14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Tax & GST

Replying to a GST show cause notice under Section 73

A show cause notice under Section 73 of the GST law deals with a tax demand where fraud, suppression or wilful misstatement is not alleged. That single fact shapes the reply. The department is not accusing the taxpayer of dishonesty; it is saying that tax was short paid or wrongly refunded, and it is giving him a chance to explain before it passes an order. A reply that treats the notice as a prosecution, and answers with indignation instead of a reconciliation, is a reply that ends in the demand being confirmed.

Dealing with a GST show cause notice section 73 of the Act is therefore a documentary exercise, and the documents have to be assembled before the argument is written. The section requires the notice to be issued within the prescribed period before the last date for passing the order, the taxpayer is given thirty days to reply, and the officer must pass a speaking order. Extensions of the reply period are applied for, not assumed, and a reply filed after the order is a representation, not a reply.

What the notice must contain, and what to check first

Read the notice for four things before drafting a word. The period covered, the amount demanded and the head under which it is demanded — tax, interest, penalty — the statements or returns on which the demand is based, and the date by which the reply is due. A notice that does not disclose the basis of the demand is deficient, and the deficiency is a ground to ask for the material, not a reason to ignore the notice.

Check the jurisdiction as well. The notice should come from the proper officer for the taxpayer's registration, and a notice issued by an officer without jurisdiction is vulnerable. Check the mode of service: a notice uploaded on the portal is served when it is uploaded, and the thirty days run from that date, not from the date the taxpayer happens to log in. If the notice is time-barred, say so at the outset, because limitation is a question the officer must decide before the merits.

Where the notice alleges suppression or fraud but is issued under Section 73, the mismatch matters. The extended period of limitation is available only where fraud or suppression is alleged, and the reply should object to the invocation of the extended period without the corresponding allegation and the sanction that Section 74 requires.

The reply, in the order a court reads it

  1. Preliminary objections. Limitation, jurisdiction, the absence of the material relied on, and any failure to give a personal hearing.
  2. The facts, in a chronology. Registration, the returns filed, the payments made, the transactions in question, and the correspondence with the department.
  3. The reconciliation. A table, or a set of tables, matching the department's figure to the books: GSTR-1 against GSTR-3B, GSTR-2B against the purchase register, the e-way bills against the invoices, and the bank statement against the receipts.
  4. The legal grounds. The provision relied on by the department, the correct provision, and the reason the demand does not survive it. Cite the statute, not adjectives.
  5. The evidence. Invoices, ledgers, transport documents, payment proofs, contracts, and where relevant, the supplier's returns.
  6. The prayer. Drop the demand, or reduce it to the amount actually admitted, with the interest computed on that amount, and with no penalty where the omission was bona fide and the tax was paid before the notice.

Keep the reply to the point. Officers read many replies, and the one that begins with a reconciliation table is the one that gets examined. The reply should be signed by the authorised representative, with the authorisation attached, and uploaded on the portal with a covering letter, and a physical copy should be submitted at the office with an acknowledgement.

The documents that decide the case

For an input tax credit mismatch, the documents are the purchase register, the GSTR-2B for the period, the invoices, the supplier's GSTR-1, and proof of payment. Where the supplier has not filed, the credit may still be allowable if the taxpayer has the invoice and the payment, though the department will press for reversal; the reply should set out the supplier's status and the taxpayer's diligence.

For an output tax mismatch between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B, the reconciliation of the two returns, the amendment statements, and the payment of the differential tax with interest is the answer. Where the differential has been paid before the notice, the penalty exposure falls away, and the reply should lead with the payment challan.

For a refund or an excess claim, the shipping bills, the export invoices, the bank realisation certificates, and the statement of the refund calculation are the evidence. The reply should deal with the specific bills the department has questioned, not with the refund in general.

For a demand relating to a period in which the registration was cancelled or suspended, the returns filed, the revocation application, and the reason for the lapse should be explained, because a cancelled registration attracts a demand for the period of cancellation that is often computed mechanically.

The personal hearing, which should not be waived

Where a personal hearing is requested, the officer must grant it, and the law requires him to do so before passing an order. Do not waive it. The hearing is the only occasion on which the officer sees the taxpayer and the reconciliation in the same room, and a well-prepared hearing often reduces the demand before the order is written.

At the hearing, carry a short note of the points and the documents relied on, and ask the officer to record the submissions. Where the officer seeks additional documents, ask for time in writing, and file them within the time with a covering letter. Where the officer does not give a hearing despite a request, the order is open to challenge on that ground alone.

The order must be a speaking order, dealing with the reply and the evidence. An order that repeats the notice and confirms the demand without discussing the reply is a non-speaking order, and it is a strong ground in appeal.

Appeal, and the pre-deposit

An order under Section 73 is appealable to the appellate authority, and the appeal must be filed within the prescribed period with the pre-deposit of the tax and penalty required by the law. The pre-deposit is a condition of maintainability, and it must be paid before the appeal is entertained. The further appeal lies to the Appellate Tribunal, and thereafter the High Court on a substantial question of law.

The appeal is not a second reply. It is a review of the order, and the grounds should focus on what the order failed to consider — the reconciliation, the hearing, the limitation, the jurisdiction. New documents are admitted only with an explanation, so the reply stage is where the evidence must be placed.

Our page on GST and indirect tax sets out the appeal timelines, and corporate compliance covers the reconciliation routine that prevents these notices.

Common questions

Can the reply period be extended?

Yes, on a written application before the period expires, with reasons. The officer has the discretion to extend, and it is rarely refused where the taxpayer needs time to obtain supplier documents or a reconciliation. An extension sought after the period has run is usually refused.

What if the notice is issued after the limitation period?

Raise it as the first objection, with the dates, and ask for the notice to be dropped on that ground. Limitation goes to jurisdiction, and the officer must deal with it. If the order ignores the objection, it is a ground of appeal.

Should tax be paid before the reply?

Where the taxpayer accepts the demand in part, paying that part with interest before the order reduces the penalty exposure and shows good faith. Where the demand is disputed in full, payment is not a condition of replying, though the department will press for it. Take the decision on the reconciliation, not on the pressure.

Does a reply prevent a penalty?

It can. Where the tax was paid before the notice and the omission was not attributable to fraud or suppression, the penalty provisions are not attracted. Where the demand is confirmed, the reply's explanation of the error is what the officer considers on the question of penalty.

A notice under Section 73 usually arrives with a deadline shorter than the time needed to reconstruct a year's reconciliation. Start with the period, the amount and the material relied on, and build the reply from the ledger and the portal downloads. Bring the notice and the returns to a consultation, or write to the office with the notice attached.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422