An addition in an assessment is not a prosecution. Section 276C makes it an offence to wilfully attempt to evade tax, and the word wilfully carries the whole weight of the provision. A taxpayer whose claim was disallowed because the officer took a different view of the evidence has not committed an offence. A taxpayer who maintained a duplicate set of books, claimed expenses that never existed, or failed to disclose a receipt that he knew of, has.
The gap between the two is where every section 276c prosecution is fought, and it is fought on documents. The department must prove the wilful attempt, and the taxpayer's answer is that the disclosure was full, the claim was bona fide, and the error was an error of law or of computation.
What the section covers
The offence is a wilful attempt to evade any tax, penalty or interest chargeable under the Act. The attempt can be by understating income, by claiming a false deduction or exemption, by maintaining false accounts, by omitting a receipt, or by any other means. The punishment for the substantive offence is rigorous imprisonment for a term which may extend to seven years, with a minimum of six months, and a fine.
A separate part of the section deals with a failure to pay tax deducted or collected at source. The punishment there is different, and the offence is constituted by the failure to pay the amount to the government after deducting it. That is the provision invoked in the prosecutions of deductors who collected tax and used it in the business.
The offences are tried by the magistrate, and the complaint is filed by the tax department after the sanction of the prescribed authority. The prosecution is independent of the assessment, though the assessment order is usually the foundation of the complaint, and the criminal court is not bound by the findings of the assessment.
The sanction, and the threshold
No prosecution is instituted except at the instance of the prescribed authority, and the sanction is a condition of the complaint. A complaint filed without it is defective, and the defect is a ground for discharge. The sanction order must show that the authority applied its mind to the material, and a printed sanction that recites the conclusions without reasons is open to challenge.
The department's own instructions prescribe monetary thresholds below which a prosecution is not ordinarily launched, and a case below the threshold that is nevertheless prosecuted is a case where the taxpayer can ask why. The instructions are not statute, but they are administrative directions that the department is expected to follow, and they are useful in an application for discharge and in a representation.
The choice between prosecution and compounding is real. The law allows the offence to be compounded, on an application and on payment, and the effect is that the prosecution ends. Compounding is applied for before the offence is tried, and the application is made to the authority the law prescribes.
The evidence that decides a prosecution
- The assessment order, with the findings of fact, and the penalty order.
- The statements recorded during the search or the survey, and the retractions, if any.
- The seized books, the loose sheets and the electronic records, with the panchnama and the inventory.
- The bank statements showing the receipts that were not disclosed.
- The returns, the audited accounts and the notes to the accounts.
- The correspondence with the department, and the replies to the notices.
The prosecution stands or falls on whether the material shows a deliberate act. A duplicate ledger, a cash receipt not entered in the books, a claim supported by a fabricated invoice — each is evidence of wilfulness. A claim that was supported by a genuine document and disallowed on interpretation is not.
The defence
The first line is that there was no wilful attempt. The disclosure was full, the documents were produced, and the issue was one of law. The assessment order's own language often helps, because an addition made on an estimate, or on a view of the evidence that the officer describes as debatable, is an addition that contradicts a charge of wilfulness.
The second is the absence of the mental element. The statute raises a presumption of a culpable mental state, but the presumption is rebuttable, and the taxpayer can show that he relied on a professional, that the transaction was recorded in the books, that the tax was paid on the basis of the return as filed, and that no concealment was possible because the record was open to inspection.
The third is a procedural defect: a complaint without sanction, a complaint by an officer not authorised, a complaint that repeats the assessment without any independent application of mind, or a prosecution launched after the limitation. Each is a ground for discharge, and the application for discharge is the place to take them.
The fourth is compounding, which ends the matter commercially. Where the case is weak on wilfulness but the material is unpleasant, compounding is often the sensible course, and it should be considered before the trial begins.
The trial, and the interaction with the appeal
The criminal trial and the tax appeal run on separate tracks. A conviction does not follow automatically from the assessment being confirmed, and an acquittal does not set aside the demand. Where the appeal succeeds on the merits and the addition is deleted, the foundation of the prosecution goes, and the taxpayer should place the appellate order before the criminal court at once.
The criminal court will decide whether the attempt was wilful on the evidence before it, and it may take a different view of the same documents that the appellate authority took. That is why the defence should be run in both proceedings with the same factual case, and why an admission in the appeal should be avoided where the prosecution is pending.
Our page on criminal law covers the procedure before the magistrate, and tax practice covers the appeal.
Common questions
Can a prosecution be launched before the assessment is final?
Yes, but it is unusual, and the complaint usually follows the assessment. Where a prosecution is launched while the assessment is under appeal, the taxpayer can ask the criminal court to await the appellate outcome, though the court is not bound to stay the trial.
Is a penalty order necessary for a prosecution?
No. The prosecution is independent, and it can be launched whether or not a penalty has been imposed. In practice, the penalty finding is relied on as evidence of wilfulness, which is why the penalty appeal matters even after the tax is paid.
What is the limitation for a prosecution?
The criminal procedure law prescribes the period within which a complaint must be filed, and the period depends on the maximum punishment. The department is bound by it, and a complaint filed after the period is liable to be dismissed.
Does compounding end the civil demand?
No. Compounding ends the prosecution, not the assessment. The tax and the penalty remain payable, and the compounding amount is separate from them.
A prosecution is a different kind of case from an appeal, and it needs a defence built on the record rather than on the computation. If a complaint has been filed, bring the assessment order, the penalty order, the seizure records and the sanction to a consultation, or write to the office before the first hearing.