14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Tax & GST

Section 44ADA: presumptive tax for professionals

A professional can opt to be taxed on half his gross receipts and keep no books of account. Section 44ada presumptive taxation is available to a person carrying on a profession specified in the statute, whose gross receipts are within the limit, and who does not want the compliance of a full accounts-and-audit regime. Half the receipts are deemed to be profit, the other half is treated as the expenses, and the tax is computed on the deemed figure at the slab rates.

The trade-off is simple. The taxpayer gives up the right to claim actual expenses, and receives in return a shorter return, no books, and no audit. For a professional whose expenses are less than half his receipts, the option is expensive; for one whose expenses are more, or whose record-keeping is poor, it is cheap.

Who is a specified professional

The section applies to a person carrying on a profession notified for the purpose, and the list includes legal, medical, engineering, architectural, accountancy, technical consultancy, interior decoration, authorised representative, film artist, company secretary and information technology professional.

The categories are defined in the rules, and a business that is not a profession does not qualify, however similar its work. A consultancy that is in substance a business of supplying manpower is not a specified profession, and a claim under this section is adjusted on assessment.

The option is available to an individual or a partnership firm, but not to a company or a limited liability partnership, which are outside the presumptive provision for professionals. A professional who incorporates a company loses the option, and the decision to incorporate should be taken with that in mind.

The limit, and the cash rule

The limit on gross receipts is fifty lakh rupees, and the higher limit applies only where the receipts in cash do not exceed five per cent of the total gross receipts. A professional who receives more than that proportion in cash is confined to the lower limit of twenty-five lakh rupees, which is the figure that applied before the limit was raised.

The cash rule is the provision that catches most practices, because professional fees are still paid partly in cash. Where the cash receipts cross five per cent even marginally, the higher limit is unavailable, and a professional with receipts of forty lakh, of which three lakh is cash, is outside the higher limit.

Receipts are counted on the basis of the fees actually received during the year, and the amount billed but not received is not counted. That is a difference from the mercantile system, and it makes the cash book the relevant record for the threshold.

What the deemed profit means

At least fifty per cent of the gross receipts is treated as the income of the profession. The taxpayer may declare a higher figure, and must declare a higher figure if the actual profit is higher, because the presumption is a minimum and not a ceiling on honesty.

No deduction is allowed for the expenses of the profession, and that includes the salary paid to staff, the rent of the office, the professional subscriptions and the depreciation on equipment. The depreciation is deemed to have been allowed, and the written-down value of the assets is reduced accordingly, which matters when the professional later opts out and sells the assets.

Where the professional wants to claim the actual expenses, the option is to keep the books, get them audited where the statute requires it, and compute the income in the ordinary way. That is not a partial option: within a year, the taxpayer either uses the presumptive basis or the regular basis.

Opting in and out

The option is exercised by filing the return on the presumptive basis, and it continues for the following years unless the taxpayer opts out. A professional who opts out in a year must keep the books and get them audited, and the audit obligation continues for the years in which the presumptive basis is not used.

Opting out and back in is permitted, but the rules have conditions, and a taxpayer who repeatedly switches attracts scrutiny. The decision should be made once, on the basis of the expense ratio, and reviewed only when the practice changes materially.

For a professional who has opted out after using the presumptive basis, the audit requirement applies where the receipts exceed the threshold, and the accounts have to be maintained from the start of that year. Reconstructing the books at the end of the year is not compliance.

Advance tax and the return

A taxpayer under the presumptive provision pays the whole advance tax by 15 March, because the income is not estimated in instalments. Missing that date attracts instalment interest, and the relief for income that could not be estimated is not available to a taxpayer who chose the presumptive basis.

The return is the ordinary form, with the presumptive computation, and the balance sheet and the profit and loss account are not required. The taxpayer should still keep a record of the receipts, the bank statements and the fee register, because the threshold and the cash proportion have to be proved if they are questioned.

Where the receipts cross the limit during the year, the option is lost for that year, and the taxpayer must keep the books and compute the income in the ordinary way. The crossing is examined at the end of the year, so a professional who crosses in March has a full year of books to reconstruct.

Where the claim is challenged

A challenge usually arises on three grounds: that the activity is not a specified profession, that the receipts exceed the limit, or that the cash proportion exceeds five per cent. Each is answered by documents, and the documents are the fee register, the bank statements and the nature of the work.

An adjustment in the processing of the return can be corrected by a rectification, and a scrutiny assessment is answered with the receipts and the professional records. A review of the receipts and the cash proportion before filing is the way to avoid the challenge, and a written submission at the assessment stage is where the nature of the profession is established.

Where the assessment is confirmed, the appeal lies to the Commissioner (Appeals) and then to the tribunal, whose Kolkata bench hears it. A writ petition is confined to jurisdictional defects.

Common questions

Can a lawyer or a doctor use this section?

Yes, both are specified professions, and so are engineers, architects, chartered accountants, company secretaries and information technology professionals. The option is available to an individual or a firm, subject to the receipts limit and the cash rule.

Do I have to maintain books of account?

Not the books required for a regular computation, and no audit is required under the presumptive provision. You should still keep the fee records and the bank statements, because the eligibility depends on the receipts and the cash proportion.

Can I claim depreciation on my office equipment?

No, not as a separate deduction; the depreciation is deemed to have been allowed within the fifty per cent. It reduces the written-down value of the assets, which affects the computation if you later opt out and sell them.

What if my expenses are more than half my receipts?

Then the presumptive basis over-taxes you, and the regular basis with books and audit may be cheaper. The comparison should be done before the year begins, because the option is exercised for the whole year, not for a part of it.

The section is a bargain about records. If your expenses are modest and your books are thin, take it, keep the receipts, and pay by March. If your expenses are heavy, keep the books instead, because the deemed profit is not a discount; it is a substitute for the deduction you would otherwise claim.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422