, and then a writ petition before the Calcutta High Court where the employer is a public authority or a body discharging a public function. Where the employer is a private company, the civil court is the forum for a claim in damages, and the criminal complaint under the penal law runs separately. Our cyber harassment practice handles the online dimension of such complaints, the labour and employment team appears in the connected proceedings, and the training sessions that employers are required to run are drawn up with the compliance team.
Can the complainant bring a lawyer to the hearing?
The Act allows her to be accompanied by a person of her choice, and committees generally permit an advocate to accompany a party as a support person rather than to conduct the case. The committee controls its procedure and may limit legal argument.
Is there an appeal against the committee's finding?
For a private employee the Act creates no general appeal. The finding is a recommendation to the employer, and the challenge is to the employer's action or to the committee's procedure, usually by writ where a public element exists. Government servants have the service rules and the tribunal.
How long can the inquiry take?
Ninety days from the date of the complaint for the inquiry, ten days to submit the report, and sixty days for the employer to act. Extensions are not provided for in the Act, though committees sometimes record reasons for a short delay.
Can a man file a complaint?
The Act protects women, and the Internal Committee is constituted for complaints of sexual harassment of women. An employee of any gender facing harassment at work has recourse under the service rules, the penal law, and in some organisations an internal policy that is broader than the Act.
The strongest protection either side has is a record. Complaints, replies, witness statements and the committee's reasoning should all be in writing and dated, because the file is what a court will see if the process is challenged.