14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Criminal Law

Police refuse to register your complaint: the BNSS route

When a police station refuses to register a complaint disclosing a cognizable offence, the law gives the informant two routes, and they run in sequence. First, the substance of the complaint is sent in writing to the Superintendent of Police, who may direct an investigation or himself investigate. If that produces nothing, the informant moves the magistrate, who can order an investigation under Section 175(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. The police refusal fir section 175 bnss sequence is well established, and it works on paper far more often than the experience at the counter suggests.

The key point is that neither route begins with an oral request. Both begin with a document, and the document is only as good as the acknowledgment that came with it — or, if there is no acknowledgment, the proof of posting.

What the police are obliged to do

Under Section 173 of the Sanhita, information relating to a cognizable offence must be reduced to writing, read over to the informant, entered in a register, and a copy given to the informant free of cost. Registration follows where the information discloses a cognizable offence; the officer does not have the power to decide that the offence is not made out and to send the informant away. The only permitted filter is a preliminary enquiry, allowed for a limited class of offences and subject to the conditions in the section, which must be completed within the prescribed period and with the approval of a superior officer.

A zero FIR can be registered at any station, whatever the place of occurrence, and it is then transferred to the station with jurisdiction. Where the offence is committed outside West Bengal, a Kolkata station can still register the information and transfer it. A refusal on the ground that "the place falls under another police station" is therefore wrong, and the wrongness should be recorded in the written complaint.

Where the offence is not cognizable, the police are not obliged to register an FIR; they enter it in the general diary and the informant may seek the magistrate's direction for investigation, or file a complaint case. Knowing which category the facts fall into decides which route is open, and the penal sections cited in the complaint should be chosen with that in mind.

The written complaint that must come first

Before any escalation, the informant should file a written complaint at the police station, in duplicate, and ask for the receiving stamp on the copy. The complaint should state the date, time and place of the incident, the persons involved, the acts alleged, the sections that apply, the names of witnesses, and the evidence in the informant's possession. It should also record what happened at the counter, if a refusal has already occurred.

Where the station refuses to accept the written complaint, the informant sends it by registered post with acknowledgement due to the officer in charge, and keeps the postal receipt. A refusal to receive is itself a misconduct, and the postal record converts an unprovable oral refusal into a dated document. In Kolkata, a copy can also be sent to the deputy commissioner of the division and to the police control room, and the acknowledgement numbers should be noted.

Sending the complaint by email to the station's official address is a useful parallel step, because the server record carries a timestamp that no one can dispute. Attach the photographs, the medical papers, the messages and a list of the witnesses.

The letter to the Superintendent of Police

Section 173(4) of the Sanhita allows the informant to send the substance of the information in writing to the Superintendent of Police, who may either investigate the case himself or direct a subordinate officer to investigate. The letter should be short, attach the complaint filed at the station, the proof of refusal or non-action, and the evidence, and ask for a direction to register and investigate.

Address it to the Superintendent of Police for the district, or in Kolkata to the commissioner's office through the deputy commissioner of the division, and send it by registered post as well as by hand. Keep the acknowledgement. A copy to the director general of police's grievance cell is not necessary at this stage but does no harm.

Where the SP directs an investigation, the station must act, and the direction is a document the informant can produce later. Where the SP does nothing, the silence is itself the material for the next step, because the magistrate will ask what the superior officer did.

Moving the magistrate under Section 175(3)

The application is made before the magistrate having jurisdiction over the area where the offence was committed — in Kolkata the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate's court at Bankshall for city offences, and the sub-divisional magistrate's court or the chief judicial magistrate's court for the districts. It is supported by an affidavit, and the material to attach is:

  • The written complaint filed at the station, with the receiving stamp, or the postal receipt where it was refused.
  • The letter to the SP and its proof of service, with any reply or the absence of one.
  • The evidence — medical papers, photographs, messages, recordings, documents — and a list of witnesses.
  • An affidavit setting out the chronology, the refusal and the fact that the informant has approached the superior officer.

The magistrate may direct an investigation, may order that the complaint be treated as a complaint case and examined himself, or may decline. The order is a judicial order, and a refusal can be challenged by a revision or a writ, though the better course is to plead the application properly the first time. The magistrate is not obliged to direct an investigation in every case; the application must show that the information discloses a cognizable offence and that the police have failed to act.

What goes wrong, and how to avoid it

The first error is an application that argues the whole case. The magistrate is deciding whether an investigation should be ordered, not whether the accused is guilty, and a fifty-page narration of the merits buries the point. Keep the application to the offence, the information given, the refusal, and the relief.

The second is a complaint that does not disclose a cognizable offence on its own terms. If the facts pleaded amount to a civil dispute — a partnership quarrel, a loan not repaid, a property boundary — the magistrate will decline, and correctly. Recast the complaint around the dishonest intention at the inception, or the criminal act alleged, and plead the ingredients.

The third is delay. An application under the section is entertained where it is made within the limitation applicable to the offence, and a delay of years invites questions about why the informant waited. Where the delay is explained — a pending civil case, an attempt at settlement, a medical condition — say so in the affidavit.

The fourth is the absence of a refusal on record. A refusal that exists only in the informant's account is weak. The postal receipt, the stamped duplicate, or the email acknowledgement is what makes the case.

After an investigation is ordered

Once the magistrate directs an investigation, the station registers the case and the investigation begins. The informant is entitled to be informed of the progress, to receive a copy of the final report, and to file a protest petition if the report proposes a closure. The protest petition is heard by the magistrate, who may take cognizance on the material despite the police's conclusion.

Where the investigation ends in a charge sheet, the case proceeds to trial before the magistrate or the sessions court depending on the offence. Where it ends in a closure report, the informant's remedy is the protest petition, supported by the material the police overlooked. Our page on quashing of FIRs deals with the mirror-image situation, where an accused seeks to have a case removed.

Common questions

Is a refusal to register an FIR a criminal offence?

It is misconduct and a statutory contravention, and it can be the subject of a complaint to the superior officer and to the police complaints authority. It is not, by itself, an offence for which the informant can file an FIR, but the refusal is relevant in the application to the magistrate and in any departmental proceeding.

Can I record the refusal on my phone?

Yes, and a recording of what the officer said at the counter is admissible if it is genuine and the voices can be identified. Do it lawfully — openly, or in a public area — and preserve the original file. The recording supports the written complaint, though it does not replace it.

Does the magistrate's order guarantee an FIR?

It guarantees that an investigation is conducted, and the station must register the case and comply. It does not guarantee a charge sheet, and the informant may still need to file a protest petition if the investigation concludes otherwise.

How long does the whole route take?

The letter to the SP is a matter of weeks; the application to the magistrate depends on the court's board, and in Kolkata the waiting period for a fresh application is measured in weeks to months. The investigation that follows is governed by the Sanhita's timelines, but in practice depends on the evidence and the station's load.

If a refusal has already happened, do not wait for a second one. The stamped duplicate, the postal receipt and the affidavit are what a court will read, and they can be assembled in a week. Bring the papers to a consultation, or read the criminal law pages and contact the office before the trail goes cold.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422