14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

Defamation notice: the contents that make it work

A defamation notice works when it is precise. It must reproduce the offending statement word for word, identify where and when it was published and to whom, explain why it is false, and demand a retraction, an apology and a withdrawal within a stated time. A notice that says "you have defamed my client, apologise" is a letter of complaint. A notice that does the four things above becomes the foundation of a suit or a criminal complaint, and it is the document the court will read first.

A defamation notice contents checklist that omits the imputation is worthless, and it is the first thing a court looks for. The purpose is not to win an argument by post. It is to create a record of the demand and of the refusal, to give the publisher a chance to mitigate, and to fix the date from which limitation and damages run. Defamation is now punishable under Section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, which replaced the old provisions of the Penal Code, and it also gives rise to a civil action for damages in the City Civil Court at Kolkata. The same notice serves both.

First, the words that actually defame

A statement defames when it lowers a person in the estimation of right-thinking members of society, or tends to make them shun or avoid him, or injures him in his trade or profession. That is the test the court applies, and the notice should be drafted with it in mind. An insult is not automatically defamation. A statement of opinion on a matter of public interest, a fair comment on a public figure's conduct, and a report of proceedings in a court of record enjoy protection, and a notice that attacks such a statement wastes its force.

The imputation must be reproduced exactly. Put the sentence in quotation marks, in the language in which it appeared, with a translation where it was in Bengali, Hindi or Urdu. Say where it appeared — the newspaper and date, the website and URL, the WhatsApp group and its members, the notice board at the office — and say to whom it was published. Publication to a third person is the essence of the wrong; a statement made only to the complainant is not actionable.

Where the statement was made orally, at a meeting or before a group of people, the notice should name the occasion, the place and the persons present. Reconstruct the words as closely as memory allows and say in the notice that the words are substantially reproduced. A notice that cites the gist of a speech and names the audience is far stronger than one that asserts a defamatory rumour without particulars.

The demand, and the time given

The demand should be specific and modest. Ask for a written retraction of the imputation, an unconditional apology in a form that can be published in the same place with the same prominence, removal of the material from the website or the group, and an assurance that it will not be repeated. Ask for compliance within a stated period — a fortnight is usual, a week where the material is still online and spreading.

Reserve rights expressly. State that the notice is issued without prejudice to the right to sue for damages, to seek an injunction restraining further publication, and to file a criminal complaint. Where the material is on a platform, mention that a grievance has been lodged with the intermediary under the information technology rules, because the platform's own timeline runs in parallel.

Do not demand a sum of money as the primary relief in the notice unless the claim is already quantified and supported. An inflated demand invites a reply that treats the notice as extortion, and it weakens the suit. It is enough to say that damages will be claimed and assessed by the court.

What the notice must leave out

Leave out abuse. A notice that calls the recipient a liar and a criminal gives him a defence of provocation in the popular sense and gives the court a reason to read the whole letter with suspicion. Leave out allegations that the sender cannot prove, because a notice is a publication too, and a reckless notice can itself be defamatory.

Leave out legal argument that will be wrong. Citations of section numbers that do not exist, or the wrong statute, are remembered by the other side and quoted back at the hearing. It is better to describe the wrong and the relief than to decorate the letter with law. Leave out any admission about the truth of the statement — a notice that concedes "some of what you said may be true" hands the defendant the defence of substantial truth.

How the notice should be served

Speed matters where the material is online, and service matters everywhere. Send the notice by registered post with acknowledgement due, and by email to the address on the website or the letterhead, and keep the postal receipt, the tracking printout and the email delivery record. Where the publisher is a company, address the notice to the company at its registered office as shown on the MCA portal, with a copy to the directors, so that there is no argument later that the notice never reached the right person.

Where the publisher is anonymous or uses a pseudonym, the notice goes to the platform's grievance officer along with a request for the subscriber details, and the platform is given the opportunity to take the material down. That step is not a substitute for the notice to the author, but it stops the harm while the author is identified.

A notice served on a Sunday night, or on the eve of an election, is still valid. What is not valid is a notice served after the limitation has run. For a civil suit for defamation the period is one year from the date of publication, and for a criminal complaint the period is governed by the limitation provisions of the criminal procedure code. A notice sent in the twelfth month is a notice sent too late.

What happens after the reply

Three outcomes follow. The publisher retracts and apologises, and the matter ends with a written record that the family can keep. He replies denying publication or pleading truth, and the denial itself becomes evidence of malice if it is knowingly false. Or he ignores the notice, which is the strongest position for the complainant, because silence after a precise demand is difficult to explain at the hearing.

If the retraction is partial, take it and sue for the rest rather than rejecting it. A defendant who has offered a correction in the same place has mitigated the damage, and a court will take that into account in awarding damages. The notice and the reply together usually decide the quantum, which is why the drafting of both is worth care.

For a criminal complaint, the notice is filed with the complaint as the first exhibit, and the magistrate at Bankshall or the City Sessions Court, depending on the forum, reads the demand and the silence before issuing process. For the civil suit, the plaint is filed in the City Civil Court at Kolkata with the notice and the proof of service annexed, and the prayer is for damages and an injunction.

Common questions

Is a notice compulsory before filing a defamation suit?

No statute makes it compulsory, but a suit filed without one is weaker on damages, because the defendant can say he was never asked to correct the statement. For a criminal complaint, the notice is not a condition precedent either, though a magistrate is more willing to take cognisance where the complainant first asked for a retraction and was refused.

Can a company send a defamation notice?

A company can sue for defamation affecting its business reputation, and it must show that the statement tended to injure its trade. The notice is issued by a director or an authorised officer, and the board resolution authorising the notice should be annexed. Individual directors cannot sue for a statement about the company unless it refers to them personally.

What if the statement was made in a WhatsApp group?

The group is a publication to its members, and the notice should name the group, the date and time of the message, and the sender. Members who forwarded the message are publishers too, though their liability depends on knowledge. Capture screenshots with the phone's clock visible, and preserve the original device, because a screenshot alone is easily challenged.

Does a true statement give a defence?

Truth is a defence in civil defamation, and under the penal provision truth published for the public good is protected. The defence is narrower than people assume: the defendant must prove the imputation is substantially true, not merely that he believed it. A notice that anticipates this by setting out the facts demonstrating falsity puts the burden where it belongs.

If a statement has already been published and is spreading, the notice is one of several steps that must be taken in the same week. Our page on defamation notice drafting describes the format, and cyber law remedies covers the takedown route where the publication is online. Bring the offending material, the screenshots with dates, and any prior correspondence to the first consultation at our Kolkata office.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422