A personal guarantee is a promise to pay a company's debt if the company does not, and it is separate from the loan. When the company defaults, the lender can recover from the guarantor personally, from his personal assets, without first exhausting its remedies against the company. The company's insolvency does not write off the guarantee, and a resolution plan approved for the company does not by itself discharge the guarantor.
What a guarantee is under the Contract Act
A contract of guarantee under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, involves three parties: the surety, the principal debtor and the creditor. The surety's liability is co-extensive with that of the principal debtor, which means that the surety owes exactly what the company owes, no more and no less, unless the guarantee fixes a lower ceiling.
That principle cuts both ways. If the company is not liable at all, the guarantor is not liable. If the debt is partly discharged, the guarantor's liability reduces in the same proportion. But if the company is liable for the whole, the guarantor is liable for the whole, and the lender may proceed against the guarantor first without any obligation to sue the company or to sell the security.
A continuing guarantee covers a series of transactions. It can be revoked by notice as to future transactions, and a guarantee that is not described as continuing covers only the transaction it names. Directors often assume that a guarantee given for one facility does not extend to a later one; the wording decides it.
What the guarantor gives up
By signing, the guarantor gives up several arguments that a borrower would have. The guarantee usually contains a clause that the lender may grant time to the borrower, vary the terms, release securities or compromise with the borrower without affecting the guarantee. Under the Contract Act, such variation would ordinarily discharge a surety, and the clause is there precisely to prevent that. Reading that clause before signing is more important than reading the interest rate.
Many guarantees are also unconditional and payable on demand, which means the lender does not have to demonstrate default before making a demand. A demand made in accordance with the guarantee is itself the trigger for the guarantor's liability.
The guarantee may extend to interest, additional interest, penal charges, costs and expenses. An unlimited guarantee, without a ceiling on the principal or the interest, exposes the guarantor to a liability that grows after the default.
How the guarantee is enforced
Where the lender is a bank or financial institution, enforcement may be through the Debt Recovery Tribunal at Kolkata under the recovery of debts legislation, or through the SARFAESI route if the guarantee is secured by a mortgage of the guarantor's property. Where the lender holds a guarantee supported by a mortgage of the guarantor's personal residence, the lender can enforce the mortgage without a court order after the statutory notice.
Where the corporate debtor is in insolvency before the NCLT, an application against a personal guarantor of that corporate debtor is filed before the same Tribunal, and the Code contains a separate procedure for the guarantor's own insolvency, beginning with the appointment of a resolution professional on the creditor's application. The result can be the guarantor's bankruptcy, with his estate vesting in a trustee and his assets being realised for the creditor.
The important point of law, and the one that surprises directors, is that the approval of a resolution plan for the company does not automatically extinguish the guarantor's liability. The creditor may pursue the guarantor for the balance that the plan does not pay. A guarantor who assumes that the company's settlement is his settlement is mistaken.
Defences that remain
The guarantor is not without defences. A guarantee obtained by concealment of a material fact is invalid. Where the lender and the borrower vary the terms of the contract without the guarantor's consent, and the guarantee does not contain a clause preserving liability, the surety may be discharged. Where the lender releases the principal debtor, the surety is discharged. Where the lender loses or parts with a security without the guarantor's consent, the guarantor is entitled to the value of the security.
There are also factual defences: that the signature was obtained by misrepresentation, that the amount claimed exceeds the ceiling in the guarantee, that the demand was not made in the manner the guarantee requires, and that the interest claimed was compounded contrary to the terms. These are decided on the document and the account statements.
Limitation matters. The period runs from the date on which the guarantee becomes enforceable, which for an on-demand guarantee is the date of the demand or the date of default, depending on the wording. A lender who sleeps on a guarantee for years may find it time-barred, though an acknowledgement of liability restarts the period.
Reducing the exposure before signing
- Fix a ceiling: a stated maximum principal, with interest capped or excluded beyond a date.
- Keep the guarantee specific to one facility rather than a continuing guarantee for everything.
- Require the lender to give notice of any default and a period to cure before demanding payment.
- Insist that any variation of the loan terms requires the guarantor's written consent, or preserve the right to be discharged.
- Preserve the right of subrogation in writing, so that on payment the guarantor steps into the lender's shoes against the company and the other guarantors.
- Where there are several guarantors, state whether the liability is joint and several and whether each is liable for the whole.
A guarantee given by a wife for her husband's company, or by a director for a company in which he holds a minority, deserves particular attention. The lender will not care who is liable so long as someone is; the guarantor should care very much.
The Kolkata practice
Guarantee enforcement by a bank is usually through the Debt Recovery Tribunal at Kolkata or, where the security permits, through the SARFAESI machinery. Personal insolvency applications against a guarantor of a company in insolvency go to the NCLT Kolkata bench. Defending them requires the guarantee, the sanction letter, the account statements and the demand notices, because the case is decided on those documents.
The most useful step for a guarantor who has already signed is to write to the lender, at the first sign of the company's difficulty, seeking a statement of account and a settlement proposal within the ceiling of the guarantee. A settlement reached early is usually cheaper than one reached after a recovery proceeding has been filed. Our banking and finance practice reviews guarantee documents, and the insolvency practice handles proceedings under the Code.
Common questions
Is the guarantor liable if the company is wound up?
Yes. The guarantor's liability is separate, and the company's liquidation does not discharge it. The lender can proceed against the guarantor for the amount that remains unpaid after the company's assets are realised.
Can the bank sell the guarantor's house?
Where the guarantee is supported by a mortgage over the house and the statutory procedure is followed, the bank may enforce the security without a court order. A house that is the guarantor's only residence is still a security in the eyes of the law, whatever the hardship.
Does the guarantee end when the loan is repaid?
Yes, for that facility. A continuing guarantee, however, may cover further advances, so the guarantor should give written notice of revocation of the guarantee as to future transactions.
Can one guarantor recover from another?
Yes, where there are co-guarantors and one pays more than his share, he can seek contribution from the others. The right of subrogation against the borrower is also available. Both depend on the terms of the guarantee.
A personal guarantee is a promise made with personal assets, so it should be read before it is signed and monitored after. To have a guarantee or a demand notice reviewed, contact the office; the published fees apply.