14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Tax & GST

Capital gains on property: indexation and exemptions

A flat sold for more than it cost produces a capital gain, and the tax depends on three things: how long it was held, what the cost is taken to be, and whether the gain is reinvested. Capital gains property indexation is the adjustment of the cost for inflation, and it is the single largest variable in the computation for a property held for years.

The structure has been changed by recent amendments, and a sale today may be governed by a different rate and a different indexation rule from a sale three years ago. The rules below describe the framework, and the position for the year of transfer should be confirmed before the return is filed.

Long term and short term

Immovable property held for more than twenty-four months is a long-term capital asset. Property held for twenty-four months or less produces a short-term gain, taxed at the slab rate applicable to the seller, with no indexation and no exemption under the reinvestment provisions.

The holding period runs from the date of acquisition to the date of transfer, and the date of acquisition is the date on the registered deed, not the date of possession or of the agreement. Where the property was inherited, the holding period includes the period for which the previous owner held it, and the cost is the previous owner's cost.

Where the property was acquired under a gift or a will, the same principle applies, and the previous owner's cost and holding period are substituted. A family that has held a plot since the 1980s has a long-term asset with a cost base that needs careful reconstruction.

The cost, and the index

For a long-term asset, the cost of acquisition is adjusted by the cost inflation index. The index is notified every year, and the adjustment multiplies the cost by the index for the year of transfer and divides it by the index for the year of acquisition.

Where the property was acquired before the base year, the assessee may take the fair market value as on the first day of the base year, or the actual cost, whichever is higher, as the cost. The base year moved to 2001-02 some years ago, and a valuation as on 1 April 2001 from a registered valuer is the document that supports the higher figure.

Where the cost includes stamp duty, registration charges and the broker's fee, those are added to the cost. Where the property was constructed, the construction cost is added, and where it was improved, the improvement cost is added with its own indexation. Each item has its own year and its own index.

The transfer expenses, such as the brokerage on sale and the legal fees, are deducted from the sale consideration. The result is the long-term capital gain, and the tax is charged on it at the rate applicable for the year.

What the 2024 amendments changed

For transfers on or after the date the amendments took effect in 2024, the long-term gain on immovable property is taxed at a flat rate without indexation, and the indexation adjustment was withdrawn for those transfers. For a resident individual or a Hindu undivided family selling property acquired before that date, an option was provided to compute the gain with indexation at the older rate, and the option is exercised in the return.

The option is not available in every case, and the conditions attached to it, and the comparison it requires, should be worked through for the particular sale. In many cases the option is valuable for a property held since the 1990s and worthless for one bought in 2019.

The practical consequence is that the computation has to be done twice, under both regimes, and the return has to state which is adopted. A computation done once, on the older basis, is a return that will be adjusted.

The exemptions

The residential house. A long-term gain on any property can be exempted if the seller purchases a residential house within one year before or two years after the transfer, or constructs one within three years. The exemption is in proportion to the amount invested, and the statute caps the investment it will recognise at ten crore rupees.

Bonds. A long-term gain on land or building can be invested in the specified bonds of the notified infrastructure agencies within six months of the transfer, with a cap on the amount that qualifies. The bonds carry a lock-in, and the exemption is withdrawn if they are sold before it ends.

Other assets. A long-term gain on any asset other than a residential house can be exempted by investing in a residential house, in proportion to the amount invested, with the same time limits and a similar cap.

Where the seller cannot complete the purchase before the return is due, the amount can be deposited in the capital gains account scheme with a bank, and the deposit is treated as the investment for the year. The deposit must be made before the due date of the return, and the withdrawal from the account has to be used for the purchase within the time allowed.

Where the tax enters the transaction

The buyer deducts tax at source on the consideration where it is fifty lakh rupees or more, at the rate the statute prescribes, and issues a certificate. The seller claims the credit in the return, and the deduction is not a tax on the seller's gain; it is an advance.

Where the sale is to a non-resident or by a non-resident, the withholding rules are different and the clearance requirements apply. A transaction with a non-resident party needs advice before the deed is signed, because the withholding can exceed the gain.

The stamp duty valuation and the sale consideration should match. Where the consideration is below the stamp duty value by more than the tolerance the statute allows, the difference is treated as income in the buyer's or the seller's hands depending on the transaction, and the provision has been amended more than once.

The records that decide the gain

  • The original purchase deed, with the stamp duty and registration receipts.
  • Evidence of any improvement: the contractor's bills, the municipal approvals, the photographs.
  • The valuation as on the base year date, from a registered valuer, where the property is old.
  • The sale deed and the brokerage invoice.
  • The deposit receipt for the capital gains account, or the purchase deed of the new house.
  • For an inherited property, the chain of title and the previous owner's deed.

A registered deed and a complete registration file is what makes the cost base provable, and a title check that establishes the chain is what supports the inherited cost. A review of the computation before filing catches the double computation and the missed improvement cost.

Common questions

Is indexation still available on property?

For transfers after the 2024 amendments, indexation has been withdrawn and the gain is taxed at a flat rate, with an option for resident individuals and Hindu undivided families to compute with indexation for property acquired before the cut-off date. The option has conditions, and the computation should be done both ways.

What if I sell before twenty-four months?

The gain is short-term, taxed at the slab rate, and the reinvestment exemptions do not apply. Where the sale is imminent and the holding period is close to twenty-four months, waiting can change the tax materially, though the decision should not be driven by tax alone.

Can I buy the new house in my spouse's name?

The exemption requires the investment to be in a residential house, and the statute's conditions on ownership and on the number of houses have been amended. A purchase in a spouse's name, funded by the seller, is examined closely, and the safest course is a purchase in the seller's own name or a joint purchase with the seller as a co-owner.

What if I sell the new house within three years?

The exemption is withdrawn and the gain is taxed in the year the new house is sold, in addition to the gain on that sale. The lock-in is a condition of the exemption and cannot be avoided by a later transaction.

Capital gains on property is an arithmetic exercise with a documentation problem in the middle. Reconstruct the cost, get the valuation, compute under both regimes, and decide on reinvestment before the due date. The tax is decided by records that are usually in a bank locker and rarely complete.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422