Product liability is the responsibility of a manufacturer, a seller or a service provider to compensate a consumer for harm caused by a defective product. The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 defines it in Section 2(34) and then sets out, in a separate chapter, who is liable and for what. It is a wider remedy than a simple refund, because it reaches injury, property damage and death, not just the price of the goods.
What the definition covers
The definition describes the responsibility of a product manufacturer or product seller to compensate for harm caused to a consumer by a defective product, or by a deficiency in a service related to it. Three words do the work. Product, which includes goods and also the output of a service. Defect, which the Act treats in more than one way. And harm, which the Act defines to include injury, illness, property damage, mental agony and death.
The claim is not confined to the person who bought the product. A consumer includes a person who uses the goods with the buyer's approval, so a family member injured by a defective appliance is a consumer for this purpose.
The three categories of defect
A manufacturing defect is a departure from the design or the specification: the batch that was made wrong, the component that failed, the medicine with the wrong formulation. It is usually proved by comparing the product with the specification and by an examination report.
A design defect is inherent in the product as designed, so that every unit carries the risk. A pressure vessel with no relief valve, a toy with a detachable part of a size that a child can swallow, an electrical appliance without adequate earthing: these are design questions, and they are proved by expert evidence on what a reasonable design would have included.
A failure to warn or to instruct is the third category. A product that is safe when used as directed but dangerous when used otherwise requires adequate warnings and clear instructions. A pharmaceutical without a contraindication warning, a chemical sold without handling instructions, a machine supplied without a guard or a manual.
Overlapping all three is the failure to conform to an express warranty the seller or manufacturer gave. Where the product does not do what the packaging promised, that is a breach in itself.
Who can be sued
The manufacturer is liable for a manufacturing defect, a design defect, a failure to warn, and a breach of warranty. The Act's provisions on the manufacturer's liability are specific and do not require the consumer to prove negligence in so many words.
A product seller is liable in narrower circumstances: where he exercised substantial control over the design or manufacture, where he altered the product, where he made a fraudulent misrepresentation about it, where he failed to exercise reasonable care, or where he breached an express warranty. An ordinary retailer who simply passed the product on is not automatically liable, and the Act gives him defences.
A product service provider is liable where the service he provided was faulty, imperfect or deficient. This catches the installer, the repairer, the maintenance contractor and, in an appropriate case, the e-commerce entity that handles delivery and installation. Our page on consumer protection sets out the commission's powers in these claims.
The seller's defences
The Act allows a product seller to escape where he proves that he had no knowledge of the defect and could not reasonably have been expected to know of it, having regard to the nature of the product and his role in its chain of distribution. Where the defect is attributable to the manufacturer, or to a party over whom the seller had no control, the seller is not liable.
What defeats the defence is the seller's own conduct: repackaging, relabelling, storing the product badly, selling an expired item, or passing off a duplicate as the original. Each of those moves the seller from a conduit to a participant.
Proving the claim
The first task is to keep the product. A consumer who returns the defective item for a refund and then sues has lost his best evidence. Photograph it, keep the batch number and the packaging, preserve the invoice, and do not repair or discard it before an inspection.
The second task is to connect the harm to the product. Medical records, the fire report, the electrician's report, the insurer's survey: whatever document records the injury and its cause. Where a whole batch appears to be affected, a report from a testing laboratory or from the manufacturer's own service records strengthens the case.
The third task is to quantify. Product liability compensation can include the cost of treatment, the loss of income, the damage to other property, the cost of replacement, and compensation for the harm itself. A death claim is valued on the dependency principle, as in an accident claim.
Limitation and forum
A product liability action must be filed within two years of the date on which the consumer discovered the defect or the harm. The commission is chosen by the value of the consideration paid for the product, with the same bands as other consumer complaints: up to fifty lakh before the District Commission, up to two crore before the State Commission at Kolkata, and above that before the National Commission.
The complaint is filed where the opposite party carries on business or where the cause of action arose. For a product bought in Kolkata from a dealer in the city, the District Commission has jurisdiction; a claim against a manufacturer with its registered office elsewhere can still be filed in Kolkata where the purchase and the harm occurred here. Where the loss is large enough to be pleaded as a suit, the pattern is on our civil litigation page.
The e-commerce question
An e-commerce entity that sells goods falls within the definition of a product seller, and the Act's rules on e-commerce direct sellers add obligations about disclosure of the seller's identity, the return policy, and the remedies available. Where a marketplace merely hosts a third-party seller, the question is whether it exercised control over the transaction. The platform's own terms, its fulfilment arrangements and its role in the return process are the material for that question.
What a claim looks like in practice
- Preserve the product and the packaging, with the batch or serial number.
- Obtain the invoice and the warranty card.
- Get a written technical opinion on the failure, from a service engineer or an approved laboratory.
- Assemble the medical or property damage records.
- Send a written notice to the seller and the manufacturer, demanding the remedy and stating the harm.
- File the complaint with the product, the report and the records, and claim the quantified loss.
Common questions
Is a manufacturer liable for a product bought second-hand?
The manufacturer's liability for a manufacturing or design defect does not depend on who bought the product first. The difficulty in a second-hand case is proving that the defect was present when the product left the factory and was not caused by the intervening use. The form of that notice is on our legal notice drafting page.
Can a claim be made for a product that injured someone who was not the buyer?
Yes. A member of the buyer's household who uses the product with his consent is a consumer, and the harm to that person is compensable.
Does the consumer have to prove negligence?
Not in the ordinary manufacturing defect case. The Act's scheme places the responsibility on the manufacturer for defined categories of defect, and the argument is about whether the product was defective, not whether the manufacturer was careless.
What if the product was used contrary to the instructions?
Misuse is a defence, and it can defeat the claim where the harm resulted from use outside the warning given. Where the warning was inadequate for a foreseeable misuse, the claim survives on the failure-to-warn ground.
Product claims are evidence-heavy and short on sympathy. The product, the invoice and the technical report decide them. A consumer who keeps those three things has a claim that a commission can decide on documents; a consumer who has thrown the product away has a story.