14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Cyber Law

Bank liability for an unauthorised online transaction

The bank bears the loss, if you report within three working days of receiving the transaction alert. The Reserve Bank's limited liability framework for unauthorised electronic banking transactions allocates the loss between the customer and the bank according to the cause of the fraud and the speed of the report, and in the ordinary case of a fraud caused by a security breach at the bank, the customer's liability is nil.

The framework in outline

The framework applies to unauthorised electronic banking transactions — a transfer, a card transaction or a withdrawal that the customer did not authorise. It draws a distinction between a fraud caused by a deficiency at the bank or in the bank's system and one caused by the customer's own negligence, such as sharing a password, a PIN or a one-time password.

The reporting period is central. The framework fixes a period of three working days from the date of receiving the communication from the bank about the unauthorised transaction, within which the customer must report. Where the unauthorised transaction is due to the bank's negligence and the customer reports within three working days, the customer's liability is zero. Where the report is delayed beyond that but within the longer window the framework provides, the liability is limited, and beyond that the customer's liability depends on the bank's policy approved by its board.

Where the fraud arises from the customer's negligence, the customer bears the loss until the report, and the bank's liability begins from the time of the report. The bank cannot avoid liability after the report by pointing to its own further delay.

What the bank must do

The framework imposes obligations on the bank that are useful to the customer's case:

  • Send a transaction alert by short message and email for every electronic transaction, so that the customer knows promptly.
  • Provide a facility to report an unauthorised transaction by a channel available twenty-four hours, including a phone number and a written mode.
  • Acknowledge the report and give the customer a complaint or reference number, with a timeline for resolution.
  • Credit the amount of the unauthorised transaction to the customer's account within a period the framework fixes, where the customer's liability is nil.
  • Not insist on a police complaint as a precondition for reversing a transaction where the customer's liability is nil, though the bank may ask for a complaint where the framework allows it.

Where the bank fails to credit the amount despite a zero-liability finding, the customer has a complaint against the bank for deficiency in service, and the banking ombudsman is the natural first forum.

What the customer must do

The sequence is short and mechanical:

  1. Report the moment the alert is seen. Do not wait for the bank to call, and do not wait for the transaction to be reversed on its own.
  2. Use the phone banking channel and follow up in writing, by email, so that the report is documented with a time stamp.
  3. Get the complaint number. Ask for it if it is not given.
  4. File a complaint on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal, which generates a reference and routes the complaint to the police, and inform the bank of the reference number.
  5. Write to the bank's nodal officer for the framework within the reporting period, so that the report is on record in the form the framework contemplates.
  6. Freeze the card or the account facility to stop further debits, and change the credentials.

Do not contact the fraudster. Do not follow a "refund" link sent by the person who made the call. Do not share the OTP that a caller asks for in order to "reverse" the transaction — that is the second half of the fraud.

What counts as the customer's negligence

The banks' most common defence is that the customer was negligent. The situations accepted by the framework and the banking ombudsman include sharing a password, a PIN or an OTP voluntarily, and leaving the card or the credentials in a place where they could be used without reasonable care. Whether the customer was negligent is a finding on the facts, and it is made by the bank in the first instance and by the ombudsman or the consumer commission on complaint.

What does not amount to negligence: using the card at a merchant, using a public network, responding to a phishing call without disclosing credentials, or a compromise of the bank's own system or the card network. A bank that loses the argument that the customer was negligent must bear the loss.

The burden of establishing negligence lies on the bank, and a bank that simply asserts that the customer must have shared the OTP without any material will not succeed.

Report first, investigate afterwards. The framework turns on the date of the report, and every day of delay moves the loss towards the customer.

The other remedies

The banking ombudsman hears complaints about the reversal of an unauthorised transaction, and the complaint can be filed after the bank's own grievance machinery has been given the opportunity to respond. The ombudsman route is free and does not require an advocate.

The consumer commission can hear a complaint about the bank's failure to credit an amount that the framework requires it to credit, since that is a deficiency in service. And where the fraud itself is the subject of investigation, the police complaint under the cybercrime portal runs in parallel; the criminal case and the bank's liability are separate questions.

Common questions

Does the bank need a police complaint before refunding?

Not for a zero-liability case under the framework. The bank may ask for a complaint, and the customer should file one anyway, but the reversal is not conditional on the police acting.

What if the money has already been withdrawn by the fraudster?

The customer's claim is against the bank under the framework, and the bank's recovery from the fraudster is the bank's problem. The credit to the customer does not depend on the recovery.

Is a debit card fraud different from a net banking fraud?

The framework covers both, and the reporting periods are the same. The alert obligations differ slightly, since the card networks have their own rules on liability for counterfeit transactions.

Report within the period, keep the complaint number, and escalate through the ombudsman if the bank does not act. Keep the complaint number and the bank's acknowledgement together, because the ombudsman will ask for both, and take advice early where the bank disputes that the report was made in time. Our cyber fraud practice handles the bank and the police sides of these complaints, banking and finance covers the larger disputes, and consumer protection covers the deficiency complaint before the commission.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422