A Right to Information request is answered within thirty days, and if it is refused or answered badly the applicant has a first appeal to an officer senior to the one who decided it, followed by a second appeal to the State Information Commission. The system works on one principle that applicants routinely forget: the department is not obliged to explain its decision, but it is obliged to hand over the record, and an application that asks for reasons rather than records gives the public information officer an easy way out.
What the Act obliges the officer to do
Section 6 of the Right to Information Act, 2005 allows any citizen to ask for information held by a public authority, and Section 6(2) removes the need to give a reason for the request or any personal justification. Section 7 fixes the clock: thirty days from receipt, forty-eight hours where the information concerns the life or liberty of a person, and thirty-five days where the application is routed through an assistant public information officer. Where the subject matter belongs to another public authority, Section 6(3) requires the request to be transferred within five days and the applicant informed.
The fee is set by the rules — ten rupees for a central public authority, with the corresponding figure notified by the state, plus copying charges per page and the actual cost of larger formats. A person below the poverty line is exempt from the fee and must be shown the exemption on production of the certificate.
Framing the request so it cannot be dodged
Information is defined as any material in any form held by or under the control of the public authority. That includes file notings, correspondence, reports, orders, and the record of a decision. The officer's standard defences are that the request is too vague, that it seeks an opinion, or that answering it would divert the office's resources under Section 7(9). Each is defeated by specificity.
- Ask for documents, not conclusions: "a certified copy of the inspection report dated..." rather than "why was my complaint rejected".
- Give the file number, the date, the office and the name of the officer if you know them.
- Break a large request into numbered points, each capable of a yes or a document, so the officer cannot refuse the whole because of one weak limb.
- Ask for certified copies and state the format you want, and offer to pay the copying charges.
- Keep the postal receipt or the online acknowledgement. The date of receipt, not the date of posting, starts the clock.
The exemptions the officer will reach for
Section 8 lists the categories that are exempt: national security and strategic interests, information expressly barred by a court, information that would breach privilege, commercial confidence and trade secrets, information received in confidence from a foreign government, and information that would endanger life or physical safety. Section 8(1)(j) is the one used most often against private individuals: information that relates to personal information, the disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity or interest, or which would cause unwarranted invasion of privacy.
Two things blunt that defence. Where the information relates to a public activity — a licence granted, a tender awarded, a sanction given — it is not private. And Section 8(1)(j) itself permits disclosure where the public interest in disclosure outweighs the harm to the individual. Section 10 requires the officer to sever the exempt portion and release the rest, which means a refusal of the whole document is usually indefensible. Section 11 requires notice to a third party whose information is being disclosed, and that third party has a right to be heard.
The first appeal, and how it is filed
Where the reply is late, incomplete, wrong, or the officer has simply not decided, the applicant appeals under Section 19(1) to the officer senior in rank to the public information officer, within thirty days of receiving the reply or of the expiry of the period. The appeal is a single letter with the original application, the acknowledgement, and the reply if there was one. No fee is prescribed for the first appeal under the central rules; state rules vary, and the appellate office will say what it expects.
The appellate officer must decide within thirty days, extendable by fifteen days for reasons recorded in writing. That officer has the power to order disclosure, and in practice the first appeal is where most good outcomes happen — the senior officer overrules a defensive subordinate without the formality of a commission hearing.
- Number the grounds: no reply, incomplete reply, wrong exemption claimed, transfer without reason.
- Say exactly what the first officer did and on what date, quoting the reply.
- State what you want the appellate officer to direct — a fresh decision, or the specific documents.
- Attach the originals or certified copies, and keep a receipt-stamped duplicate.
- Send it by registered post or speed post, or file it at the office counter and take the acknowledgement.
The second appeal and the penalty
If the first appeal fails, the second appeal goes to the State Information Commission — in West Bengal, the West Bengal Information Commission at Kolkata — within ninety days of the first appellate decision. The commission can direct disclosure, summon the officer, and impose a penalty under Section 20 of two hundred and fifty rupees a day for delay, subject to a ceiling of twenty-five thousand rupees, where the delay was without reasonable cause. It can also recommend disciplinary action. Section 19(8) puts the burden on the public information officer to show that the refusal was justified.
The commission's hearings are held in Kolkata and can be attended in person or through a representative. Its decisions are binding, and where a department ignores a direction the commission can proceed under its contempt powers. This is the point at which a request that began as a two-line application becomes a matter worth conducting carefully: the commission reads the record, and vague grounds that survived the first appeal rarely survive there.
Where the papers go in Kolkata
Every department has a designated public information officer, and the application goes to that officer and not to the minister or the secretariat at large. For the Kolkata Municipal Corporation the request is filed with the officer designated for the borough or the department concerned. For a state department the application goes to the state public information officer, with the first appeal to the appellate authority of the same department. Where the subject is a police station's record, the application goes to the public information officer of the police establishment concerned.
A refusal is best answered with documents rather than argument, which is where drafting help matters. Our writ practice takes up cases where a commission order is ignored, and the legal formats page carries the standard application and appeal formats. Where the request concerns a property record, the parallel route through property registration searches often produces the same document faster.
Can I ask why a decision was taken?
You can ask for the file noting, the order and the correspondence that led to it, and those usually reveal the reason. A bare question asking for the reason may be answered by a statement of the outcome, because the Act gives access to records and not to the officer's reasoning.
Is there a fee for the first appeal?
The central rules prescribe no fee for the first appeal. Some states charge one under their own rules, so check with the appellate office before filing; the second appeal to the commission also carries a fee set by the commission's regulations.
What if the officer does not reply at all?
Silence for thirty days is a deemed refusal. The first appeal can be filed on the expiry of the period without waiting for a reply, and the appellate officer will call for the file.
Can I get information about a private company?
Only to the extent that the public authority holds it — a licence application, a tender, an inspection report. The Act reaches the public authority's record, not the company's own papers.
The rti application first appeal cycle rewards precision. Write the request for documents the office certainly holds, file the appeal the day the thirty days run out, and keep every acknowledgement; a department that has to answer on the record usually does.