14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Tax & GST

First appeal to the CIT (Appeals): form, fee and grounds

An assessee who disputes an assessment order appeals to the Commissioner (Appeals), not to a tribunal, and cit appeals filing is now almost entirely electronic: Form 35 is filed through the e-filing portal within thirty days of the service of the notice of demand, the fee is nominal, and the appeal is heard by the faceless appellate centre rather than by an officer sitting in a particular building. The one condition that stops more appeals than any other is the statutory requirement that the tax on the returned income, and the tax on the undisputed part of the demand, be paid before the appeal is entertained.

The statutory frame

An appeal against an order of assessment or penalty lies to the Commissioner (Appeals) within thirty days of the date of service of the notice of demand and the order. The Commissioner may admit an appeal after that period on sufficient cause being shown, and the application for condonation should be a separate, reasoned request filed with the appeal rather than a line in the grounds.

The appeal must be in the prescribed form, verified, and accompanied by the notice of demand and the order appealed against. The fee is fixed by statute in slabs that rise with the assessed income; it is small, and the portal computes it when the appeal is filed. The larger payment is the tax condition: the appeal is not admitted unless the assessee has paid the tax on the returned income and the tax on the undisputed portion of the demand.

The tax condition, which decides admissibility

This is the point that ends appeals before they are heard. An assessee who has filed a return and paid the tax on it satisfies the first limb. The second limb asks for the tax on the amount that the assessee does not dispute — for example, where an addition of a disallowed expense is partly accepted. The proof of payment is uploaded with the appeal.

Where the assessee genuinely cannot pay, the practical options are to apply for a stay of the demand, to pay in instalments with the department's leave, or to restrict the appeal to the disputed portion so that the admitted amount is paid. Filing the appeal and ignoring the condition produces a dismissal that then has to be appealed, which wastes the limitation period.

Grounds that work

  • No application of mind: the order does not deal with the explanation, the evidence or the case law cited.
  • Violation of natural justice: a faceless order passed without granting the hearing that was asked for, or a show cause notice that did not disclose the proposed addition.
  • Factual error: an addition computed on a figure that the record contradicts — a duplicate entry, a double counting of the same receipt.
  • Legal error: a deduction allowed by the statute and denied, or a provision applied to a year to which it does not apply.
  • Limitation: an order passed after the period the statute allows, which goes to jurisdiction.
  • Penalty without satisfaction: a penalty imposed without a finding that the conditions of the penalty provision are met.

How the faceless hearing works

  1. Filing on the portal. Form 35, the statement of facts, the grounds, the order, the demand notice and the proof of payment are uploaded.
  2. Registration and defect cure. The appeal is registered, or a defect memo is issued. A defective appeal that is not cured is treated as not filed.
  3. Notice. The National Faceless Appeal Centre issues a notice scheduling the hearing, ordinarily through video conference, with a date and a window.
  4. Submissions. Written submissions are uploaded before the hearing, and the assessee or the representative appears on the video conference.
  5. Additional evidence. The appellate authority has a discretion to admit additional evidence, and an application under the rule should be made expressly rather than by annexing new papers to the submissions.
  6. The order. The order is passed and served electronically, and the appeal effect is given by the assessing officer.

The power to enhance, and the danger in it

The appellate authority can confirm, reduce, enhance or annul the assessment. The power to enhance is real, and it is the reason an appeal should not be filed casually: an appellate authority that finds an issue the assessing officer missed can issue a show cause and enhance. In practice this happens where the appeal invites the authority to examine the whole computation, so the grounds should be confined to what is genuinely disputed.

The authority can also set aside the order and remand the matter for a fresh assessment, which is often the best outcome where the assessing officer failed to consider the evidence. A remand comes with directions, and the assessee's task on remand is to comply with them precisely.

After the CIT (Appeals)

A further appeal lies to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal within sixty days of the order, with a fee that depends on the assessed income, and the tribunal hears both facts and law. The tribunal's Kolkata bench hears appeals from this region, and its orders are appealable to the Calcutta High Court on a substantial question of law.

A writ petition is available where the appellate order is without jurisdiction, but the ordinary rule is that the statutory appeal to the tribunal must be exhausted first.

Practical points

The order and the notice of demand are served electronically, and the thirty days run from the date of service recorded on the portal. The acknowledgement should be downloaded on the day it appears, because it is the evidence of the date. The grounds should be specific to the order — quoting the paragraph and the figure — rather than a list of propositions, and the statement of facts should be a chronology with the page references to the paper book.

The compliance team prepares the paper book and the reconciliation, the indirect tax practice handles the parallel GST appeals that often arise from the same transaction, and a demand that is enforced without jurisdiction is taken up as a writ petition. Appeal formats are on the legal formats page.

Can I appeal without paying the tax on the returned income?

No. The condition is statutory, and an appeal filed without the proof of payment is not admitted. Where payment is impossible, a stay application and an instalment request are the practical answers.

Is the appeal heard in Kolkata?

The appeal is heard by the faceless appellate centre through the portal and video conference. The assessee does not attend an office, though the representative appears from Kolkata.

Can new documents be filed in appeal?

Only with the authority's leave, under the rule on additional evidence. Documents that were available and not produced before the assessing officer are usually refused.

What if the department does not give effect to the appellate order?

A rectification application, and then a representation to the assessing officer's superior, followed by a writ petition where the order is not implemented. Delay in giving appeal effect is a recurring problem, and the application should attach the appellate order and the computation.

The appeal is a document case. Order, notice, payment proof, grounds referencing the record — file those four properly and the hearing takes care of itself.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422