The ordinary rule is simple: a criminal case is investigated and tried where the offence was committed. Everything else — the police station's area, the court's territorial limits, and the question of which state's police will act — follows from identifying the place of the offence. The complication is that the place of the offence is not always obvious: a cheating that begins with a phone call in Kolkata and ends with a transfer from a bank in Mumbai has more than one situs, and criminal case jurisdiction then turns on where the essential ingredients took place.
Registration is not the same as jurisdiction
The Sanhita requires that information disclosing a cognizable offence be registered at the police station where it is given, even if the offence occurred outside that station's area, and the case is then transferred to the station having jurisdiction to investigate. This is the zero FIR. The rule exists so that a complainant is never sent from one station to another, and it applies to Kolkata as much as anywhere else: a Ballygunge station cannot refuse a complaint about an incident in Barasat.
Registration anywhere and investigation by the right station are two different questions, and a complainant should confirm both. Ask for the FIR number and the station that will investigate; if the station is in a different district, the file will be transferred and the FIR number will change, which matters when the case is later cited before a court.
Where the offence is committed
The place of the offence includes the place where the act was done and, in many offences, the place where the consequence occurred. A theft is committed where the property was taken. An assault is committed where the blow landed. A cheating is committed where the inducement was made and where the property was delivered, and the courts have accepted that a complainant who parted with money in Kolkata can have the case tried in Kolkata even if the accused operated from another state.
- Offence committed in more than one place: the case can be tried in any of the places where the offence, or any part of it, was committed.
- Offence committed partly in one area and partly in another: the court in either area has jurisdiction, and the case is ordinarily tried where the more substantial part occurred.
- Uncertainty about the place: where it is doubtful which of several areas the offence was committed in, the court in any of those areas may try it.
- Offence committed outside India: a separate procedure applies, and the case is tried in the court having jurisdiction over the place where the accused is found or where the offence has effect.
Cyber offences, which test the rule hardest
An online fraud has no single location. The accused may sit in another state or abroad, the server may be elsewhere, the money may move through accounts in three states, and the victim is in Kolkata. The practice that has settled is that the case is registered where the victim resides or where the consequence was felt, and the investigating officer then issues notices to the platforms and requests the banks for the transaction trail. The National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal allows a complaint to be filed from anywhere, and the complaint is routed to the police unit for the victim's area.
Where the offence involves a foreign element, the investigation depends on letters rogatory and mutual legal assistance, and the practical reality is that the case proceeds against the persons and accounts within India. For a Kolkata complainant, the cyber cell at Lalbazar is the unit that handles the city cases, and the case is then tried before the Magistrate having jurisdiction over the police station that registered it.
Which court tries the case
Territorial jurisdiction over the court follows the police station. A case registered in the city is tried by the Magistrate at Bankshall or by the court to which the case is committed after the charge sheet — the City Sessions Court for offences triable by a sessions court. A case registered in Barasat or in the Alipore area goes to the district courts there. A case in Howrah goes to the Howrah courts, and a prosecution in another state is tried in that state unless the case is transferred.
The pecuniary and subject-matter rules also matter. A special statute may designate a special court — an offence under the narcotics law, a case under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, or a matter under the Companies Act — and that designation overrides the ordinary distribution. Where two courts could try the case, the one that takes cognizance first does not necessarily prevail; the question is which court is empowered.
Disputes between two states
Where two police forces each claim the case, or each refuses it, the complainant has two routes. The first is a representation to the Director General of Police of the state, and the second is an application to the High Court, which can direct that the investigation be conducted by a particular agency or that the case be transferred. The Supreme Court has also entertained petitions where two states were investigating the same transaction, and the ordinary principle is that one investigation should proceed to avoid conflicting findings.
A transfer of the trial itself is a different remedy. The High Court can transfer a case from one court to another within the state, and the Supreme Court can transfer a case from one state to another, on grounds of convenience or of the fairness of the trial.
Cheque cases, where the rule is special
The dishonour of a cheque has its own jurisdictional rule: the complaint is filed where the bank branch on which the cheque was drawn is situated, because that is where the offence of dishonour occurs. A cheque drawn on a Kolkata branch, presented anywhere in India, is a Kolkata case. The provision is specific to the cheque legislation, and it is the reason a Delhi creditor can be compelled to litigate in Kolkata for a cheque drawn on a Kolkata bank.
Practical steps before filing
Identify the place of the act and the place of the consequence, and file where the more substantial part occurred. Keep the FIR number and the station's name. Where the offence is online, preserve the transaction trail — the bank statement, the UPI reference, the chat — because the investigating officer in another state will rely on what the complaint contains. And where the case moves to another state, ask the court for the copies you will need rather than travelling for them.
The criminal law practice handles the registration, the transfer of the file and the trial in the court that finally hears the case, the cyber fraud practice deals with the online cases and the bank correspondence that follows, and a case that has been registered in the wrong forum is corrected through quashing or a transfer application.
Can I choose the police station?
You can file at the station nearest to you, and it must register the case. It will then be transferred to the station having jurisdiction, unless the offence occurred within its own area.
What if the offence happened in another state entirely?
The case is registered where the consequence was felt if the offence is one that continues to its effect, and otherwise in the state where the act took place. For an online fraud, the victim's location is ordinarily accepted as a place of trial.
Does the court's power depend on the police station's area?
The territorial jurisdiction of the court follows the area in which the offence was committed, and the police station's boundaries are administrative. Where a station registers a zero FIR and transfers the case, the trial follows the transfer.
Can two cases run at once for the same incident?
Two FIRs on the same transaction are not permissible, and the second is treated as a statement in the first investigation. Two cases in different states are possible only where the offences are genuinely distinct, and the High Court can transfer or consolidate them.
Jurisdiction is the first question and the easiest to get wrong. Fix the place of the act, the place of the consequence and the court that sits over that area, and the rest of the file will follow the right route.