Cyber insurance covers a small business for the cost of a data breach or a cyber attack, and for the liability it owes to others. The policy is written in two sections, one for the business's own losses and one for its liability to third parties, and the disputes are almost always about the conditions the business agreed to keep rather than about the event itself.
The first-party cover
The business's own losses fall into recognisable heads. Breach response costs are the largest in most claims: the forensic investigation to find out what happened, the legal advice on notification obligations, the cost of informing affected persons, and where the policy provides for it, credit monitoring for those affected.
Business interruption follows. Where a ransomware attack takes the systems down, the policy can cover the lost profit for the interruption period, with a waiting period and a sub-limit, and sometimes the extra cost of working around the outage. Cyber extortion is covered, which for most Indian businesses means ransomware, though a payment to an attacker raises legal and sanctions questions that the policy and the insurer's guidance will address.
Funds transfer fraud is a separate head, and the one most often excluded or heavily conditioned. Where an employee is deceived by a spoofed email into remitting money to a fraudster's account, the question is whether the policy covers social engineering, whether it requires a callback verification on any change of bank details, and whether the employee's conduct broke a condition. Read that clause before signing, not after the money has left.
The liability cover
The third-party section responds to claims made against the business. A customer whose data was exposed, a patient whose record was published, a business partner whose systems were infected through the insured's network. The policy covers the defence costs and the damages, and it may cover the cost of an investigation by a regulator and, where insurable, a penalty.
Two features shape this cover. It is usually written on a claims-made basis, which means the policy in force when the claim is made is the one that responds, not the policy in force when the breach happened, subject to a retroactive date. And the limit is shared or separate between the sections, which decides how much is left for the liability claim after the response costs are paid.
The conditions that decide claims
Cyber policies require the insured to maintain the security controls described in the proposal. Multi-factor authentication on remote access and on email, patching within a stated period, endpoint protection, backups that are tested and held separately from the live network, and a written incident response plan. Where the loss is traceable to a control the business said it had and did not, the insurer can reduce or refuse the claim. The security programme that the proposal form describes is part of the compliance work on our corporate compliance page.
The notification requirements are strict. The policy will require the incident to be reported within a short period, and the business must not admit liability or settle with a claimant without the insurer's consent. The forensic vendor is usually drawn from the insurer's panel, and a business that appoints its own investigator and then presents the report may find the insurer disputing the method. The insurer's consent is also required before any public statement about the incident.
What is excluded is worth listing, because these are the clauses that end claims.
- Prior known incidents and known vulnerabilities that were not remediated.
- Failure to maintain the minimum controls warranted in the proposal.
- Unencrypted portable devices and the loss of data from them.
- War and state-sponsored attacks, in the version of the exclusion the insurer uses.
- Contractual liability the business assumed beyond what the policy provides.
- Fines and penalties where the law makes them uninsurable.
- Intellectual property and bodily injury claims, which belong to other policies.
The Indian compliance layer
Cyber cover sits on top of statutory obligations, and the obligations shape the claim. The directions issued by the Indian Computer Emergency Response Team require specified cyber incidents to be reported to it within a very short time of being noticed, which means the incident log and the reporting trail are required documents in any claim. The data protection law adds its own notification duties to the data protection authority and, in some cases, to affected individuals, and the cost of complying with those duties is what the breach response head of the policy is designed to fund.
Where the business is an intermediary under the information technology rules, its obligations to appoint a grievance officer and to act on orders on a short timeline create a compliance risk that a general liability policy does not cover. Our page on data privacy sets out those obligations. The statutory obligations of a platform are set out under cyber law.
How a claim is made, and how it is lost
- Contain the incident, but preserve the evidence: the affected systems, the logs and the images before they are rebuilt.
- Notify the insurer within the period the policy fixes, in writing, with the facts as known at that time.
- Notify CERT-In as the directions require, and keep the acknowledgement.
- Instruct the forensic vendor the insurer nominates, and share the scope with the insurer in writing.
- Keep every invoice and every decision on record, with the date and the person who decided.
- Do not settle with a claimant, or make a public statement, without the insurer's written consent.
When the insurer repudiates
A repudiation based on an alleged breach of a security warranty is met with the proposal form, the audit reports, the patch records and the incident timeline. Where the insurer relies on a known-vulnerability exclusion, the burden is to show that the insured knew of the vulnerability before the inception of the policy, and a vulnerability report produced after the event is not knowledge.
The forum depends on the insured. An individual or a small business that bought the policy for its own purposes can complain to the Insurance Ombudsman or the District Consumer Commission; a claim under a large commercial policy is litigated in a civil suit before the City Civil Court or the original side of the Calcutta High Court. Our page on consumer protection explains the ombudsman and commission routes.
Common questions
Is a ransomware payment covered?
Extortion cover is common, but the payment involves legal questions about dealing with a criminal and about sanctions, and the insurer will require involvement and may require the involvement of a response firm. The cover pays the loss; it does not make the payment lawful in every case.
Does the policy cover an employee's mistake?
Where the loss is a funds transfer fraud caused by an employee's deception, the answer depends on the social engineering clause and on any verification condition. A policy that requires a callback before a change of bank details will not pay where no callback was made.
Is cyber cover available for a small firm with no IT department?
Yes, and the controls the insurer will require are the basic ones: multi-factor authentication, patching, endpoint protection and offsite backups. A small business that cannot show these will find the cover thin and the premium high.
Does the business need a separate policy for a breach involving personal data?
Cyber policies usually include the privacy liability section, and the data protection law's notification costs sit within the breach response head. The two are drafted together, and the limits and sub-limits should be read as one package.
The policy is not a substitute for controls, and the insurer knows it. A business that keeps its systems patched, its backups offsite, its access controlled and its incident log in order gets a claim paid and a renewal at a sensible premium. One that buys the policy and changes nothing gets an investigation and a repudiation letter quoting its own proposal form.