The nominee collects the money; the heirs own it. That single sentence answers most disputes over a dead person's bank balance, shares and mutual fund units in India. A nomination is a direction to the institution about who may give a valid discharge, not a substitute for a will, and not an instrument of succession. The exception is a life insurance policy, where a nominee in the permitted relationship takes beneficially. The nomination vs succession bank question is really a question about two different laws touching the same asset, and once that is separated the rest follows.
The confusion is understandable, because the bank pays the nominee without asking any questions and the family treats that payment as a decision on title. It is not. The bank is discharging its own liability, and once it has done so its role is over. What happens between the nominee and the other heirs is a separate legal question that the bank never decides.
What a nomination actually is
A nomination is a statutory facility that lets a depositor or holder name a person to whom the institution may pay in the event of death. For bank deposits with banking companies it comes from the Banking Regulation Act, which permits a depositor to nominate a person and provides that the nominee receives the deposit on death. For shares and debentures, the Companies Act allows a holder to nominate, and the company registers the nomination. Mutual fund unit holders nominate under the regulations framed by the securities regulator. Provident fund accounts carry a nomination under the scheme rules.
In each of these, the enacting provision is written as a receipt provision. It tells the institution that payment to the nominee is a good discharge. It does not say the nominee becomes the owner. Courts have read these provisions consistently: the nominee holds the money for the persons entitled under the law of succession, and must hand it over to them. Where the family needs to establish that entitlement formally, the route is a claim to establish the heirs' title rather than a complaint against the bank.
Insurance is the place where the analysis changes, and it is worth separating out because families assume the same rule applies everywhere.
Where the nominee takes beneficially
Under the Insurance Act, a policy holder may nominate a person to receive the policy money. The Act was amended some years ago to create a category of beneficial nominee: where the nominee is the spouse, a parent or a child of the policy holder, the nomination operates so that the nominee is entitled to the policy money to the exclusion of other heirs. Where the nominee is anyone else, the older rule applies and the nominee collects as a trustee for the heirs.
That distinction is why a man who names his brother on a life policy and names his wife on his bank deposit has made two very different arrangements. The wife collects the deposit for the heirs; the brother may take the policy money for himself, subject to the terms of the policy and any claim that the nomination was procured improperly.
A will can still override a nomination, because a nomination is not a testamentary instrument and can be revoked or superseded by a later will that deals with the same asset. Where there is a will, the executor's claim is to the asset, not merely to the residue.
The claim a bank will actually process
In practice the bank asks for a small, predictable set of papers: the death certificate in original or a verified copy, a claim form signed by the nominee, proof of identity and address of the claimant, and the passbook or deposit receipt. Where the nomination is registered and the amount is within the bank's settlement limit for nominee claims, the bank pays on that basis. Where there is no nomination, the bank's board-approved policy will usually require a succession certificate, a probate, or a letter of administration, together with an indemnity and a declaration from the legal heirs.
Two practical points catch families out. First, the bank's internal limit for paying without a succession certificate is a matter of its own policy and changes; nobody should assume a figure. Second, a joint account with a survivorship clause is not a nomination at all, and the survivor takes the balance by the terms of the account, though the heirs may still have a claim against the survivor for their share of the deceased's contribution.
Where the amount is small and the bank is cooperative, an indemnity route is often enough. Where it is not, the family has to obtain a court order, and that is where the delay begins.
Succession certificate and probate in Kolkata
A succession certificate is the order that authorises the holder to collect debts and securities of a person who died without a will. The application is made under the Indian Succession Act to the district judge, and in Kolkata the practice runs either before the original side of the Calcutta High Court or before the City Civil Court, depending on the value of the estate and the court's own pecuniary limits. The application sets out the deceased's particulars, the heirs, the debts and securities, and is supported by the death certificate, the pedigree, and evidence of the applicant's relationship.
The court issues notice to the next of kin and publishes a citation so that any other claimant can appear. If nobody objects and the evidence is accepted, the certificate issues on payment of the court fee, which the state charges on the value of the estate. The rate is fixed by law and revised from time to time, so it has to be confirmed for the current year rather than quoted from memory.
Where there is a will, the route is probate in the same courts, and probate is mandatory for an executor to act where the will deals with immovable property in the presidency towns, Kolkata included. That requirement is a trap for families who hold a will, believe it is self-proving, and find the sub-registrar or the bank unwilling to act on it.
When the dispute actually reaches court
Most nomination disputes never need a full trial. The nominee has the money and the heirs want their share. A legal notice demanding accounts and distribution resolves a fair number, because the nominee's position is weak once he understands that he holds in trust. A properly drafted notice before the suit also fixes the date from which interest and costs can be claimed. If it does not resolve, the heirs can sue for their share, joining the nominee and seeking accounts of what he received.
Where the estate needs to be administered as a whole, an administration suit before the Calcutta High Court's original side is the proper vehicle, and it allows the court to call for accounts from the executor or the person holding assets. For smaller estates, a suit for partition and accounts before the City Civil Court, or before the district court at Alipore or Barasat if the property lies in the districts, will do the same work at less cost. A civil suit of that kind is slower than a notice but it produces an order that the bank and the sub-registrar will act on.
There is also a criminal dimension that families sometimes reach for and usually regret. Retaining money received as a nominee is not, by itself, criminal breach of trust, because the nominee received it lawfully. A criminal complaint without a clear case of dishonest misappropriation usually ends in a final report, and the family has spent a year learning that the remedy was civil.
The steps worth taking while everyone is alive
The cheapest fix is made by the account holder, not the heirs. Make the nomination, keep it current after a marriage or a death in the family, and tell one person where the nomination records are. Where the intention is to benefit one person to the exclusion of others, a nomination is the wrong instrument; a will, or a gift, or a properly drafted trust is.
For a family that has just lost someone, the sequence is: obtain enough death certificates, list every asset and every nomination, write to each institution at once so that the date of intimation is on record, and decide early whether a probate or succession certificate will be needed. Institutions differ in what they will accept, and a single application saves months over four separate negotiations.
Common questions
Can a nominee keep a fixed deposit and refuse to share it with the other heirs?
Not lawfully, where the asset is a bank deposit, shares or mutual fund units. The nominee is entitled to collect and is answerable to the heirs for what he collects. Retaining it is a breach of that obligation and can be enforced by a suit for accounts and the claimant's share. Where the asset is a life policy with a spouse, parent or child as nominee, the position is different and the nominee may be entitled in his own right.
Does a nomination override a will?
No. A nomination is not a testamentary document, and a later will dealing with the same asset prevails over it. Where the will is silent about the asset, the nomination governs collection only, and the asset falls into the residue for distribution under the will.
Is a succession certificate always needed for a bank deposit?
No. Many banks settle nominee claims within their own limit on an indemnity and a declaration, and some settle small no-nomination claims the same way. The requirement for a court order usually appears where there is no nomination, where the amount is large, or where the heirs disagree and the bank will not choose between them. The bank's current policy decides, and it is worth asking in writing before filing anything.
What does a succession certificate cost in West Bengal?
The court fee is charged ad valorem on the value of the debts and securities covered, at a rate fixed by state law, and there is also the cost of publication and of the lawyer's work. The rate should be confirmed against the current schedule rather than estimated, because it has been revised more than once and a wrong estimate misleads the family about whether the exercise is worth it. The fee is also usually much lower than the value the order releases.
Nomination and succession answer different questions. One asks who may receive the money from the institution; the other asks who owns it once received. Treating the first as the second is the single most common cause of a family litigation that nobody wanted, and it is avoidable with a nomination that is current, a will that is clear, and a family that knows which of the two it is dealing with.