An employee stock option is a right to buy shares later at a price fixed now. It is not a share, and it is not income when it is granted. The tax falls at the exercise, again when the shares are sold, and — for some employees — the first of those can be deferred. Getting the sequence right is worth more than the rate itself, because a badly timed sale can put the whole gain in the highest slab.
The scheme and the law behind it
For an unlisted company, the framework is in the Companies Act and the rules made under it, which require the options to be approved by the shareholders by special resolution, to be offered under a scheme that sets out the vesting period, and not to be transferable. The scheme has to be administered by a committee of the board or by a trust, and there are limits on the number of options and on the price.
A listed company works under the securities regulator's share-based employee benefit regulations, which impose disclosure, a minimum vesting period of one year, and restrictions on the pricing and on the treatment of options when an employee leaves.
A private company that grants options outside an approved scheme creates a tax problem for itself and a documentation problem for the employee. The scheme matters as much as the grant letter.
The three dates
Four events are involved, and employees routinely confuse them.
- Grant. The date the option is given. Nothing is taxable, and the employee owns a right, not a share.
- Vesting. The date the option becomes exercisable, usually in tranches over a period. Still nothing taxable.
- Exercise. The date the employee pays the exercise price and the shares are allotted. This is the taxable event, because the difference between the fair market value of the shares on that date and the price paid is a perquisite — a benefit in kind from employment.
- Sale. The shares are sold, and the gain or loss from the exercise-date value is a capital gain.
The tax at exercise is the part employees do not expect. An employee who exercises options worth a substantial amount may owe tax on a gain he has not received in cash, because the shares are not listed and cannot be sold. That is the classic squeeze, and it is why many schemes allow a cashless exercise or a sale to a nominated buyer.
The deferral, and who gets it
The law permits a deferral of the perquisite tax in defined cases. Where the employer is an eligible start-up, and where the shares of the employer company are listed on a recognised stock exchange, the tax on the perquisite is deferred to the earliest of three events: the expiry of a stated number of years from the end of the assessment year in which the options were exercised, the sale of the shares, or the employee ceasing to be employed.
The deferral is a timing benefit, not an exemption. The tax is still paid, at the rate applicable in the year in which it falls due, and the deferral can push the gain into a year in which the employee's other income is higher.
An employee who is not in an eligible start-up and whose employer is unlisted has no deferral. The tax is due in the year of exercise, through the employer's withholding, and the employer is obliged to deduct it.
The capital gain on sale
For unlisted shares, the gain is computed from the exercise-date fair market value, and the holding period decides whether it is long term or short term. The holding period runs from the date of allotment, not the date of grant or vesting. For listed shares, a statutory securities transaction tax applies and the holding period for long-term treatment is shorter.
The rate depends on the holding period, the type of share, and the year of transfer. It has been changed more than once, so the rate should be confirmed for the year of sale rather than taken from an old note.
There is also a valuation requirement. Unlisted shares have to be valued by a merchant banker or a chartered accountant on the prescribed basis at the time of exercise, and the valuation report is the document the employer and the employee both need. A valuation obtained late, or on a different basis, is a common source of assessment.
Leaving the company
What happens on resignation depends entirely on the scheme. The usual terms are that vested options may be exercised within a window after the last working day, and unvested options lapse. Some schemes provide for a buyback by the company at the exercise price or at fair value. Some provide that the company may repurchase the shares at a stated price on a termination for cause.
Read the scheme and the grant letter before resigning, not after. An employee who resigns without exercising within the window loses the benefit, and a company that refuses to allot shares after a valid exercise is in breach of the scheme.
Where the employment ends by termination, the scheme may treat the options differently, and the distinction between resignation, termination without cause and termination for cause is usually set out in the grant letter. It is worth negotiating that clause at the time of joining rather than at the time of leaving.
An option that has vested is a contractual right. An option that has not vested is a hope. The scheme decides which, and the scheme is not negotiable after the event.
Disclosure and the company's side
A company granting options must account for them, disclose them in its financial statements, and reflect them in its share capital when they are exercised. For a private company, the allotment has to be filed with the Registrar within the prescribed period, and the register of members updated. A failure at that stage leaves the employee holding shares that the company's records do not show, which becomes a problem at the time of a sale or an investment round.
Stamp duty on the allotment, the valuation report, and the filings are the company's responsibility, and employees should confirm that they have been done before relying on the shareholding.
Common questions
Is the grant taxable?
No. Nothing is taxable at grant or at vesting. The taxable event is the exercise, and the tax is on the difference between the fair market value on that date and the price paid.
What if I cannot afford the exercise price?
Some schemes permit a cashless exercise, a net settlement, or a loan from the company. Others do not, and the option simply lapses. Asking the company for the available mechanics before the exercise window closes is worth doing.
Do I pay tax if the shares are worth nothing?
If the fair market value at exercise is below the price paid, there is no perquisite. The loss may be available as a capital loss on sale, subject to the rules on set-off.
For a company setting up a scheme, and for an employee reading one, the documents decide everything. Our corporate law practice handles ESOP schemes and allotments, shareholder agreements covers the exit mechanics, and intellectual property covers the assignment of the work the employee created, which is a separate question from the shares.