A person arrested must be produced before a Magistrate within twenty-four hours of the arrest, excluding the time taken on the journey, and until that happens the custody is the police's. The first hearing before the Magistrate decides everything that follows: whether the accused goes to police custody for interrogation or to judicial custody in a correctional home, whether bail is considered, and when the next remand will be. A police remand judicial custody decision made in those few minutes shapes the investigation, the accused's access to a lawyer and the pace of the trial.
What the twenty-four hours must contain
The arrest itself has formalities. The officer must prepare a memorandum of arrest, attested by a witness and countersigned by the arrested person, and must inform a relative or a friend of the arrest and the place of detention. The arrested person must be medically examined, and the examination report goes to the court. The Supreme Court's directions in the D.K. Basu case, which arose in this city, are the standard against which an arrest is tested, and their breach is a ground in every bail application.
- An arrest memo with the date, time and the witness's signature.
- Intimation to a relative, recorded in a register kept at the police station.
- A medical examination, with injuries noted.
- The right to consult a lawyer during interrogation, and the right to legal aid where the accused cannot afford one.
- Production before the Magistrate within twenty-four hours, and a remand order recorded in writing with reasons.
Police custody and judicial custody are different things
Judicial custody means the accused is in the custody of the court and lodged in a prison or correctional home. Police custody means he remains with the investigating agency for interrogation. The remand provision of the Sanhita allows a Magistrate to authorise detention, and the courts have consistently held that police custody is not the default: it has to be asked for, and the investigating officer has to give reasons why interrogation in custody is necessary.
Police custody is ordinarily available only during the first fifteen days of detention. After that the accused is in judicial custody and the investigating agency can interrogate him in the prison with the court's permission. Where the investigation is substantially complete, where the documents are already seized, or where the accused has cooperated, the court will refuse police custody and send him to judicial custody.
The remand hearing, and what the Magistrate must do
- Production. The accused is produced in person, ordinarily before the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate's court at Bankshall for a case in the city, or before the duty Magistrate where the arrest is at night.
- The case diary. The investigating officer produces the case diary, and the Magistrate is expected to look at it rather than accept the officer's request.
- Hearing the accused. The accused, or his lawyer, is heard on custody and on bail. An order passed without hearing him is vulnerable.
- The order. The Magistrate records whether custody is police or judicial, the period, and the reasons. A remand order that simply says "remanded" is a rubber stamp and can be challenged.
- The next date. Judicial custody is authorised in instalments — fifteen days at a time in the ordinary course — and the accused must be produced again on each date.
The ceiling on detention, and default bail
Detention pending investigation is capped. For an offence punishable with imprisonment of ten years or less, the accused cannot be detained beyond sixty days; for a graver offence the period is ninety days. If the charge sheet is not filed within that period, the accused is entitled to be released on bail, and that right is absolute — the court has no discretion to refuse it, though it may impose conditions. This is what the profession calls default bail, and it is the single most valuable date in a criminal file.
Where the investigation requires more time, the court may extend the period on a report from the investigating officer, up to a further sixty days in the graver cases. The application for extension has to be made before the period expires; an application made after it has expired does not cure the default.
Opposing police custody, and asking for bail
The grounds that work are factual rather than rhetorical. The investigation is complete and the documents are with the police. The accused was not required for any recovery. The alleged offence is documentary — a cheating case built on bank statements and agreements — so interrogation adds nothing. The accused is a woman, or is ill, or is of advanced age, and custody would endanger health. The co-accused have already been released. Each of these is a reason the court can record.
Bail at the first hearing is possible in less serious cases, and the factors are the nature of the offence, the antecedents, the risk of absconding, and whether the investigation would be hampered. In economic offences the court applies a stricter test, and the amount involved and the likelihood of the evidence being tampered with weigh heavily.
Where the case is heard in Kolkata
A case registered in the city is produced before the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate at Bankshall, and after the charge sheet the case is committed to the City Sessions Court for trial where the offence is triable by the sessions. Undertrial prisoners from the city are lodged at the Presidency Correctional Home at Alipore, and those from the northern fringes at the Dum Dum Central Jail. The investigating officer's file, the lock-up records at Lalbazar, and the station diary are the documents that a bail application draws on. The criminal law practice attends the first production and the remand hearings, the anticipatory bail team handles the position before arrest, and a case that should not have been registered at all is challenged through FIR quashing.
Can the police keep me for questioning after the Magistrate sends me to judicial custody?
Only with the court's permission, and only on an application showing why interrogation in the prison is necessary. The accused remains in judicial custody otherwise, and the police cannot remove him from the prison without an order.
Is police custody always for fifteen days?
The fifteen-day limit is on the total period of police custody, not on each order. A Magistrate cannot extend police custody beyond fifteen days from the date of arrest by passing successive orders.
Can I get bail if the charge sheet is filed on the sixtieth day?
The entitlement arises when the period expires without a charge sheet. If the charge sheet is filed before the period runs out, the default right does not arise, and bail is then a matter of the court's discretion on the merits.
Does the twenty-four hours include travel time?
No. The period excludes the time necessary for the journey from the place of arrest to the court, and the exclusion is read strictly — it covers the journey, not the investigation.
The record of the first twenty-four hours is made by other people, which is why a lawyer should be present at the production itself. Ask for the arrest memo, the medical report and the case diary before the remand is argued, and the order will usually reflect what the file shows.