A defamatory post on social media can be met on three fronts at once: a request to the platform for a takedown, a criminal complaint by the person defamed, and a civil suit for damages and an injunction. Each has its own requirements, and the first thing to do in all three is preserve the post before it is deleted.
Preserve the evidence first
Take a full screenshot showing the post, the account name, the URL and the timestamp, and a second screenshot of the profile. Save the page to an internet archive so that the URL resolves to the content later even if the post is removed. Note every person who saw it and can say so in evidence, because publication to a third party is an element of the wrong.
Where the post is a video or a story that expires, download it. Where it is in a private group or a direct message, keep the message with its metadata. A defamation case is often lost because the plaintiff cannot prove what was published, and the platform's removal has destroyed the only copy.
The platform takedown
Platforms operate a grievance mechanism, and every significant intermediary is required to appoint a grievance officer and to publish the contact details. A takedown request through that mechanism, with the URL and the reason, is the quickest route and the one most likely to succeed for content that clearly breaches the platform's own policies: harassment, impersonation, or a fake account.
Where the platform does not act, the legal route is a court order or a government notification, on which the intermediary is required to act within a defined period. That route is used for content that is unlawful under Indian law, and it requires the complainant to obtain an order. A court can grant an injunction restraining publication and directing removal in a civil suit, and it can grant it on an interim application where the defamation is clear and the damage is continuing.
The platform is not the primary wrongdoer. It is liable only where its protection from liability is lost, which generally requires actual knowledge in the form of a court order or a government notification that it failed to act on. Suing the platform in the first instance, rather than the person who posted, is usually a waste of the complainant's time. The conditions on which a platform's protection depends are set out under cyber law.
The criminal complaint
Defamation is an offence under the penal law, re-enacted in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita with the same structure of exceptions. The offence is generally non-cognizable and bailable, and the prosecution must be instituted on a complaint by the person defamed, or by someone authorised to act for him where he is dead or unable to act. A police officer cannot, as a matter of routine, register a case and proceed of his own motion, and this requirement exists to prevent the harassment of journalists and critics.
The exceptions are the defence of the case. Truth is a defence where it is published for the public good. A statement in good faith made for the protection of the maker's or another's interests, or as an opinion on a public question, attracts protection. Fair comment on the conduct of a public servant in the discharge of his duties is protected, subject to good faith. The complainant must therefore be prepared to meet the exception, and a complaint about a statement of opinion on a public question is weak.
Where the imputation is against the President or the Governor, or against a public servant in respect of his conduct, the sanction requirements in the law have to be met before the complaint is filed. Filing without the sanction invites a dismissal that is difficult to repair.
The forum is the court of the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate at Bankshall for offences committed within the city's metropolitan area, and the appropriate magistrate's court elsewhere in the state. The complainant should file with the post, the screenshots, the archiving evidence and a note identifying the account holder, which the police can supplement with a production notice to the platform for the subscriber's registration details.
The civil suit for damages and injunction
The civil remedy gives money and an injunction, and it does not depend on the criminal exceptions in the same way. The plaintiff must prove that the statement was published to a third party, that it referred to him, and that its natural meaning lowered him in the estimation of right-thinking members of society.
Damages are assessed by the court on the harm to the plaintiff's reputation, the extent of the publication, the gravity of the imputation and the conduct of the defendant. General damages in these cases are moderate, and a plaintiff whose case rests on an exaggeration of the harm will be disappointed. Aggravated damages can be awarded where the defendant repeated the statement after a notice, which is the reason the notice should always be sent.
The suit is filed in the City Civil Court where the value is within its limit, and on the original side of the Calcutta High Court where it is above it. An interim injunction against further publication is sought with the plaint, and it is granted where the statement is clearly defamatory and the defendant does not have a plausible defence. Our page on civil litigation explains how the interim application is framed.
The legal notice before the suit is worth sending even though it is not mandatory. It puts the defendant on notice, it may produce an apology or a retraction, and the refusal to retract after the notice supports the claim for aggravated damages. A model is available through our defamation notice service.
Finding the person behind the account
An anonymous account is the practical difficulty in every online defamation case. The route is through the criminal investigation: the police request the platform for the subscriber's registration details and the IP logs, and if necessary the telecom operator for the subscriber data of the mobile number. In a civil suit, the plaintiff can apply to the court for a direction to the platform to disclose the account details, and the court will weigh the right to reputation against the anonymous speaker's privacy.
A platform will not disclose user data on a private request, and it will resist a demand that is not backed by an order. The application should be specific, limited to the account and the period, and supported by the plaintiff's affidavit on the harm suffered.
Common questions
Can a company sue for defamation?
A company can sue for a statement that damages its trading reputation, and the claim is usually in the same form: a suit for damages and an injunction. A company cannot, however, be said to have been lowered in the estimation of society in the way an individual can, and the damages are assessed on the business loss and the conduct of the defendant.
Is sharing a defamatory post also defamation?
Republishing or sharing a defamatory statement is publication in law, and it can attract liability, though the extent of the liability differs between the originator, the one who repeats it and a platform that merely hosts it. The person who shares with a comment of his own is in a weaker position than the one who merely forwards.
Does the complainant have to prove that the statement was false?
In a criminal complaint, truth is a defence that the accused must establish within the exceptions, and the complainant's burden is to prove publication and the defamatory meaning. In a civil suit, the falsity is usually pleaded and proved by the plaintiff. In both, a defendant who cannot show the statement was true is exposed.
What is the limitation for a defamation suit?
One year from the date of publication, under the Limitation Act, for a suit for damages for defamation. The criminal complaint must be filed within the period the procedural law allows for a complaint, and delay in either forum weakens the case.
Online defamation is a race between the poster's delete key and the complainant's evidence. The plaintiff who archives the post, sends a notice, asks the platform for a takedown through the proper channel and files the civil suit within the limitation has done everything the law requires. The remedies are modest, but they are real, and they work. The first step, before any suit, is a demand in the form shown on our legal notice drafting page.