A person who is induced to marry on a false profile, a concealed first marriage, or a fabricated employment and income can ask a family court to annul the marriage, and can also pursue the conduct as a criminal offence. The two remedies are independent: a decree of nullity fixes the status, and a conviction punishes the deception. Most victims pursue only one, usually the criminal case, and are then unable to extricate themselves from the marriage.
The civil remedy: annulment
Under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, a marriage is void where either party had a spouse living, or where the parties are within the prohibited degrees of relationship, unless the custom permits the marriage. Where the marriage is void, no decree dissolving it is needed, but a declaration of nullity can be sought, and in practice the declaration is what the registrar, the bank and the immigration authority will want.
A marriage is voidable where the consent of the petitioner was obtained by force or by fraud as to the nature of the ceremony or as to any material fact or circumstance concerning the respondent. Concealment of a subsisting marriage, of a serious mental or physical condition, or of a fact that would have altered the decision to marry, can fall within this ground, depending on the facts. A petition on this ground must be filed within the period the Act allows, which makes delay dangerous.
Where the fraud does not fit the statutory ground, the marriage can still be ended by divorce on the ground of cruelty or desertion, and the deception is pleaded as part of the cruelty. The relief available depends on the personal law that governs the parties; for a marriage registered under the Special Marriage Act, the grounds are in that statute, and for a Christian marriage they are in the Divorce Act.
The criminal side
Where money, property or a valuable benefit was obtained by the false representation, the offence is cheating, and where a false document was created or used, the offence is forgery. A fabricated profile on a matrimonial site that is used to induce payments may also attract the information technology offences of identity theft and cheating by personation by means of a computer resource.
Where the person married while a previous marriage subsisted, the offence of bigamy is complete, and the second spouse can prosecute. The formalities matter: the prosecution proceeds on a complaint by the aggrieved spouse under the penal provision that makes the offence punishable on the complaint of the person aggrieved, and the proof consists of the record of the first marriage and the marriage certificate of the second.
Where the deception was accompanied by a demand for property, the anti-dowry provisions may apply, and where there was cruelty, the penal provision on cruelty by the husband or his relatives applies. These are serious allegations, and a complaint that mixes them indiscriminately is the weaker for it.
The conjugal relationship and the Domestic Violence Act
Where the parties lived together as husband and wife after a sham marriage, the woman may be able to claim protection under the domestic violence legislation, which covers a relationship in the nature of marriage. The courts have set conditions for that phrase: the couple must hold themselves out to society as spouses, they must have lived together as spouses for a significant period, they must be of the age to marry, and the woman must not be a kept mistress receiving money for the relationship. A fraudulent promise of marriage followed by an intimate relationship does not by itself create such a relationship.
The distinction between a relationship in the nature of marriage and a promise of marriage that was broken matters both for the domestic violence remedy and for maintenance. A broken promise is not a marriage, and the remedy for it is the criminal or civil claim for the deception.
Recovering the money
Money handed over in the belief that a marriage would take place, or spent on the fraudulent representation, is recoverable. A suit for recovery can be filed against the person who took it, and an interim attachment of his assets may be sought where he is likely to dispose of them. A decree is the practical remedy where the amount is significant, because the criminal case may end in a fine that does not compensate the victim.
A claim for damages in tort for deceit is also possible, and it allows the recovery of losses that are consequential on the representation. The two claims are usually pleaded together.
Getting the fake profile removed
Matrimonial and social platforms have grievance mechanisms under the information technology rules. A complaint to the grievance officer, with the profile link, the screenshots, the identification of the false statements and the complaint number from the police, usually results in removal. Where the platform does not act, a court order can direct removal, and the platform will comply with a direction.
Preserve the profile before it is deleted: a full page capture showing the uniform resource locator and the date, the messages exchanged, the photographs used, and any payment records. A deleted profile that was never captured is difficult to prove, and the investigation then depends entirely on the platform's own records.
Which forum, in Kolkata
A petition for nullity or divorce is filed in the family court that has jurisdiction, which is determined by where the marriage took place, where the parties last lived together, or where the respondent resides. For parties within Kolkata, that is the family court at Kolkata; for South 24 Parganas it is at Alipore, and for North 24 Parganas at Barasat. Where the marriage was registered under the Special Marriage Act, the district court's jurisdiction follows the place of registration as well.
The criminal complaint for cheating or forgery is filed before the magistrate having jurisdiction over the place where the offence was committed, which for a fraud conducted over the internet is usually where the victim resides or receives the communication. The cyber offences may be reported to the cyber crime cell of the Kolkata Police at the headquarters at Lalbazar, or at the local police station. Both the family and the criminal proceedings can run at the same time, and the pleadings should be consistent.
Our family law practice and divorce practice handle the nullity and divorce petitions, and cyber fraud handles the deception conducted over the internet.
Common questions
Can I annul a marriage if my spouse lied about income and employment?
Possibly, if the lie concerns a material fact or circumstance concerning the respondent and induced the consent. The ground is construed with care, and the petition must be filed within the statutory period.
Is a marriage void if the first spouse is alive?
Yes, subject to the exceptions for a marriage permitted by custom in certain communities. A declaration of nullity can be sought, and the offence of bigamy can be prosecuted on the complaint of the aggrieved spouse.
Can I get my money back if the marriage did not take place?
Yes. A suit for recovery of the money paid, and a claim for damages for deceit, are available, and the criminal case for cheating can run alongside.
Does a promise to marry create a legal relationship?
Not a marriage. A relationship in the nature of marriage requires the conditions the courts have laid down, such as cohabitation and holding out to society. A broken promise is dealt with as a claim for the deception.
Fix the status first, then pursue the deception. If you are dealing with a false profile or a concealed prior marriage, contact the office; the consultation fee is published.