14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Cyber Law

Email and WhatsApp evidence: the certificate required

An electronic record is proved in court by producing it with a certificate signed by the person in charge of the device or the system that produced it, in the form the law prescribes. A screenshot without that certificate is treated as a copy, and a court may refuse to act on it. The requirement now sits in the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, which replaced the Indian Evidence Act, and it is the same requirement that Section 65B of the old Act imposed.

Why the certificate is needed

An electronic record is easy to alter. The law's answer is to require the party producing it to certify the process by which it was produced, so that the court has some assurance about its integrity. The certificate is not proof that the contents are true; it is proof that the record is what it purports to be — that the computer or device produced it in the ordinary course of its use, and that it has not been tampered with.

The certificate must be given by a person occupying a responsible official position in relation to the operation of the relevant device or the management of the relevant activities. For a chat on a personal phone, that person is the owner of the phone. For a company's email server, it is the system administrator or the officer in charge of information technology.

Where the certificate is not filed, the record may still be admitted at the court's discretion in an appropriate case, but relying on that discretion is a gamble. File the certificate with the document.

What the certificate should say

The certificate should identify:

  • The electronic record, by description and date, with the exhibit reference.
  • The device or system on which it was produced, and the manner of its production.
  • The person giving the certificate and his position, with a statement of his responsibility for the device or system.
  • That the record was produced by the device in the ordinary course of its use, and that the information was fed in the ordinary course.
  • That the record has not been altered, and where the law requires it, the hash value of the record.

The certificate should be signed and dated, and it should accompany the printout or the electronic copy. Where the record is produced on a storage device, the device and the certificate go together, and the court may order that a copy be made and the original retained.

Emails

An email is proved most cleanly by the person who received it, certifying the device or the mail system from which the printout was taken. Print the email with the full headers where the sender's identity is disputed — the header carries the routing and the originating address. Where the email is on a corporate system, the administrator's certificate is the better document.

Where the sender denies sending the email, the header and the service provider's records are the answer. A court can direct the service provider to furnish the subscriber details and the access logs, and in a criminal case the investigating officer does this routinely.

Attachments and the transmission report should be preserved with the email. Where an email says a document was attached, the attachment and the email have to be produced together, or the recipient's evidence about the attachment has no documentary support.

WhatsApp and similar messaging applications

Messaging application evidence raises three questions: who is the sender, is the record complete, and is it authentic. Each has an answer:

  1. Identity. The phone number is the identity marker. Show the contact card with the number, and where the number is disputed, obtain the subscriber details from the service provider through the court or the police.
  2. Completeness. Export the entire conversation rather than producing selected screenshots. A party who produces only the messages that help him will be asked for the rest, and the court may draw an adverse inference.
  3. Authenticity. The device owner's certificate, together with the export file and, where possible, the original device produced for inspection.

The cleanest practice is to export the chat through the application's export function, which produces a file with the messages and the timestamps, and to keep the phone available. A court may direct that the phone be produced and the chat examined, and a party who has deleted the chat is in difficulty.

Voice notes, call records and deleted messages

Voice notes are electronic records like any other and are proved the same way. Call detail records are obtained from the service provider through the court or the police, and they show the number, the time and the duration, but not the content. Deleted messages can sometimes be recovered from a backup or from the other party's device, and the application's cloud backup is a source that is often overlooked.

Where the record is on a platform rather than a device, a request to the platform for the account data, made through the court or the police, is the route. Platforms respond to legal process and to preservation requests, and the request should be made early, because platforms hold data for limited periods.

A printout proves nothing about itself. The certificate is what turns a printout into evidence, and it takes five minutes to prepare.

Filing in the Kolkata courts

In the City Civil Court at Kolkata or on the original side of the Calcutta High Court, the electronic record is filed with the certificate and the list of documents, and the certificate is marked as an exhibit along with the record. In criminal trials before the City Sessions Court or the Magistrates' courts, the investigating officer ordinarily produces the records with the certificate, and the defence challenges the certificate's sufficiency.

A party who is unsure of the form should look at the certificate annexed to the record and check that the person signing it is the person in charge. A certificate signed by the advocate rather than by the device's owner is a defect that is regularly taken.

Common questions

Can a screenshot alone be filed?

It can be filed, and the court may admit it, but it is weak without the certificate and without the source. File the export file, the certificate and, where the contents are disputed, the device.

Who signs the certificate for a company's records?

The officer responsible for the computer system or the management of the relevant activity. In practice the information technology head or the company secretary, with a statement of his position and responsibility.

What if the phone has been lost or damaged?

The certificate can be given by the person who had charge of the device at the time, explaining what happened. The absence of the device weakens the case but does not destroy it, particularly where a backup exists.

Prepare the certificate with the record, and export the whole conversation. Our cyber law practice handles electronic evidence in the Kolkata courts, civil litigation covers the suit in which it is produced, and cyber harassment covers the criminal complaints where the same evidence decides the case.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422