14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

Medical records: the patient's right to copies

A patient is entitled to copies of his medical records, and a hospital or doctor who refuses without a lawful reason is exposed to a consumer complaint, a regulatory complaint and, in a government hospital, a writ petition. The patient right medical records rests less on one statute than on a set of instruments read together, which is why hospitals sometimes argue about it and why a written request framed properly ends the argument quickly.

The four sources of the right

The first is professional regulation. The ethics regulations framed under the Indian Medical Council framework require a doctor to maintain records for his in-patients and to supply copies on request. The same regulations set out how long records are kept and the period within which copies must be furnished, which is measured in days rather than weeks. A doctor who says records are confidential is confusing confidentiality with custody: confidentiality governs disclosure to third parties, not access by the patient himself.

The second is consumer law. A patient is a consumer of medical services, and a hospital's failure to provide records that the patient needs to assess his own treatment is capable of being a deficiency in service. A consumer complaint for medical negligence frequently begins with an application for the records, because the patient cannot plead a case without them.

The third is the state's clinical establishments legislation. West Bengal enacted its own law regulating clinical establishments, and it set up a regulatory commission in Kolkata with powers over registered establishments, including obligations about records and about furnishing them. The commission is a forum that costs a patient far less than a court.

The fourth is the data protection framework. The statute on personal data gives an individual rights over his own personal data held by a data fiduciary, including a right to access. A hospital holds health data and is a data fiduciary in relation to it. That right is separate from, and additional to, the medical records right, and the two should be invoked together in a refusal case.

What the record actually contains

Patients usually ask for "the file" and are handed a discharge summary. The record is broader: the admission record, the case sheet with the daily notes, the nursing notes, the investigation reports including images, the operation notes, the anaesthesia record, the consent forms, the medication chart, the discharge summary, and the correspondence between treating doctors. Where the treatment was in an intensive care unit, the monitoring charts matter more than the summary.

Ask for the record by description, not by a general word. A request that lists categories is harder to answer with a summary, and it creates a record of what was asked for if the response is incomplete.

Where imaging was done, the images themselves are part of the record, not only the radiologist's report. A CT or MRI film can be re-read by another radiologist, and that re-reading is often the whole case.

How to ask, and what to send

The request should be in writing, addressed to the medical records department of the hospital and copied to the medical superintendent or the director. It should identify the patient by name, age, the admission number and the dates of admission and discharge, list the documents wanted, state the purpose, and give a date by which the copies are requested.

  • Proof of identity of the patient, and of the person collecting the copies where it is not the patient.
  • A signed authorisation where a family member is collecting on the patient's behalf.
  • For a deceased patient, proof of death and proof of the applicant's relationship, since the hospital will want to satisfy itself that it is not disclosing to a stranger.
  • The hospital's own requisition form, where it insists on one, filled and attached rather than substituted for the letter.
  • Payment of the copying charge, which is a reasonable per-page charge and not a fee the hospital may set at will to deter requests.

Keep a receipted copy of the letter. A hospital that receives a written request and does not answer it has created the very evidence the patient needs, and a hospital that answers orally has not answered at all.

What may lawfully be withheld

Some redaction is legitimate. Information about a third party, such as a donor or another patient named in the notes, may be masked. Where the record contains the identity of a person who reported a communicable disease, the disclosure rules under the public health framework may restrict it. Mental health records are governed by their own statute, which gives a person access to his records but allows the treating psychiatrist to withhold a part where disclosure would cause harm to the patient or to another person.

What is not legitimate is withholding the whole file because it is "hospital property", because "the doctor is not available", or because a negligence claim is anticipated. Records belong to the hospital in the sense of custody, but the patient's right of access is a statutory and professional obligation, and the hospital's interest in defending a claim is not a ground for refusal.

There is a practical limit that patients should know: a hospital is not obliged to create a document that does not exist, and a missing record is itself a fact that a court will weigh. If the case sheet cannot be produced, the inference tends to run against the hospital.

Where to complain when the answer is no

The cheapest route is the clinical establishment regulator. A complaint to the commission in Kolkata can be filed by the patient or a family member, and it can result in a direction to furnish the records. It is quicker than a court and does not need a plaint.

The second route is the consumer commission. A complaint before the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Kolkata, or the state commission for a larger claim, can seek the records and compensation for the refusal. A legal notice before the complaint is often enough, because the hospital's own legal advisers know the exposure.

The third route is a writ petition. Where the hospital is a government hospital or a public institution, a writ petition before the Calcutta High Court is available, and it compels the production of records as a matter of public duty. Courts have consistently treated the withholding of records from a patient, or from the family of a patient who died, as arbitrary.

The fourth is an application under the data protection framework to the Data Protection Board, where the hospital is a data fiduciary and has refused a request for access without a lawful basis.

Records after a death, and records for a claim

After a patient dies, the right to the records passes to the persons entitled to pursue the estate's claims, which in practice means the spouse, children or parents, and the hospital will usually ask for a declaration of the legal heirs, a death certificate, and identity proof. Where the death is under investigation, the police will have taken custody of the case sheet, and the family's request should be made to the investigating officer as well as the hospital.

For an insurance claim, the hospital's discharge summary and the final bill are usually enough, and the insurer's own form authorises the hospital to release them. For a negligence claim, the full record is needed, and the earlier it is collected the better, because notes get condensed and memories fade.

Time limits matter in the underlying claim. A consumer complaint has a limitation period running from the date of the deficiency, and a civil suit has its own. A patient who spends a year chasing records can find the claim itself has become vulnerable, so the request should be made at the same time as the advice is taken, not after.

Common questions

Can a hospital charge for copies of my records?

Yes, a reasonable charge per page is normal and is not a refusal. What is not acceptable is a charge set so high that it defeats the right, or a demand for a lump sum unrelated to the volume of copying. Ask for the hospital's schedule of charges in writing, and pay by a mode that leaves a receipt.

Can the hospital refuse because the doctor who treated me has left?

No. The obligation to maintain and furnish records is the hospital's and the treating institution's, not the individual doctor's. A hospital that employed or engaged the doctor holds the record and must produce it, and the doctor's departure is a matter between the hospital and him.

Am I entitled to the records of a relative who died in hospital?

Yes, as a person entitled to pursue the estate's claims, subject to proving the relationship and the death. Hospitals commonly ask for a legal heir declaration and an indemnity. Where the hospital insists on a succession certificate for the release of records, that is usually an overreach and can be challenged before the commission.

Do records have to be kept for a fixed number of years?

The professional regulations prescribe retention periods, which differ for in-patient records and for medico-legal cases, and the clinical establishments law adds its own. In practice, hospitals retain in-patient records for a period measured in years and medico-legal records for longer. A patient should not assume the record exists forever, which is the strongest practical reason to ask early.

A request in writing, listing the documents, signed and receipted, is the whole of the practical advice. It costs nothing, it puts the hospital on notice, and if the answer is a refusal it converts the patient from a supplicant into a complainant with a document in his hand. In a negligence case the record is the case; a patient who obtains it early is the one who can test it.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422