14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Corporate & Insolvency

Partnership deed clauses that prevent disputes

Most partnership disputes are not about the law of partnership; they are about a deed that is silent where it should have been specific. Partners who start with a one-page deed drafted by a stationer end up in the City Civil Court arguing about goodwill, drawings and who was authorised to sign the cheque. The clauses that prevent that cost an afternoon to draft. How such a suit is conducted is described under civil litigation.

Capital, contribution and the money question

The deed should state the capital each partner brings, when it is to be paid, and what happens if it is not paid. It should distinguish capital from loans, because a partner who advances money beyond his capital has a claim that ranks differently from his capital on dissolution.

Under the Partnership Act, a partner is not entitled to interest on capital unless the deed provides for it, and a partner is entitled to interest on a loan he advances beyond the amount of capital he agreed to subscribe. Those defaults are unsuitable for most commercial partnerships, so the deed should state the position on interest on capital, interest on drawings, and partners' remuneration, with the figures and the payment cycle. Every one of those is a live source of dispute two years in.

The profit-sharing ratio should be stated as a ratio, and the deed should say how losses are shared. Where the Act's default applies and the deed is silent, losses are shared in the profit ratio, which some partners discover with surprise.

Authority: who can commit the firm

The commonest flashpoint is a purchase or a borrowing that one partner made without consulting the others. The Act gives every partner authority to act in the ordinary course of business, but it also allows the deed to restrict that authority, and to bind third parties to those restrictions where the restriction is known to them. In practice the restriction is enforced against the partner afterwards, not against the supplier who supplied the goods.

The deed should therefore specify: who may sign cheques and for what amount, who may borrow and up to what ceiling, which decisions require the consent of all partners, and which require a majority. Sale of immovable property of the firm, admission of a new partner, borrowing above a stated figure, and appointment of employees above a stated salary are the usual matters reserved to unanimity.

The deed should also provide for banking: the operation of accounts, the mode of signature, and what happens if the authorised partner is unavailable. Two signatures above a stated figure is a simple control that has saved many firms.

Exit clauses: retirement, death and expulsion

The Act's default is rigid. In the absence of a provision, a partner cannot retire without the consent of the others, and a partner who retires does not affect the liability of the firm for acts done before his retirement. The deed should provide for retirement on notice of a stated period, for the valuation of the outgoing partner's share, and for the payment of that share over a stated schedule or a lump sum.

The valuation clause is the one that matters most. It should say how goodwill is valued, whether assets are taken at book value or market value, whether a practitioner or the firm's auditor does the valuation, and whether the outgoing partner is entitled to interest on the unpaid balance. A deed that says "as mutually agreed" leaves the whole question to the court.

Death should be dealt with separately from retirement. The Act treats the death of a partner as a dissolution of the firm unless the deed provides otherwise, and most commercial firms should provide otherwise, with the deceased partner's legal heirs taking the value of the share rather than the position of partners. The deed should name the person who is to continue, the valuation mechanism, and the period within which the heirs are paid. Minors should not be admitted as partners, though a minor may be admitted to the benefits of the firm with the consent of the others.

Expulsion needs a clause and it needs to be exercised properly. The Act permits expulsion only where the deed confers the power and where it is exercised in good faith by a majority. An expelled partner who was not given a proper hearing and a proper notice has won cases on the clause alone.

Records, accounts and information

The deed should fix the accounting year, the date by which accounts are drawn, who audits them, and each partner's right to inspect the books. Without a clause, a partner's access depends on the Act and is often resisted in practice. The deed should also provide for monthly or quarterly drawings against anticipated profits, with a limit, because unreconciled drawings are the most common grievance at the time of a dispute.

Dispute resolution and the clause that saves the firm

A well-drafted arbitration clause keeps the dispute out of court. It should name the seat, which for a Kolkata partnership is Kolkata, the number of arbitrators, the mode of appointment, the language and the applicable law. A clause that says only "disputes shall be referred to arbitration" gives both sides an opportunity to litigate the clause itself.

The deed should also provide for mediation before arbitration, which is cheap and often effective between partners who were once friends. A model page on this site sets out the format used for arbitration agreements.

Registration and stamping

Registration of the firm with the Registrar of Firms is not compulsory, but non-registration has a serious effect: an unregistered firm cannot sue to enforce a contractual right, and cannot claim a set-off, though it can be sued. Partners of an unregistered firm also lose the right to sue for the reliefs the Act provides. Registration is a formality and it should be done.

The deed itself must be stamped under the West Bengal stamp schedule, and a deed that is deficiently stamped cannot be admitted in evidence until the deficit and the penalty are paid. The stamp duty depends on the consideration involved and the schedule in force, and the position should be confirmed with the sub-registrar or the collector of stamps for the transaction in hand. A partnership deed is also usually notarised where it is to be produced before a bank.

Where the partners want limited liability, the alternative structure is a limited liability partnership registered under the LLP Act, 2008, which limits each partner's exposure to his contribution and is governed by an LLP agreement with the same drafting questions. Our page on company and firm formation compares the two. The comparison between the two structures is on our corporate law page.

Common questions

Can a partner be forced out of the firm?

Only in the circumstances the deed provides, and only by the majority and procedure it specifies. Without an expulsion clause, the firm's remedy against a misbehaving partner is a suit for dissolution or for accounts, which is slower and more expensive.

What happens to the firm when a partner dies?

Unless the deed says otherwise, the firm is dissolved on the death of a partner. Most firms want the opposite, so the deed should provide that the remaining partners continue the business and pay the deceased partner's legal representatives the value of his share.

Is the deed enough, or does the firm need to be registered separately?

Both. The deed governs the partners' rights between themselves, and the registration with the Registrar of Firms gives the firm the ability to sue. The Udyam registration, the GST registration and the professional tax registration are separate requirements that depend on the business.

Can a partner withdraw money he has not earned?

Where the deed fixes a drawing limit, drawing beyond it is a breach and the excess is recoverable with interest if the deed provides. Without such a clause, the firm's remedy is through the accounts at dissolution, which is late and unsatisfactory.

The deed is not the place to save money. A partnership that spends a few hours on capital, authority, valuation and arbitration has an agreement that holds when partners disagree, which is the only time an agreement matters.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422