14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Criminal Law

Arrest rights: grounds, family intimation and remand

An arrest is not a gap in the law. The person arrested must be told the grounds of his arrest, must be allowed to inform a relative or a friend, must be produced before a magistrate within twenty-four hours excluding travel time, and must be medically examined. Those four safeguards, together with the right to consult a lawyer, are the core of arrest rights india recognises, and they are enforceable against the police station today, not merely at the trial.

In practice the first twenty-four hours decide the shape of the case. If the family knows where the person is, if a lawyer reaches the station, and if the grounds are recorded, the remand hearing becomes an argument about custody rather than an argument about whether the arrest happened at all.

The grounds must be given, and given in writing

The arresting officer must communicate the grounds of arrest to the person arrested. The Sanhita requires the grounds to be furnished in writing, and the requirement is not satisfied by a verbal statement that a case has been registered. A written ground of arrest is what allows the arrested person to apply for bail on the correct facts, and its absence is a defect the magistrate will notice.

The police also have a discretion to arrest at all. For offences punishable with less than seven years, the officer must ordinarily issue a notice of appearance rather than arrest, and the notice is a document the person is entitled to receive. Where the offence is punishable with more than seven years, or where the officer records reasons for believing that arrest is necessary, the arrest may follow.

Section 35 of the Sanhita carries the notice-of-appearance provision, and Section 47 the requirement of grounds. Where an arrest is made without either, the person's lawyer should record the objection at the station and again at the remand hearing, because the illegality of the arrest affects the legality of the custody that follows.

Family intimation, and the record of it

The arrested person is entitled to have a relative or a friend informed of his arrest and place of detention. The officer must record the name and address of the person informed, and the entry must be made in the register. Section 48 of the Sanhita carries the obligation, and it is one of the safeguards that the Supreme Court laid down in the arrest guidelines that came out of a Calcutta case in the 1990s and have been applied ever since.

Where the family is not informed, the consequences are practical rather than theoretical. Nobody arranges a lawyer, nobody brings the medical papers, and the first production before the magistrate happens with the person unrepresented. That is why the first call a family makes after learning of an arrest should be to the police station, to confirm the place of detention, the offence and the time of arrest, and the second to a lawyer.

Keep a written record of the call: the time, the officer spoken to, and what was said. If the station refuses to confirm, a letter to the officer in charge, copied to the deputy commissioner, creates a dated record that the family tried.

The twenty-four hour rule and the first production

The arrested person must be produced before a magistrate within twenty-four hours of the arrest, excluding the time taken for the journey. Section 58 of the Sanhita states the rule. The magistrate before whom the person is produced is the one with jurisdiction over the case — in Kolkata, for city offences, the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate's court at Bankshall, and for others the magistrate designated for the purpose.

At the first production the magistrate considers whether the arrest was lawful, whether the person should be released on bail or kept in custody, and whether the police need remand for further investigation. The magistrate can remand to police custody for a limited period, and thereafter to judicial custody. The remand is not a formality: the police must show what they have done and why custody is needed, and the person's lawyer can oppose it.

Where the police fail to produce the person within the period, the detention becomes unlawful, and the remedy is a habeas corpus petition before the Calcutta High Court or an application to the magistrate. The petition is heard urgently, and it is the remedy of choice where the place of detention is not even known.

What the lawyer does in the first twenty-four hours

  1. Confirm the police station, the offence, the time of arrest and the place of detention, and record the answers.
  2. Meet the person at the station or at the court lock-up, take instructions, and check the grounds of arrest and the medical examination.
  3. Apply for bail before the magistrate at the first production, with the case diary and the grounds of arrest in hand.
  4. Oppose police remand where the investigation does not justify it, and ask for judicial custody with the medical treatment the person needs.
  5. Inform the family of the next date, and collect the documents for the bail application.

The first production is a hearing, and it is short. A lawyer who arrives with the grounds of arrest, the identity papers and a draft bail application does more in ten minutes than one who arrives to ask for time.

Medical examination and the record of injuries

The arrested person must be examined by a medical officer, and the examination record must note any injuries and the person's state of health. Where the person alleges ill-treatment, the record is the best evidence, and a request for a fresh examination should be made at once, before the injuries fade. The medical report also decides whether the person can be kept in custody at all, and whether he needs hospital treatment.

Refusal of medical examination, or a report that records nothing, is a matter to be raised at the remand hearing and, if necessary, in a complaint against the officer. Section 53 of the Sanhita provides for the examination of the arrested person, and the rules require the report to be furnished to the person or his lawyer.

Anticipatory bail, where the arrest has not yet happened

Where a person learns that a case has been registered and fears arrest, the remedy is an application for anticipatory bail before the sessions court or the Calcutta High Court. The application sets out the facts, the delay in the complaint, the civil nature of the dispute where that is the defence, and the willingness to cooperate with the investigation. An order of anticipatory bail can be conditioned on joining the investigation, and a breach of the condition is a ground for cancellation.

Anticipatory bail is not available in every offence, and the courts have taken a restrictive view in cases of economic offence, organised crime and offences against women and children. The application should be filed early, with the documents, because a person who learns of the case on the day of arrest has already lost the advantage.

Our page on anticipatory bail sets out the material to file, and criminal law covers the trial that follows.

Common questions

Must the police allow a lawyer to meet the arrested person?

Yes. The right to consult a lawyer is part of the constitutional protection, and a meeting at the police station is permitted, though it may be in the presence of an officer. Denial of access is a matter to record in writing and to raise before the magistrate.

Can a person be arrested at night?

Yes, but the officer must record the reasons, and where the person is a woman, the arrest and the search must follow the specific safeguards, including the presence of a woman officer and the prohibition on arrest after sunset and before sunrise except with special permission in writing.

How long can police custody last?

Police custody remand is granted in instalments and is subject to the statutory ceiling, after which custody becomes judicial. The magistrate must apply his mind at each hearing, and a routine remand order without reasons is open to challenge.

What if the family cannot find out where the person is?

This is exactly what the family intimation rule is meant to prevent. If the station will not disclose the place of detention, a habeas corpus petition before the Calcutta High Court is the fastest remedy, and a complaint to the deputy commissioner and the police control room should be made the same day.

If an arrest has just happened, the hour matters more than the argument. Telephone the office, or have someone bring the case papers to the consultation, and if the person is being produced at Bankshall the same day, come straight to the court with the FIR copy.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422