14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Tax & GST

Leaving the composition scheme: what you owe

A business leaves the composition scheme either because its turnover crosses the threshold or because it chooses to. In the first case the option lapses on the day the threshold is crossed, and the business must file regular returns from that date. In the second, the exit is effective from the date the withdrawal is filed. The gst composition scheme exit is a switch of regime, and the tax consequences are different from what most traders expect.

The scheme's attraction is the low rate and the single quarterly payment. Its cost is that the business cannot claim credit, cannot collect tax from customers, and cannot make inter-state supplies of goods. A business that has started selling outside the state, or has started buying from suppliers who charge tax, has usually outgrown it before the turnover threshold is reached.

What the scheme allows

The scheme is available to a registered person whose aggregate turnover in the preceding financial year does not exceed the notified limit, which is in the low crores for goods and lower for services, and it is not available to a person making inter-state outward supplies of goods, to a supplier through an electronic commerce operator who collects tax at source, to a manufacturer of notified goods, or to a person who is not permitted by the rules.

The rates are notified by category: a small rate for manufacturers and traders, a higher one for restaurants, and a distinct rate for service providers. The tax is paid quarterly, and the annual return is filed at the end of the year. The composition taxpayer cannot collect tax from the customer and must state on the invoice or bill that he is a composition taxable person.

The prohibition on credit runs both ways. The composition taxpayer cannot claim credit on his purchases, and his customer cannot claim credit on the tax he pays to the composition taxpayer. That second point is why a business selling to registered buyers usually has to leave the scheme to keep its customers.

When the option lapses

The option lapses when the aggregate turnover crosses the threshold. The lapse is automatic and takes effect from the day the threshold is exceeded, not from the end of the year and not from the date the department notices. The business has to file a withdrawal in the prescribed form, and it must begin filing the regular monthly returns from the date of the lapse.

A business that continues to file the quarterly composition return after crossing the threshold is filing a return for a scheme it is no longer in, and the short payment that results is a demand with interest. That is the commonest composition default, and it is entirely avoidable with a turnover monitor.

Where the business has more than one registration under the same permanent account number, the turnover is aggregated. A trader who splits his business into three registrations to stay under the limit is caught by the aggregation rule, and the lapse applies to all of them on the date the aggregate crosses.

The exit form and the effective date

The withdrawal is filed electronically, in the prescribed form, through the registration portal. Where the exit is voluntary, it takes effect from the date of filing. Where the option has lapsed, the business has to file the form within the period the rules allow and to regularise the returns from the date of the lapse.

The business must then file the regular returns for the period from the date of the switch, including the outward supplies made in that period. A gap between the last composition return and the first regular return produces a notice, because the system sees a registered person with no return for a month.

Where the business wants to remain registered but under the regular scheme, it does not need a fresh registration; the same registration continues and the scheme changes. Where it wants to cancel the registration altogether, that is a separate application, and the two should not be confused.

The stock position

The switch requires a stock statement as on the date of the exit, valued at cost, with the invoices for the goods held. The stock statement decides the transition entries, and it is the document the department will ask for first.

Whether an amount is payable on the stock depends on the direction of the switch, and this is where practitioners conflate two rules. A regular taxpayer who moves into the composition scheme must pay an amount equal to the credit on the inputs held in stock and on the capital goods, because he has already taken the credit and is now leaving the regular regime. A composition taxpayer who moves out becomes eligible to claim credit on the inputs in stock and on capital goods, subject to the conditions and the documentary proof the rules require.

So the answer to "what do I owe on exit" is usually nothing on the stock, and often a credit instead. The tax payable on exit is the tax on the supplies made in the composition period that has not been paid, and the regular tax on the supplies made after the switch. A business that pays an amount on stock on exit has usually paid something it did not owe.

The mistakes that cost money

  • Continuing to file the quarterly return after the threshold is crossed, which produces a demand for the difference between the composition rate and the regular rate.
  • Not filing the withdrawal, so the portal shows a composition taxpayer who is filing regular returns, which is an inconsistency that blocks refunds and e-way bills.
  • Claiming credit on stock without the invoices, or claiming it beyond the period the rules allow, which is reversed on audit.
  • Issuing invoices that show tax collected, which a composition taxpayer is not permitted to do and which must be paid to the government even though it was wrongly collected.
  • Making an inter-state supply of goods while in the scheme, which is a breach of the condition and ends the option.

The returns after the switch

From the date of the switch, the business files the monthly or quarterly returns as a regular taxpayer, with the outward supplies, the credit claimed and the tax paid. The credit on the opening stock is claimed in the first return, with the stock statement and the invoices, and it is the entry that an audit examines most closely.

The annual return for the year of the switch is a split return in effect: the composition period and the regular period. The reconciliation between the two is where the numbers usually go wrong, because the composition turnover and the regular turnover are reported on different bases.

Where a demand arises from the transition, the reply should be built on the date of the lapse, the returns filed, and the stock statement. A GST transition dispute is decided on those three documents, and a review of the registration and returns before the notice is cheaper than the appeal after it.

An appeal against a demand confirmed on the transition lies to the appellate authority and then to the tribunal, with the pre-deposit, and a reply at the notice stage is the point at which the arithmetic can still be corrected.

Common questions

Can I choose to exit the composition scheme in the middle of the year?

Yes. The withdrawal is filed in the prescribed form and takes effect from the date of filing, and the business files regular returns from that date. The returns for the composition period up to the exit still have to be filed.

Do I have to pay tax on my closing stock when I exit?

Ordinarily no. On exit from the scheme the business becomes eligible for credit on the inputs in stock and capital goods, subject to the conditions, rather than paying an amount on them. The amount on stock is payable in the opposite case, when a regular taxpayer enters the scheme.

What happens if I cross the threshold in December?

The option lapses on the day the threshold is crossed, and the business must file the withdrawal and the regular returns from that date. Continuing to pay at the composition rate for the rest of the year creates a shortfall that is recovered with interest.

Can I re-enter the composition scheme later?

The option can be availed again in a subsequent year if the eligibility conditions are met, subject to the restrictions in the rules and the time limits for exercising the option. A business that has been penalised for a composition default should expect the department to examine the next opt-in closely.

Exit from the scheme is a date, a form, and a stock statement. Fix the date from the turnover record, file the withdrawal, value the stock with the invoices, and file the first regular return on time. The tax on transition is mostly the regular tax on what you sold after the switch, not a charge on what you were holding.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422