A void marriage is one that the law never recognised, and no decree is needed to establish that it is void — though a declaration is usually sought. A voidable marriage is valid until a court annuls it on one of the grounds in the statute, and if no petition is filed within the time allowed, it remains a marriage. The distinction decides everything that follows: status, legitimacy of children, maintenance, and the date from which the parties are treated as unmarried.
Under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, the void grounds are in section 11 and the voidable grounds in section 12. The Special Marriage Act, 1954 has its own equivalent provisions in sections 24 and 25.
The void grounds
Section 11 provides that a marriage is null and void if it contravenes any of three conditions: neither party has a spouse living at the time of the marriage; the parties are not within the sapinda relationship unless custom permits; and the parties are not within the prohibited degrees of relationship unless custom permits.
Bigamy is the commonest. A second marriage performed while the first subsists is void, and the second wife acquires no status as a wife — though the children of that marriage are legitimate under section 16. A marriage within the prohibited degrees, or within the sapinda relationship, is void only if no custom permits it, and the custom must be pleaded and proved with the specificity that the courts demand.
Because a void marriage needs no decree, a civil court can declare it void in a suit for declaration, and a criminal court can proceed on the footing that it never existed. The petition under section 11 is for a declaration, and there is no limitation period for it in the Act.
The voidable grounds
Section 12(1) lists four. First, that the marriage has not been consummated owing to the impotence of either party. Second, that the marriage was solemnised in contravention of the condition relating to the consent of the parties, where the consent was obtained by force or by fraud as to the nature of the ceremony or as to any material fact or circumstance concerning either party. Third, that the consent of the petitioner was obtained by force or fraud, in the wider sense now covered by the same clause. Fourth, that the respondent was pregnant by some person other than the petitioner at the time of the marriage.
Each ground has a proviso. The petition must be presented within one year of the discovery of the fact, and the petitioner must not have cohabited with the respondent after the discovery, or after the time when the force ceased or the fraud came to light. For the pregnancy ground, the petitioner must have been ignorant of the fact at the time of the marriage.
The one-year period is a real bar. A petition filed after the year has expired is dismissed as not maintainable, whatever the merits of the ground.
What the court requires in proof
Impotence is a question of fact and medicine. The court wants the medical evidence, the pleadings must state the specific incapacity alleged, and the evidence must be more than an assertion that the marriage was not consummated. A party who refuses medical examination invites an adverse inference, though the court cannot compel it.
Fraud and force require precision. The pleading must identify the representation, when and by whom it was made, and how it was material. A general allegation that the family concealed the respondent's character, or his income, or his employment, is not a case of fraud as to a material fact unless it is pleaded with particulars. The courts have also held that a representation about the respondent's virginity or previous relationship may be material in an appropriate case, and that the assessment is fact-specific.
Pregnancy by another person is proved by the birth record, the timing of the delivery, and the medical evidence. The one-year limit from the date of the marriage makes this a ground that must be raised quickly.
Children, and section 16
Children of a void or voidable marriage are legitimate under section 16 of the Hindu Marriage Act, whether or not a decree of nullity has been passed. That legitimacy is not complete: the Act confines the children's rights in the property of the parents, and does not give them rights in the property of the parents' relatives as if the marriage were valid.
Where a decree of nullity is passed, the court may still make an order for the custody of the children, and the child's maintenance is a separate question from the parents' status. The child's rights are protected even where the parent's marriage is void, and the certificate of legitimacy is best sought expressly in the nullity proceeding rather than in a later suit.
Maintenance after a nullity decree
The position is different for the two categories. A wife whose marriage is voidable and is annulled may claim maintenance under section 25 of the Act, because the court has the power to make such an order on passing a decree. A woman whose marriage is void from the outset is in a weaker position: the courts have generally held that she is not a "wife" for the purposes of the summary maintenance provision, though some decisions have awarded maintenance to a woman who had lived as a wife under a marriage that appeared valid.
The practical answer is that the claim should be pleaded in the alternative — under the Act's own maintenance provision, and under the summary provision if the relationship was a marriage in fact. That way a finding of nullity does not extinguish the money claim altogether.
Nullity and the age of marriage
A marriage in breach of the age condition in the Hindu Marriage Act is not void under section 11, and it is not voidable under section 12. The child marriage legislation, the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006, makes such a marriage voidable at the option of the child, with its own procedure and its own reliefs. That is a separate statute, and the petition is not the section 12 petition.
The distinction matters because a nullity petition under the Hindu Marriage Act on the ground of age will be dismissed, and the time spent will not be refunded.
Kolkata: the forum and the practical course
A nullity petition is filed before the family court at Kolkata for parties within the city, or the district court at Alipore or Barasat for areas outside its jurisdiction. The petition is a matrimonial cause and follows the same procedure as a divorce petition, with a decree at the end.
Because the relief is a declaration of status, the petition should also seek consequential reliefs — custody, maintenance, and where necessary a declaration about the children — in the same proceeding. A nullity decree that leaves those issues open invites a second proceeding. Our family law practice handles nullity petitions, and the custody practice deals with the orders that usually accompany them.
Can I remarry if my first marriage is void?
Technically yes, because a void marriage does not create a subsisting marriage. Practically, a declaration of nullity should be obtained first, and the second marriage should take place only after the decree or after a clear opinion on the first marriage's invalidity. A person who remarries on his own assessment of voidness risks prosecution for bigamy if the assessment turns out to be wrong.
Is there a time limit for a nullity petition?
For a void marriage under section 11, the Act imposes none. For a voidable marriage under section 12, the petition must be presented within one year of the discovery of the fact, and the petitioner must not have cohabited after the discovery. A petition filed after the year is dismissed, and the marriage then stands.
What happens to the wife's residence if the marriage is annulled?
The annulment ends the status of wife, and with it the basis for a residence order under the domestic violence legislation, which protects a woman in a domestic relationship. Orders already made continue for the period they specify, and the court dealing with the nullity can make interim arrangements for residence and maintenance while the petition is pending. The question should be raised in the nullity proceeding, because after the decree the position is much weaker.
Nullity is a narrow remedy, and it turns on evidence that must be gathered in the first months. Where the ground is impotence or fraud, the medical and documentary record decides the case; where it is bigamy, the first marriage's proof decides it. There is little room for general allegations.
If you are dealing with this now, the page on family law sets out the documents we ask for and the fee for each stage.