The Debts Recovery Tribunal is a fast recovery forum, and it is not available to most businesses. An application can be filed only by a bank or a financial institution as defined by the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993, or by an assignee of such a creditor. A private company owed money on a supply invoice cannot file there, however large the debt.
Who can file, and who cannot
The Act applies to the recovery of debts due to banks and financial institutions. The definition of a financial institution is a list of notified entities, and the definition of debt is tied to that list. A company that is owed money for goods supplied is not within it.
Two consequences follow from that. The first is that a supplier or a landlord who has heard that the DRT is faster should not spend money on an application that will be rejected on maintainability. The second is that the DRT becomes available when the debt has been assigned to a bank or an asset reconstruction company, which is a route some sellers of distressed receivables take.
A non-banking financial company that has been notified for this purpose can file, and so can a bank's assignee. Where the creditor is a co-operative bank or a notified institution, the position depends on the notification, and it is worth checking before filing rather than after. The regulatory setting for lenders is dealt with under banking and finance.
The twenty lakh threshold and the limitation
The tribunal has jurisdiction over a debt of at least twenty lakh rupees. Below that, the bank's remedy is a civil suit or the SARFAESI route for a secured debt, and the tribunal will not entertain the application.
Limitation is three years from the date on which the debt became due, since the Act applies the Limitation Act, and there is provision for the exclusion of periods during which the creditor was pursuing a civil remedy or where the defendant had acknowledged the debt. An acknowledgement in writing, or a part payment, restarts the period on the acknowledged amount, and banks rely on these revivals constantly in old files.
The application and how the case runs
An application under Section 19 of the Act sets out the debt, the security, the amount claimed with interest, and the reliefs sought. It is verified, and it carries the documents: the loan agreement, the sanction letter, the mortgage or hypothecation deed, the statements of account and the demand notices.
The tribunal issues a summons, and the defendant files a written statement within the period allowed. A counterclaim is permitted, and it has to be dealt with in the same proceeding. The tribunal then hears the matter, and its decision takes the form of a certificate of recovery in favour of the applicant.
Interim orders are available. The tribunal can restrain the defendant from disposing of property, direct the defendant to deposit money, and appoint a receiver. For a lender with a genuine case, that is where the real recovery often happens, long before the certificate issues.
Execution through the Recovery Officer
Once a certificate of recovery is issued, the Recovery Officer attached to the tribunal executes it. The modes are the ones familiar from civil execution, with the added power to recover the amount as arrears of land revenue. The Recovery Officer can attach and sell movable property, attach immovable property and bring it to sale, direct the arrest and detention of the debtor in an appropriate case, and appoint a receiver.
The Third Schedule to the Act and the rules made under it deal with the procedure for arrest and detention and for the sale of property, and they favour speed over the leisurely pace of a civil execution petition. Property can be attached and sold without the debtor's cooperation, which is the whole purpose of the statute.
Appeal to the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal
An appeal from the tribunal lies to the Appellate Tribunal, which for West Bengal sits at Kolkata. The appeal must be filed within forty-five days of the order, and the appellant must deposit twenty-five per cent of the amount of the debt due as a condition of the appeal, with a discretion in the Appellate Tribunal to reduce the amount for reasons recorded.
That deposit is the reason these appeals are rare and settlements common. A borrower who wants to appeal usually has to find a quarter of the debt first, and the tribunal that passed the order will not stay execution without it.
What a private creditor should do instead
A supplier, a landlord, a professional or any other private creditor has three workable routes.
The first is a summary suit under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, where the claim arises on a written contract, a cheque accepted for payment, or an invoice supported by the statutory presumptions. In a summary suit the defendant must apply for leave to defend and satisfy the court that he has a triable defence. Where leave is refused, the plaintiff gets a decree without a trial, which is the closest a private creditor gets to the DRT's speed. Our page on recovery suits explains the procedure and the documents.
The second is the route under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, where the creditor is an operational creditor on account of goods or services supplied and the default has continued for the statutory period. A demand notice precedes the application, and the forum is the NCLT Kolkata bench. The threshold for an application under the Code is substantial, and the remedy is a resolution of the debtor rather than a direct payment, which suits some creditors and not others. The process and the threshold are described under insolvency and bankruptcy.
The third is the Facilitation Council for micro and small enterprises, which is a fast arbitral route with a statutory interest entitlement. A supplier registered on the Udyam portal should look at that first, because it is cheaper than a suit and produces an enforceable award.
Settlement and the one-time route
Banks and financial institutions settle a large proportion of DRT matters under their compromise policies. A borrower who wants to settle should approach the bank's authorised committee, and the settlement terms are normally conditional on payment within a short period and on withdrawal of all proceedings. Where a settlement is reached before the certificate is issued, the terms are recorded before the tribunal and the case is closed on payment.
A creditor of a business in the DRT's file can still protect himself by attaching the same assets in a separate civil action and by proceeding with the suit rather than waiting for the bank's recovery. The bank's security may not be enough to cover all creditors, and a separate decree keeps the recovery alive.
Common questions
Can an individual sue a company before the DRT?
Not on a debt owed to him personally. The tribunal's jurisdiction arises on a debt due to a bank or a notified financial institution. An individual's remedy is a civil suit or, if the debt has been assigned to a notified entity, the assignee's application.
Is the DRT cheaper than a civil suit?
The filing fee is lower and the process is faster, but it is available only to the institutions the Act covers. For a private creditor the comparison is between a summary suit and the Facilitation Council, and the answer depends on whether the supplier is registered as a micro or small enterprise.
Can the borrower be arrested on a DRT certificate?
Detention is permitted in the circumstances the rules provide, particularly where the debtor has refused to pay despite the means to do so or has transferred property to defeat the recovery. It is not the ordinary mode of recovery and the Recovery Officer applies it sparingly.
What happens if the borrower files for insolvency?
Proceedings before the tribunal are then governed by the moratorium, and the bank pursues its claim before the National Company Law Tribunal. The certificate of recovery remains evidence of the debt, and the creditor lodges its claim with the resolution professional.
Knowing which forum you cannot use saves more money than knowing how to use the one you can. A private creditor with a documented debt should decide between the summary suit and the MSME route within weeks, and not spend a year exploring a tribunal that will not open its doors.