14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

Affidavit versus a notarised document: the difference

An affidavit is a statement of facts sworn by the person making it, and a notarised document is any document on which a notary has certified that it was executed or signed before him. The short answer to affidavit vs notarised document is that the affidavit speaks to the truth of what is said, while notarisation speaks only to the fact that a signature was made. Neither one registers a deed, and neither transfers property.

Two different acts, two different statutes

An affidavit is taken under the law relating to oaths and affirmations, and it is sworn before a person authorised to administer an oath — a notary, an oath commissioner, a judicial magistrate, or an officer of the court designated for the purpose. Notarisation is done under the Notaries Act, 1952 by a notary appointed by the government, whose functions include attesting and authenticating documents, administering oaths, and certifying copies of documents.

The overlap is real but limited. A notary may administer an oath when taking an affidavit, and the same person may therefore do both. What changes the legal character of the paper is not the seal but the form: an affidavit has a deponent, a statement in the first person, a verification clause, and a jurat recording that it was sworn on a date before a named authority. A notarised document need have none of that.

What an affidavit is actually for

An affidavit is sworn evidence. Where a statute or a court rule permits a fact to be proved by affidavit, the affidavit is the evidence and the deponent may be cross-examined on it. Courts routinely direct that examination-in-chief be given by affidavit, and applications for interim relief, condonation of delay, and amendment of pleadings are all supported by affidavits.

  • Declarations for a name change, a change of date of birth, or a correction of a record.
  • Supporting an application to a court, tribunal or authority — an injunction, a caveat, a condonation application.
  • Loss of a document, where a declaration is needed before a duplicate is issued.
  • Evidence in chief in a civil trial, where the court has ordered affidavit evidence.
  • Statements required by a bank, a passport office or a registrar about residence, relationship or custody of documents.

The discipline that goes with it is that a false statement in an affidavit is an offence. The deponent can be prosecuted for giving false evidence, and the court can also proceed for contempt where the affidavit is filed in judicial proceedings. A loose declaration signed without reading is therefore not a harmless formality.

What notarisation proves, and what it does not

A notary's attestation proves that the person named appeared before him, was identified, and signed the document in his presence, and that the notary explained the contents where the rules require it. It is evidence of execution. It is not evidence that the contents are true, that the transaction is lawful, that the consideration was paid, or that the document creates a valid title.

That is why a notarised agreement to sell does not convey property, a notarised power of attorney executed abroad is not the same as one executed and authenticated in the manner the law requires for registration, and a notarised gift deed does not pass title. Notarisation is a step in the execution of a document; it is not a substitute for the formality the law attaches to the transaction.

The registration confusion, which causes the real losses

Section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908 makes registration compulsory for instruments of gift of immovable property, for other non-testamentary instruments that create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish a right, title or interest in immovable property of the value of one hundred rupees and upwards, for leases of immovable property for a term exceeding one year, and for certain other classes. A sale deed, a gift deed, a partition deed, a settlement, and a lease beyond a year all fall within it.

An unregistered instrument that the Act requires to be registered does not affect the property, and is not admissible in evidence for the purpose of proving the transaction. A notary's seal changes nothing about that. Families discover the point years later, when a partition arrangement recorded on notarised paper is produced in a suit and the court refuses to act on it as a partition. The remedy at that stage is a registered deed, executed now, and it requires the cooperation of every party — which is precisely what is not available by then.

The same rule applies to a will, with an important distinction: a will does not require registration to be valid, and probate does not depend on it. Registration of a will is optional and adds a record of its existence, not validity.

Where each is used in Kolkata practice

Affidavits are sworn before the oath commissioners attached to the Calcutta High Court, before notaries in the city, and before judicial magistrates where a court requires it. The stamp paper value is prescribed by the state and is small; the affidavit is typed on that paper, signed on every page, and the jurat is completed by the authority in his own hand. Standard wording for the common declarations is on the legal formats page. A defective jurat — an undated attestation, a signature without the authority's endorsement — is the commonest reason a filed affidavit is returned.

Notarisation is used for attestation of copies, for agreements that the parties want authenticated even though registration is not legally required, for affidavits of the kind described above, and for documents executed abroad which then need apostille or consular authentication before an Indian authority will act on them. For a power of attorney executed outside India and used for a property transaction in West Bengal, the document must be executed and authenticated in the manner the law requires for registration — notarisation alone is not enough, and the sub-registrar will say so at the counter.

What neither can fix

Neither an affidavit nor a notarisation can cure a defect in title, prove payment of consideration, or bind a person who did not sign. A notary has no power to decide a dispute or to declare who owns property; a document that records his "opinion" on ownership is worth nothing. Nor can an affidavit contradict a registered deed: where the deed says one thing and the affidavit another, the deed governs, and the affidavit may itself become evidence of an attempt to mislead.

The practical lesson is to match the formality to the transaction. A statement of fact needs an affidavit. A document that is to be relied on abroad, or whose execution may later be denied, benefits from notarisation. A transaction in immovable property needs a registered instrument, stamped at the rate applicable in West Bengal on the market value, and executed before the sub-registrar with the parties present for biometric authentication. Our property registration practice handles the deed, the stamping and the appointment; the affidavit drafting service handles the sworn papers that accompany it.

Is a notarised agreement to sell enforceable?

It can be the basis of a suit for specific performance, because an agreement to sell creates a right that equity may enforce, but it does not transfer ownership. Possession and title pass only on a registered sale deed, and the agreement's value as evidence depends on its terms, not on the notary's seal.

Can a notarised will be probated?

Yes, because a will needs no registration. Probate requires proof of execution and attestation as the Succession Act prescribes, and a notarised will is proved in the same way as an unregistered one — by the attesting witnesses or by the evidence the court accepts when they are unavailable.

Can an affidavit be used as evidence in a criminal case?

Not as substantive evidence. A witness must depose in court, and an affidavit is generally confined to the purposes the statute or the court permits. It can still be used to contradiction or to support an application, but it does not replace testimony.

Does a notary have to read the document to me?

The notary must satisfy himself of the executant's identity and, where the rules require, explain the contents. That duty does not make him a legal adviser, and a party who signs without reading cannot later rely on the notary's silence as a defence.

Most of the trouble in this area comes from treating a seal as a substitute for a formality. Before signing anything, ask which formality the transaction actually needs — an oath, an attestation, or a registration — and the answer will usually decide the paper.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422