14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Cyber Law

Jurisdiction in cyber offences: where the case can be filed

A cyber offence can be reported at any police station, because the procedure requires the station to register the information and transfer it to the station with jurisdiction. The trial is held where the offence was committed or where its consequence followed, and for online conduct the place where the victim accessed the material, or where the loss was suffered, is commonly accepted. That means a Kolkata victim is not sent to another state to pursue a complaint about an account operated from there.

The general rule, and its cyber application

The criminal procedure code fixes the ordinary place of inquiry and trial at the place where the offence was committed. It also provides that where an offence is committed partly in one place and partly in another, or where the act and its consequence occur in different places, the case may be tried in either place.

Cyber offences rarely have a single location. The offender may be in one state, the server in another country, the victim in Kolkata and the money transferred through a bank in a fourth place. The courts have applied the "consequence" limb to hold that the place where the victim suffered the effect has jurisdiction. A defamatory post read in Kolkata, a phishing transfer debited in Kolkata, an account hacked from anywhere with the loss felt in Kolkata — each is ordinarily triable in Kolkata.

The consequence must be real, not manufactured. A victim who deliberately accesses material in a chosen district in order to create jurisdiction invites an objection. In practice, the victim's ordinary residence and the place where the loss was suffered are what support the complaint.

The zero-FIR procedure

The criminal procedure provides that information about a cognisable offence may be given at any police station, whether or not it has jurisdiction, and the station must register it and forward it to the station having jurisdiction. This is the zero-FIR, and it exists precisely so that a complainant is not turned away.

A police station that refuses to register a cyber complaint on the ground of jurisdiction is acting contrary to the provision. The complainant can then send a written complaint to the Commissioner of Police or the Superintendent of Police, who may investigate or direct a subordinate to do so, and can also move the Magistrate with a complaint.

In Kolkata, complaints of cybercrime are handled by the Kolkata Police's cyber crime unit, and the local police station forwards the complaint to it. The National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal generates a reference that can be cited at the police station, and the police can access the portal's back end for the complaint.

Which court tries the case

The trial court is determined by the offence and by the place. Offences under the Information Technology Act are tried by the designated court in the district, and the general offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita are tried by the Magistrate or the Sessions Court according to the punishment. A cyber fraud involving cheating, or an offence of stalking, is ordinarily tried by the Magistrate; a graver offence with a longer punishment goes to the Sessions Court.

When offences under the Information Technology Act and general offences are charged together, the case is tried by the court that would try the graver offence, and the special provisions of the Information Technology Act apply to the offences under that Act.

Victim compensation is dealt with by the trial court under the state's victim compensation scheme, and a court that convicts can order compensation to the victim under the criminal procedure provisions.

Extra-territorial reach

The Information Technology Act applies to offences committed outside India by any person, where the act involves a computer, a computer system or a network located in India. That is a wide provision, and it is what allows a case to be registered where the offender is abroad but the resource is in India.

Enforcement across borders then depends on mutual legal assistance requests and on the cooperation of the foreign service provider. The practical remedy in most cross-border cases is the takedown and the account suspension obtained from the platform, and the criminal case proceeds against the accused if he is ever located.

Where the offender is in a jurisdiction with which India has an arrangement, the investigating agency can seek the records through the central authority. The request is routed through the Ministry of Home Affairs, and it takes time.

Practical points for the complainant

  1. File on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal and note the reference.
  2. Give the complaint at the nearest police station and ask for a copy of the FIR or the acknowledgement with the crime number.
  3. Where the station refuses, write to the Commissioner with the portal reference and a request for a direction to register.
  4. Keep the evidence preserved as the criminal process may take months to reach the electronic records.
  5. Ask for the subscriber details of the offending account or number to be obtained from the service provider through the police, because those details will not be released to the complainant directly.

The service provider route matters. An internet service provider or a messaging platform will not disclose subscriber data to a private complainant; it responds to a police requisition or to a court order. That is why the police complaint is the gateway to the evidence, and why the complaint should specify what data is needed and why.

Jurisdiction is a question for the police and the court, not a reason for the complainant to be turned away. Register the complaint, and let the transfer happen.

Common questions

Can the case be transferred to another state?

Yes. Where the offender is identified and the evidence is elsewhere, the investigating agency can coordinate with the other state's police, and a case may be transferred. The trial ordinarily remains where the FIR was registered in the first instance unless a higher court orders a transfer.

What if the offence was committed entirely abroad?

Where a computer resource in India is involved, the Act's extraterritorial provision can apply. The complaint can be registered, and the case depends on locating the accused and on international cooperation for the evidence.

Is a complaint to the platform a substitute for the FIR?

No. The platform report may get the content removed, but it does not start a criminal proceeding or obtain the subscriber data. Both are needed, and the platform report should quote the police reference.

File on the portal, file at the police station, and keep the reference numbers. Our cyber law practice handles these complaints in Kolkata, cyber fraud covers the financial cases, and FIR matters covers the position of a person wrongly accused.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422