14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Tax & GST

Reopening under Section 148: the information that must exist

A notice under Section 148 is not issued on a hunch. After the 2021 amendment, the officer must first apply his mind to information suggesting that income has escaped assessment, give the taxpayer a chance to be heard on that information, and obtain the approval of a specified authority before issuing the notice. A section 148 reassessment that skips any of those steps is open to challenge, and the challenge is made by a writ petition before the Calcutta High Court, not by waiting for the assessment order.

The distinction between a valid reopening and a fishing expedition is the quality of the material. The officer must have information, must apply it to the taxpayer's return, and must record why he is satisfied that income escaped. Where the reasons reproduce an investigation report about a third party, without connecting the material to the taxpayer's own transactions, the notice is founded on borrowed satisfaction, and the courts have set such notices aside.

The sequence the statute now requires

  1. The officer receives information suggesting escapement, and applies his mind to it.
  2. He issues a show cause notice, giving the taxpayer an opportunity of hearing and the material on which he proposes to act.
  3. The taxpayer replies, with the return, the accounts and the explanation.
  4. The officer passes an order under the new provision, recording his satisfaction or otherwise, and only after that can the notice under Section 148 be issued.
  5. The notice is issued with the prior approval of the specified authority, which is a higher authority where the period exceeds three years.

The show cause stage is not formal. The taxpayer is entitled to the reasons, and to a reasonable opportunity to respond, and the order must deal with the reply. An order that repeats the show cause without considering the reply is vulnerable, and a notice issued without the order is without jurisdiction.

Time limits and the amount at stake

The outer limit is three years from the end of the relevant assessment year in ordinary cases, and ten years where the income alleged to have escaped is above the threshold of fifty lakh rupees. The longer period requires a higher sanction and a recorded satisfaction about the amount, and it is confined to cases where the material is in the possession of the officer.

The proviso to the reopening provision adds a further condition. Where the assessment was made under the ordinary scrutiny provisions, no reopening after four years is permitted unless the income escaped by reason of the taxpayer's failure to disclose fully and truly all material facts. That is a jurisdictional fact, and the officer must record it, not assume it.

The date of the notice, not the date of the order, is what the taxpayer must check against the limitation. A notice issued after the period is dead on arrival, and the point should be taken in the first reply.

The reasons, and how to attack them

The notice must be accompanied by the reasons recorded, and the reasons are the foundation of the case. Read them for four defects:

  • No information. The reasons describe a suspicion, an audit objection, or a survey finding that does not amount to information suggesting escapement.
  • Borrowed satisfaction. The reasons reproduce an investigation wing report about another person, and do not state what the taxpayer did or failed to disclose.
  • Change of opinion. The same material was examined in the original assessment, and the officer now takes a different view of it.
  • Mechanical approval. The sanctioning authority granted approval in a printed format, without recording why the case warranted reopening.

Where the reasons are defective, the remedy is a writ petition before the Calcutta High Court, filed promptly after the notice. The court examines the reasons as they stand, and does not permit the department to supplement them with fresh material in the affidavit. That rule is the taxpayer's best protection, because it forces the department to defend the notice on the record it made.

The reply, if the taxpayer chooses to participate

There is a choice at the notice stage: challenge the notice by writ, or participate in the proceedings and reserve the jurisdictional objection. The choice depends on the defect. A notice that is barred by limitation or that discloses no information is best challenged by writ. A notice that is within time and discloses some material is usually better answered on the merits, with the jurisdictional objections recorded, so that the assessment order can be appealed on both grounds.

Where the taxpayer participates, the reply should set out the return, the disclosure, the explanation of the transaction, and the documents. It should also ask for the copies of the material relied on, and for the opportunity to cross-examine where the material is a statement recorded from a third party. The denial of those requests is a ground in the appeal.

Do not ignore the notice. A failure to respond leads to a best judgment assessment, and a best judgment assessment is harder to displace than an assessment on the merits.

What the reassessment can cover

The reassessment is confined to the reasons recorded. The officer cannot assess an item that is outside the reasons, and an addition on a new ground in the reassessment order is a ground of appeal. Where the reasons refer to a specific transaction, the enquiry should be about that transaction, and the taxpayer's reply should hold the officer to it.

The assessment is conducted under the faceless machinery, which means the taxpayer's submissions go to a unit that does not meet him, and the personal hearing is conducted through the portal. The reply must therefore be self-contained, with the documents attached and the page references given, because the officer reading it will not have the file in front of him.

Our page on writ petitions sets out the form of the challenge, and tax practice covers the appeals that follow the assessment.

Common questions

Can a notice be challenged after the assessment order?

Yes, in the appeal against the order, where the jurisdictional objection was recorded in the reply. Where the objection was not raised at all, the appellate authority may decline to entertain it, and the writ becomes the only route.

What is the time to file a writ against a notice?

There is no fixed period, but a writ filed promptly, within weeks of the notice, is far stronger than one filed after the assessment. The court asks why the taxpayer waited, and a delay weakens the case even where the reasons are defective.

Does the officer have to give the material relied on?

Yes. The taxpayer is entitled to the information on which the reopening is based, subject to the limited protection for sensitive material. A refusal to supply it, without reasons, is a breach of the opportunity to be heard.

Can the department reopen for the same issue twice?

Not on the same material. A second reopening on the same facts, after the first has been quashed or decided, is a change of opinion and is liable to be set aside. A second reopening on fresh material is permissible if the statutory conditions are met.

If a notice has arrived, the reasons recorded are the document to read first, and the limitation is the second. Bring the notice, the reasons and the original return to a consultation, or write to the office within the reply period.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422