A tribunal does two different things with income, depending on whether the victim died or survived. In a death claim it takes the annual income, adds an allowance for future prospects, and capitalises the result by a multiplier. In an injury claim it asks what the injured person can no longer earn, which is a question about capacity rather than about salary. Both start from evidence, and neither rewards a bare assertion.
The three kinds of income evidence
The first is the salaried employee, whose income is proved by the salary certificate, the bank statement and the income tax return. The tribunal takes gross income and deducts the tax actually payable, not the tax that might have been payable on a higher estimate. Allowances that would have continued are included; reimbursements that merely cover actual expenditure are not.
The second is the self-employed trader or professional, whose income is proved by the return, the books, the GST filings and the testimony of customers or patients. A shopkeeper in Burrabazar and a consultant in Salt Lake present very different evidence, and the tribunal weighs it accordingly. Where the return is modest but the lifestyle is not, the tribunal does not usually accept the lifestyle as proof of income; it asks for accounts.
The third is the person with no documentary proof at all: the daily labourer, the domestic worker, the driver paid in cash. Here the tribunal may take the minimum wage for the category of work, or make a reasoned estimate. It cannot take a figure from the air, and an award that does so is vulnerable on appeal.
Why future prospects are added
Compensation is for what the victim would have earned over the years, and a younger person's income would have grown. The settled approach adds a proportion to the established income: a higher addition where the victim was under forty and had stable work, a lower one in the forties, a lower one still in the fifties, and none after sixty. The proportions were fixed by the Constitution Bench in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi and are now applied as a matter of course.
Two conditions matter. The income must be established, because prospects are a percentage of something. And the employment must suggest stability; a person on a fixed-term contract nearing its end is a different case from a government servant with decades of service left. For the self-employed, the addition is applied to the proved income in the same way, though tribunals are slower to assume growth in an unstable business.
Deduction for the victim's own expenses
The income plus prospects is not the family's loss in full. Part of it the victim would have spent on himself. The tribunal deducts a proportion that falls as the number of dependants rises: roughly a third where there are two or three dependants, a quarter for four to six, a fifth for more, and half where there is a single dependant. The deduction is arithmetic, not moral; a tribunal that deducts half because the family was well off is making an error.
Injury cases: capacity, not salary
Where the victim survived, the question changes. The tribunal asks about loss of earning capacity, which depends on the nature of the injury, the victim's age, occupation and qualifications, and the extent of permanent disability. A fifty per cent disability to a keyboard operator and a fifty per cent disability to a loader are not the same loss, even though the medical certificate uses the same words.
The disability certificate from a government medical board is the starting point, and the treating doctor's evidence explains what it means functionally. Tribunals then apply the disability percentage to the income to arrive at the annual loss, and capitalise it by the multiplier for the victim's age. Where the injury is minor but permanent, the award may instead be a lump sum for loss of amenities and pain.
Separate heads are available for income lost during treatment and recuperation, for the extra expenditure caused by the disability, for the cost of future medical care where the evidence supports it, and for the loss of marriage prospects in a young unmarried victim where that is proved. Each needs a factual foundation: the number of months off work, the bills, the doctor's prognosis.
What tribunals get wrong, and how it is corrected
The common errors are mechanical. Applying the multiplier for the wrong age. Adding prospects in a case where income was never proved, so that the percentage is applied to a figure the tribunal itself invented. Deducting for personal expenses in a case where the deceased had no dependants and the claim is by the estate. Taking the disability percentage from the certificate without asking what the victim actually did for a living.
These errors are corrected on appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act before the Calcutta High Court, which hears the appeal on facts as well as law. That is the practical reason the tribunal's reasoning matters: an award that shows its working is harder to disturb than one that states a conclusion, and it is also easier to improve if the working is wrong.
Evidence worth collecting early
- Twelve months of salary slips, the bank statement and the latest return, with the acknowledgement.
- For a business, the audited accounts, the GST returns and a few invoices showing the scale of trade.
- The employment contract or appointment letter, which shows the nature of the job and its stability.
- For a daily wage worker, the contractor's certificate, the muster roll or the evidence of the employer.
- The disability certificate, the discharge summary, the follow-up prescriptions and, where future surgery is likely, the doctor's estimate.
Documents collected within weeks of the accident are more persuasive than documents assembled a year later, partly because their authenticity is easier to accept and partly because the tribunal's view of the claimant is formed early. Our motor accident practice builds the income file before the claim is filed, and civil litigation support is available where the award needs to be challenged.
Common questions
Is the gross salary or the take-home salary used?
Gross income less the income tax actually payable. Deductions such as provident fund contributions are not subtracted as if they were lost, because they accrue to the employee. The tribunal's aim is the income available to the family, not the credit to the bank account.
Can future prospects be claimed for a self-employed person?
Yes, where the income is proved and the business suggests continuity. The tribunal applies the same proportions to the proved income. What it will not do is assume growth for a business that was already failing.
What if the injured person returns to the same job?
Return to work reduces but does not necessarily eliminate the claim. If the person works in pain, has lost promotion prospects, or must employ help, those are losses the tribunal can recognise. The medical evidence must support the effect on working life.
Does a higher income always mean a higher award?
Usually, but not automatically. The dependency ratio, the multiplier for age, and the quality of the proof all matter. A large claimed income that is not documented can produce a smaller award than a modest income that is.
Income is the hinge on which a motor accident claim turns, and it is the part most within the claimant's control. If you have an accident file, or an award that looks wrong on its face, bring it to the office; the consultation fee is ₹2,000 and is published.