14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Criminal Law

Medical examination in custody and the rights around it

Every person arrested and kept in custody is entitled to a medical examination, and the report of that examination is a document with three uses: it records injuries that may have been caused in custody, it establishes the state of health on the day of arrest, and it can support a request for hospital treatment or for release. Medical examination custody rights are not a favour to the arrested person. They are part of the procedure, and the omission of the examination is itself a defect in the custody.

Families usually learn about the examination only after the first production, when a magistrate asks whether the medical report is on record. By then a week may have passed and the injuries may have healed. The practical task is to ask for the examination early, to ask for a copy of the report, and to insist that the request and the reply are recorded.

What the rules require

Section 53 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 provides for the examination of an arrested person by a medical officer. The examination is to be conducted at the request of the investigating officer, and the report is to be furnished to the court and, on request, to the arrested person or his lawyer. The examination must record the injuries, if any, and the medical officer's opinion on the person's fitness for custody.

The rules go further where the arrested person alleges that the examination was conducted by someone other than a doctor, or that the person was subjected to ill-treatment. In those cases a fresh examination by a doctor at a hospital is required, and the report must be preserved. Where the arrested person is a woman, the examination must be conducted by or under the supervision of a woman medical officer, and the modesty safeguards apply.

Where the person is in custody for a long period, the question of medical attention does not end with the first examination. A prisoner who falls ill in judicial custody is entitled to treatment at the government hospital, and the jail authorities must send him there. The right is enforceable by an application to the magistrate, and in a serious case by a writ petition.

Why the first examination matters most

Injuries are dated by the medical report. A bruise that is three days old looks different from one that is three hours old, and a report prepared on the day of arrest fixes the time. Where the person alleges that he was beaten at the station, the report of the first examination is the evidence that either supports the allegation or weakens it beyond repair.

The report also fixes the medical history. If the person is diabetic, asthmatic or on medication, the record made on the first day is what the jail and the court will act on. A person whose condition is recorded can obtain treatment; a person whose condition is discovered three weeks later in the jail hospital will be asked why he did not mention it.

And the report can keep the person out of custody altogether. A medical opinion that the person needs hospital care, or that he is unfit for custody, supports a bail application or an application for treatment at a hospital. Magistrates act on a doctor's opinion; they do not act on a family's assurance.

Getting the examination done, and getting the report

  1. At the police station or at the court lock-up, ask for the examination. Put the request in writing, and keep a copy.
  2. Attend the examination if the person is a juvenile or a woman, where the rules permit the presence of a family member or a support person.
  3. Ask the examining doctor to record every complaint, including pain, old injuries and any allegation of assault, and to state the opinion on fitness for custody.
  4. Apply to the court for a copy of the report. The court can direct that it be given, and the request is made in the bail or remand application.
  5. Where the report is silent on an alleged injury, apply for a fresh examination at a government hospital, and ask the court to record the request and the order.

Where the police refuse to send the person for examination, the refusal should be recorded in writing and raised at the first production. The magistrate can direct the examination there and then, and the direction is complied with on the same day.

Second opinion and the hospital route

Where the person disputes the report — because it was conducted perfunctorily, because the doctor was known to the investigating officer, or because the injuries were not recorded — the remedy is an application for examination at a government hospital, preferably a teaching hospital, by a doctor not connected with the station. In Kolkata the examination is ordinarily conducted at a government hospital, and the court can direct the specific hospital.

The application should set out what the person complains of, who examined him, what the report says and what it omits, and should ask for a fresh examination with a direction that the report be placed before the court. A bald assertion that the report is false is not enough; the specific omission is what persuades.

Where the person is in judicial custody, the application is made to the magistrate having jurisdiction over the case or to the jail visiting magistrate. The jail authorities must produce the medical record of the prisoner's treatment, and the court can call for it.

Ill-treatment in custody: the separate complaint

An allegation of assault in custody is a separate matter from the medical examination, and it should be pursued on its own track. The complaint is made in writing to the officer in charge, to the superintendent of police, and to the magistrate, with the medical report attached. Where the allegation is serious, a complaint can also be made to the State Human Rights Commission and to the police complaints authority.

The forensic value of the medical report is decisive in such a complaint. A report that records tenderness and an abrasion on the wrist, with the time noted, is worth more than a page of narrative. Where the report records nothing, the complaint should say why a fresh examination was demanded and when, so that the omission itself becomes the issue.

The magistrate before whom the person is produced has the power to order an enquiry into the allegation, and to direct that the person be examined at a hospital. This is one of the few remedies available in the first twenty-four hours, and it should be sought at the first production.

Women, juveniles and the special safeguards

For a woman in custody, the examination must be conducted by a woman medical officer, and the rules on the presence of others apply. A woman arrested must not be kept in the same lock-up as a man, and the search must follow the prescribed safeguards. Where these are breached, the breach is a ground for complaint and for an application for release.

For a juvenile, the medical examination is part of the procedure before the Juvenile Justice Board, and the Board must be informed of the child's health. The child cannot be kept in a police lock-up, and the examination is conducted at a hospital with a parent or guardian present where the rules allow. The rules on juvenile custody are stricter than those for adults, and the board oversees them.

Our page on criminal law sets out the procedure before the magistrates' courts, and anticipatory bail covers the position before an arrest.

Common questions

Is a medical examination compulsory for every arrest?

Yes, on the arrest of a person, the examination is part of the prescribed procedure. The examining officer's report must be obtained, and it must be produced before the court at the first production. A station that skips the step is skipping a legal requirement.

Can the family request the examination?

The family can ask the station, and can ask the court. The formal request is made by the investigating officer, but a written request from the family or the lawyer should be submitted and acknowledged, because it puts the station on notice and creates a record for the remand hearing.

Who pays for the treatment?

Treatment at a government hospital is provided by the state. Where the person is in judicial custody, the jail authorities arrange the transfer. Where a private hospital is involved, the cost is a matter for the family, though the court can direct that emergency treatment be provided and the cost recovered later.

Does the report go to the accused?

On request, and on the court's direction, the report is furnished to the arrested person or his lawyer. It is part of the material the prosecution must disclose, and it is relied on in the bail application. Ask for it in writing at the first production rather than at the trial.

If someone has been arrested within the last day, the examination and the report are the two things to secure before anything else. Call the office, or bring the arrest papers to the consultation, and if the first production is today, come to court with the request already written.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422