Advance tax is payable in four instalments during the year, and interest is charged in two situations: where an instalment is short, and where the total paid by the end of the year falls below the required proportion. The first is dealt with by the provision on instalment defaults, the second by the provision on short payment. Advance tax interest 234b 234c is therefore two computations on the same set of facts, and both can apply in the same year.
The obligation begins only where the tax liability for the year is ten thousand rupees or more. Below that, no instalment is due. Above it, the schedule runs from June, and each date has its own percentage.
The four dates
- Fifteen per cent of the estimated liability by 15 June.
- Forty-five per cent by 15 September.
- Seventy-five per cent by 15 December.
- One hundred per cent by 15 March.
The percentages are cumulative, not incremental. A taxpayer who pays fifteen per cent in June and nothing in September has paid fifteen per cent against a requirement of forty-five, and the shortfall of thirty per cent attracts interest. The estimate is of the year's liability, and it is revised as the year progresses.
A taxpayer under the presumptive provisions pays the whole amount by 15 March, because the income is not computed in the ordinary way and there are no quarterly estimates to make. That concession is in the statute and it is often missed.
The instalment interest
Where an instalment is short, interest is charged at one per cent per month for three months on the shortfall, for each of the first three instalments. For the March instalment, the interest is charged at one per cent for one month. The rationale is that the shortfall existed for the period until the next instalment was due.
The computation is done instalment by instalment: the tax paid up to each date is compared with the cumulative requirement, and the difference attracts the interest for the prescribed number of months. A taxpayer who paid everything late but paid in full by March still has an instalment default for June, September and December.
The interest is computed by the department in the assessment, and it is shown in the intimation or the assessment order. A taxpayer who disagrees with the computation can ask for the working, and in most cases the disagreement is about the estimate of the year's income at each date, not about the arithmetic.
The short-payment interest
Where the advance tax paid is less than ninety per cent of the assessed tax, interest is charged at one per cent per month from the first day of the assessment year to the date on which the tax is determined. The assessed tax is the tax on the total income, reduced by the tax deducted at source and the tax collected at source, and by the reliefs the statute allows.
An assessment that adds income produces a shortfall for this purpose even where the taxpayer paid what he estimated, because the assessed tax is higher than the estimate. That is the ordinary consequence of an addition, and it is why the interest is often the largest single item in an assessment order.
The computation runs to the date of determination, which is the date of the assessment order, and then the interest stops and the demand is payable. Where the assessment is set aside and made again, the computation is reworked from the original date.
The relief for income that arrives late
The instalment interest is not charged where the shortfall arises from capital gains, from casual income such as a lottery or a prize, or from the income of a business or profession that the taxpayer could not have estimated before the date of the instalment, provided the tax on that income is paid in the remaining instalments.
The relief exists because these receipts are inherently unpredictable. A person who sells a flat in February cannot have paid advance tax on the gain in June. The relief requires the tax to be paid by the last instalment, and a taxpayer who pays in the following July has lost the protection.
The same reasoning applies, to a lesser extent, to the short-payment interest, where the shortfall is attributable to such income and the tax was paid before the end of the year. The provision has been read to give relief where the taxpayer could not have anticipated the income, and the burden of showing that is on him.
An example
A consultant estimates a total income of thirty lakh for the year, with a tax liability of about ₹5,00,000, and has tax deducted at source of ₹50,000, so the advance tax required is ₹4,50,000. He pays nothing until March, when he pays the whole amount.
The June requirement was ₹67,500 and he paid nil, so the shortfall of ₹67,500 attracts one per cent for three months. The September requirement was ₹2,02,500, and the shortfall attracts one per cent for three months. The December requirement was ₹3,37,500, again three months. The March instalment is met, so no shortfall there. The instalment interest is a little over eighteen thousand rupees, which is the price of holding the money for a year.
If his assessment later adds ₹2,00,000 of income, the assessed tax is higher, and the short-payment interest is computed on the difference from the first day of the assessment year. That is the larger exposure, and it is the reason a conservative estimate is cheaper than an optimistic one.
How to answer a computation you dispute
Ask for the computation sheet, which shows the tax paid, the assessed tax and the shortfall for each period. The disputes that succeed are usually about a credit that was not given, about a relief that was available, or about a double computation of interest where the assessment was revised.
Where a credit for tax deducted is missing, the certificate and the return of the deductor are the documents. Where the relief for capital gains is denied, the date of the transfer and the payment of the tax in the last instalment are the documents.
A review of the advance tax working during the year is worth more than the argument after the assessment, because the estimate is the only variable the taxpayer controls. A written submission at the assessment stage, with the computation, is how the credit and the relief are placed on record.
Where the assessment order is wrong on the interest, the appeal lies to the Commissioner (Appeals) and then to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, whose Kolkata bench hears such appeals. A writ petition is confined to cases where the interest is charged without jurisdiction.
Common questions
Is advance tax payable if my liability is nine thousand rupees?
No. The obligation applies where the tax liability for the year is ten thousand rupees or more. A person below that threshold pays the tax with the return, and no instalment interest arises.
Can I revise my estimate during the year?
Yes, and the instalments are computed on the revised estimate as at each date. A revised estimate that reduces the payment already made does not attract a refund of the advance tax; the excess is adjusted against the final liability.
Does tax deducted at source reduce the advance tax?
Yes. The instalments are computed on the tax liability reduced by the tax deducted or collected at source, and the assessed tax for the short-payment interest is likewise reduced. A taxpayer whose entire income is subject to deduction at source has no advance tax obligation.
Can both interest provisions apply in the same year?
Yes. An instalment default and a short payment at the end of the year are separate failures, and both computations can produce interest. The relief for late-received income is the main thing that removes one or both.
Advance tax is a cash-flow discipline with an interest penalty attached. Estimate high rather than low, pay by the four dates, and keep the working. The interest is small when the estimate is close, and it is the largest line in the order when it is not.