14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Tax & GST

GST audit and scrutiny notices in West Bengal

A scrutiny notice asks a question; an audit examines the records. Both come from the same department and both look like official letters, but the powers behind them are different, the reply periods are different, and the consequences of ignoring them are different. A taxpayer who treats a scrutiny notice as an audit panics unnecessarily, and a taxpayer who treats an audit as a scrutiny usually ends up with a demand that could have been avoided.

In West Bengal both are conducted by the state GST authorities for registered persons within the state, and both begin with a document on the portal. The gst audit scrutiny west bengal taxpayer faces is, in the ordinary case, a desk exercise on the returns and the annexures, and it is answerable from the records the business already has.

Scrutiny: the short, targeted enquiry

Scrutiny is the examination of the returns filed, to verify the correctness of the disclosures. The officer compares the returns with the annexures, with the tax paid, with the credit taken, and with the data the department has from other sources. Where he finds a discrepancy, he issues a notice in the prescribed form, describing the discrepancy and asking for an explanation.

The taxpayer replies in the prescribed form within thirty days, and the officer may extend the period. Where the reply is satisfactory, the proceedings are closed. Where it is not, the officer issues an order, and the order can confirm the demand or require further action. The order is appealable.

The scrutiny is confined to the points raised. An officer cannot use a scrutiny notice to reopen the whole return, and a reply that confines itself to the discrepancy, with the reconciliation and the documents, is the reply that closes the file. Volunteering information about unrelated periods invites a wider enquiry.

Audit: the deeper examination

An audit is the examination of the records, books and other documents of the registered person, to verify correctness of the turnover, the credit, the payment and the compliance. It is conducted by the departmental officers, or by a chartered accountant or cost accountant appointed by the commissioner, and it begins with a notice in the prescribed form giving the taxpayer not less than fifteen days to produce the records.

The audit is conducted at the premises of the taxpayer or at the office of the officer, and the taxpayer must provide the books, the returns, the invoices, the ledgers, the bank statements and the other records required. The audit is to be completed within the period the rules prescribe, and the findings are communicated in a report, with an opportunity to reply.

The audit is not a search. The officer cannot seize the records during an audit unless the seizure provisions are separately invoked, and the taxpayer is entitled to a reasonable time to produce the records. A demand for every document ever generated, on twenty-four hours' notice, is not what the rules contemplate.

The documents that should be ready

  • The returns for the period — outward supplies, inward supplies, the summary return and the annual return.
  • The sales register and the purchase register, reconciled to the returns.
  • The electronic credit ledger and the electronic liability ledger, downloaded for the period.
  • The invoices, with the e-way bills where the movement of goods required one.
  • The bank statements, and the ledger of advances and adjustments.
  • The stock records, the job work records, and the records of goods sent on approval.
  • The contracts with customers and suppliers, and the credit notes and debit notes.

The reconciliation is the document that matters most. A taxpayer who can show, in one working paper, how the books tie to the returns and to the ledgers, answers most of the questions before they are asked. A taxpayer who produces three cartons of invoices and asks the officer to find the answer has already lost the officer's goodwill.

The reply to a scrutiny notice

  1. Identify the exact discrepancy, and the period and the amount involved.
  2. Reconcile the figure with the books and the portal, and explain the difference — a timing difference, a credit note, an amendment, a classification issue.
  3. Produce the supporting documents for the specific figure, not the entire file.
  4. Where tax is payable on the admitted difference, pay it with interest and say so, and ask that the proceedings be closed.
  5. File the reply in the prescribed form on the portal, and keep the acknowledgement.

Where the officer's figure is wrong, say so plainly, with the correct computation. An explanation that the department's data is incomplete is a good explanation, but it must be supported by the taxpayer's own data.

The special audit

Where the officer is of the opinion that the value or the credit availed is not correctly declared, and that the matter needs a deeper examination, he may direct a special audit by a chartered accountant or a cost accountant nominated by the commissioner. The special audit is ordered with the prior approval of the commissioner, and the auditor's report is furnished to the taxpayer, who has an opportunity to reply.

The special audit is expensive and slow, and it is usually ordered where the records are complex or where the officer suspects a pattern of non-compliance. The taxpayer can challenge the order where it does not record the reasons or where it is beyond the officer's jurisdiction, and the challenge is by way of a writ petition.

Penalties, and the difference between a mistake and a suppression

A discrepancy found in scrutiny or audit does not automatically attract penalty. Where the taxpayer has paid the tax with interest on being pointed to the error, the penalty provisions for a bona fide mistake are not attracted. Where the department alleges suppression or wilful misstatement, the notice must say so and the higher penalty provisions apply, and the reply should address the allegation squarely.

The distinction matters because the same short payment can be characterised either way, and the officer's characterisation decides the penalty. A reply that admits the error, pays the tax and explains the cause is a reply that keeps the matter in the lower category. A reply that denies everything, and is then contradicted by the records, moves it to the higher one.

Our page on GST and indirect tax sets out the forms, and corporate compliance covers the record-keeping that makes an audit survivable.

Common questions

How much time do I get to reply to a scrutiny notice?

Thirty days from the date of the notice, extendable by the officer on a written request. The date of service is the date the notice appears on the portal, so check the portal regularly rather than waiting for an email.

Can the audit be conducted without notice?

The audit begins with a notice giving at least fifteen days to produce the records. An audit that begins without the notice, or on a shorter period without reasons, can be objected to in writing and, if it proceeds, challenged.

Does the officer have to give a personal hearing?

Where a demand is proposed, the taxpayer is entitled to be heard before the order. Ask for the hearing in writing, attend with the reconciliation, and ask that the submissions be recorded in the order.

What if the notice covers a period for which returns were not filed?

The audit for a period of non-filing will usually result in a demand computed on the best judgment basis. The reply should file the returns if they can still be filed, pay the tax with interest, and address the computation. Leaving the period unfiled invites the estimate.

A notice is best answered from a reconciled file, and the reconciliation takes time. If one has arrived, bring the notice, the returns and the ledgers to a consultation, or write to the office with the notice number and period. The GST practice page lists the documents.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422