When a non-resident sells immovable property in India, the buyer has to deduct tax at source on the entire sale consideration and not merely on the capital gain, because the deduction provisions for payments to non-residents operate on the gross amount. That is why an nri property sale tds position is usually ruinous if left to the buyer's default computation: the seller ends up with far more tax deducted than the gain justifies, and then waits a year for a refund. The remedy, available before the sale, is a certificate from the assessing officer permitting deduction at a lower rate on the estimated gain.
Why the whole price is taxed at source
The provision that governs payments to non-residents requires deduction at the rates in force on the amount payable, and the department's position is that the amount payable is the consideration, not the profit. The buyer who pays the entire price without deduction is treated as an assessee in default and is liable for the tax, interest and penalty, which is why no careful buyer will agree to skip the deduction.
The rate is the rate applicable to the income in the seller's hands — the capital gains rate for a long-term transfer, and the short-term rate where the property was held for a shorter period — plus surcharge and cess. The rates for capital gains on property changed recently, and the position for a non-resident is not identical to that for a resident in every respect, so the rate in force on the date of transfer has to be checked rather than assumed.
The lower deduction certificate
The seller applies to the assessing officer in the prescribed form for a certificate permitting the buyer to deduct at a lower rate, computed on the estimated capital gain rather than the sale price. The application sets out the cost of acquisition, the improvements, the expenses of transfer, the indexed cost where indexation is available, and the estimated gain. The officer issues a certificate with a specified rate and a validity period, and the buyer deducts accordingly.
The certificate should be applied for well before the sale deed is executed, because the buyer will not complete the transaction without it once the price is significant. The application takes weeks, and a certificate that arrives after the deed is useless for that transfer.
- Documents: the purchase deed, the improvement bills, the sale agreement, the computation of the gain, the PAN, and the tax residency certificate where the treaty is invoked.
- Treaty relief: where a tax treaty gives the seller a better position, the certificate application should invoke it and attach the residency certificate and the form the treaty requires.
- Validity: the certificate covers the transaction and the period it states; a sale completed outside that period needs a fresh certificate.
The forms the buyer files
For a payment to a non-resident, the buyer deducts tax and files the return for tax deducted at source in the form prescribed for non-resident payments, and issues the certificate of deduction to the seller. The seller's credit appears in the annual tax statement, and the credit is what supports the refund claim.
For the remittance of the sale proceeds abroad, the bank requires the forms that certify the tax position: a declaration of the remittance, a certificate from a chartered accountant in the prescribed form, and, where the remittance is large or the case falls in a specified category, an undertaking. The bank will not remit without them.
Repatriation, and its ceiling
The foreign exchange regulations permit a non-resident to repatriate the sale proceeds of immovable property held in India, subject to a ceiling per financial year and to conditions about how many properties may be repatriated and how the property was acquired. The ceiling is currently in the region of one million dollars per financial year for the sale proceeds of immovable property, and the conditions differ for property acquired out of funds brought into India and property acquired otherwise. The figures are revised by the regulator, so the position should be confirmed with the bank before the sale is timed.
The sale proceeds are credited to the non-resident's account in India, and the repatriation is made from that account with the bank's certification. Where the amount exceeds the ceiling, the excess can be held in India and repatriated over subsequent years, and the investment options for the balance are governed by the foreign exchange rules rather than by the tax law.
The refund that usually follows
Because the deduction is on the gross consideration, the tax paid at source normally exceeds the tax on the gain. The seller files a return in India for the year of transfer, claims the credit, and receives a refund. The return has to be filed within the time allowed for a non-resident, and the refund is processed after the assessment; a seller who does not file simply leaves the money with the department.
The refund claim needs the computation, the deduction certificates, the bank statements, the purchase deed and the proof of the transfer expenses. Where the property was held for a long period, the indexed cost and the improvement costs are the figures the officer will examine, and the documents should be assembled at the time of sale rather than at the time of filing.
What goes wrong
The most expensive error is a sale completed without the lower deduction certificate, which locks the seller out of his money for a year or more. The second is a buyer who deducts at the wrong rate because he applied the resident rate, which produces a short deduction and a demand on the buyer. The third is a certificate obtained on a computation that omits the improvements or the transfer expenses, which produces a higher rate than necessary. The fourth is a remittance attempted before the tax is paid and the forms are in place, which the bank will refuse.
There is also the treaty question. A seller who is resident in a treaty country may be entitled to a different treatment of the gain, and the certificate application should raise it at the outset. Raising it after the deduction has been made converts an argument into a refund claim.
Where the file is handled
The certificate application is made to the assessing officer having jurisdiction over the non-resident's affairs, which for many NRI sellers is the international taxation ward of the Kolkata charge, and the buyer's deduction and return are handled in the buyer's own ward. The property documents come from the sub-registrar's records, and the property registration practice handles the deed and the searches. The computation and the certificate application are prepared with the compliance team, and a deduction made at the wrong rate is challenged as set out for writ and appellate work. The legal formats page has the undertaking and declaration formats the banks ask for.
Can the buyer avoid deduction if the seller gives an indemnity?
No. A private indemnity does not displace the statutory duty, and a buyer who relies on it remains liable as an assessee in default. The certificate from the officer is the only lawful way to reduce the deduction.
Is indexation available to a non-resident?
The position has changed with the recent amendments and differs between property acquired before and after the cut-off date, and between residents and non-residents in some respects. The computation should be made on the law in force for the year of transfer, and the certificate application should state the basis adopted.
How long does the certificate take?
Several weeks in the ordinary course, and longer where the officer seeks further documents. Applications made a month before the intended sale are the ones that are refused for want of time.
Can the sale proceeds be repatriated in one go?
Only up to the ceiling for the financial year. The balance remains in the Indian account and can be repatriated in later years, subject to the conditions the exchange regulations impose.
The sequence matters more than anything else: certificate first, deed second, deduction third, remittance last. A seller who follows that order keeps the tax to the gain and the money moving.