14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Corporate & Insolvency

MSME registration and delayed payment protection

A micro or small enterprise that supplies goods or services on credit is entitled to payment within forty-five days, and to compound interest on anything that runs beyond that. The right does not depend on a clause in the contract; it comes from the MSMED Act, 2006. What the Udyam registration does is prove the status that the right depends on.

Who the protection covers

The Act applies to micro and small enterprises, as classified. The classification turns on the investment in plant and machinery and, after a later notification, on turnover as well, with the thresholds revised from time to time. Service enterprises are covered too, which matters because a surprising number of suppliers think the Act is only for manufacturers.

Registration is by filing a memorandum, now done online through the Udyam portal, on the basis of the enterprise's PAN, GST details and the promoter's Aadhaar. The certificate is issued immediately and carries a permanent registration number. Suppliers should print the Udyam certificate and put the number on every invoice, because the buyer's obligation under the Act begins with notice of the supplier's status.

Where a supplier is not registered, the position is less certain. The Act's benefit is expressed in terms of micro and small enterprises rather than registered ones, and the registration is the ordinary evidence of that status. A supplier who has the characteristics of a small enterprise but no certificate will spend the first hearing of a claim arguing about his own status instead of the buyer's default. Register.

The forty-five day rule and how the clock runs

The Act requires the buyer to make payment on or before the date agreed in writing, which cannot exceed forty-five days from the day of acceptance or the day of deemed acceptance of the goods or services. Where there is no written agreement, the period is fifteen days. Any agreement providing for a longer period is void to the extent it exceeds forty-five days.

Acceptance means the day the buyer actually accepts the goods or services, and where the buyer does not object within fifteen days of delivery, the day of deemed acceptance is the day of delivery. This is the provision suppliers use most often, because buyers routinely take delivery, raise no objection and pay late.

Two practical consequences follow. Invoices should state the date of delivery and the date on which payment falls due under the Act, so that the file shows the calculation. And the buyer's silence for fifteen days should be recorded in the supplier's ledger, not merely assumed.

The interest, and its rate

Where the buyer fails to pay within the statutory period, the Act obliges him to pay compound interest at three times the bank rate notified by the Reserve Bank, on the outstanding amount, for the period of delay. The interest is compound and not simple, which is what gives the provision its teeth, and the entitlement does not require the supplier to prove loss.

The supplier must claim it. A demand notice or a statement of account should show the principal and the interest separately, with the rate and the period, so that the buyer cannot later argue that the interest was never quantified. The demand that carries the calculation is drafted in the form shown on our recovery notice page.

The Facilitation Council, and how a reference works

Where the buyer does not pay, the supplier may make a reference to the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council. In West Bengal the Council is constituted under the Act with its office in Kolkata, and a supplier dealing with a Kolkata buyer will find the forum familiar. References are made in a prescribed form, with the invoices, the delivery proof, the correspondence and a statement of the amount claimed with interest.

The Council first attempts conciliation, either itself or through a centre it designates. If conciliation fails, the Council refers the dispute to arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and the Council or the centre may itself act as arbitrator. The award is enforceable as if it were a decree of a civil court, which is the practical advantage of the route over a suit. The conduct of that reference is dealt with under arbitration.

The fee is nominal compared with a civil suit, and the Council's awards have been upheld repeatedly by the High Courts on the substantive entitlement to interest. The main challenge in practice is delay in the arbitration, and a supplier should keep the reference tight and documentary to move it along.

Where the buyer is the one who suffers

Buyers should note the procurement consequence. A company that buys from a micro or small supplier and pays in ninety days is not merely slow; it is liable for compound interest at three times the bank rate, recoverable through a fast-track arbitration, and the amount can be recovered as arrears in the manner the Act provides. Large buyers have lost references on invoices that their own accounts department considered routine.

The other exposure is the tax one. The Income Tax Act restricts the deduction of the expenditure where payment to a micro or small enterprise is not made within the period the MSMED Act allows, so a late payer can lose the deduction as well as pay interest.

What a claim needs

  1. The Udyam certificate showing micro or small status on the date of supply.
  2. The purchase order or the contract, and the invoices with the Udyam number quoted.
  3. Proof of delivery or of performance of the service, and the buyer's acceptance or the fifteen days' silence that follows delivery.
  4. The ledger showing what was paid and when.
  5. A demand notice claiming the principal and the interest, with the calculation.
  6. The reference to the Facilitation Council in the prescribed form, with the fee.

A supplier whose buyer is in another state needs to consider which Council has jurisdiction, since the Act and the rules deal with the location of the buyer and of the supplier, and the position has been litigated. For a West Bengal supplier dealing with a Kolkata buyer the question does not arise, and the reference goes to the Council in Kolkata.

The remedy is not exclusive

The supplier keeps the ordinary civil remedy as well, and can sue on the invoice where a summary suit is available. The Council route is quicker and cheaper, and it carries the interest entitlement on the face of the statute, which is why it is usually tried first. Where the buyer is in insolvency proceedings, the supplier lodges the claim with the resolution professional and keeps the interest claim alive as part of it. That route is set out under recovery suits.

Common questions

Does the Act apply if the contract says payment in ninety days?

No. Any agreement that provides for a period longer than forty-five days is void to the extent of the excess, so the ninety-day term does not displace the statutory period. The buyer pays interest for the period beyond forty-five days.

Can interest be claimed if the invoice did not mention the MSME number?

Yes, the entitlement comes from the Act and not from the invoice. The invoice helps prove that the buyer knew of the status, which matters where the buyer claims he did not.

Is Udyam registration different from the old Udyog Aadhaar?

Udyam replaced Udyog Aadhaar as the registration system, and registrations were migrated. A supplier with an old certificate should confirm the position on the Udyam portal and download the current certificate before making a reference.

What if the buyer disputes delivery or quality?

A genuine dispute about whether the goods conformed reduces or defeats the claim, and it has to be supported by the buyer's contemporaneous record, such as an inspection report or a rejection note sent within fifteen days. A buyer who raises quality for the first time in the arbitration rarely succeeds.

The Act gives a small supplier a lever that a large buyer cannot bargain away. The invoice that carries the Udyam number, states the delivery date and notes the due date is the whole foundation of that lever, and it costs nothing to write.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422