A search is conducted under an authorisation issued by a senior officer, and the person whose premises are searched has real rights on the day — to see the authorisation, to have witnesses present, to a copy of the panchnama, to have seized valuables valued, and to copies of any statement recorded. The search assessment rights of a person under enquiry are narrower than most assume on the other side too: the officers may examine anyone on the premises, may seize books and assets, and may record a statement that the department will later rely on heavily. What happens in the first six hours often decides the assessment that follows two years later.
The authorisation, and what it does not reveal
The search power is conferred by the provision long numbered 132 in the 1961 Act, and it is carried into the current assessment law with a different number and the same substance. The officer must hold an authorisation in writing, and the person searched is entitled to be shown it. He is not entitled to see the reasons recorded by the authorising officer, because those are privileged, and a challenge to the sufficiency of the reasons is generally not entertained; what can be challenged is the absence of the statutory conditions, for instance an authorisation that does not name the premises or the person.
The authorisation defines the scope. A search of business premises does not authorise a search of a relative's residence, and a search for books does not authorise the seizure of a vehicle. Officers may, however, enter and search any premises where they have reason to believe that books or assets relating to the person are kept, so the practical reach is wider than the paper suggests.
On the day: what must happen
- Two independent witnesses: the search is conducted in the presence of two respectable inhabitants of the locality, and their signatures appear on the panchnama.
- The panchnama: a contemporaneous record of what was found, where it was found, and what was seized. A copy is given to the person searched.
- Seizure lists: each item is listed with a description, and cash and jewellery are counted and weighed in the presence of witnesses.
- Valuation: jewellery and valuables are valued by a valuer, and the valuation is part of the record.
- Restraint orders: the officers may prohibit the removal of any asset, and the order is served in writing.
- Locker operations: a bank locker is opened under a procedure with notice to the bank, and the inventory is recorded.
Where the search continues for more than a day, the premises may be sealed, and the person is entitled to be present when the seal is broken. A search that continues without a panchnama, or with a panchnama signed by witnesses who were not present, is a search that can be challenged — though the courts have generally declined to annul an assessment only because of an irregular search.
The statement recorded on the spot
The officers may examine any person on oath during the search and reduce the answers to writing. This statement is the single most important document in the file, and it is recorded in circumstances that are not conducive to care: at night, without a lawyer, with officers who have just seized the accounts.
Three points matter. First, the statement may be used in the assessment, and a disclosure made in it is difficult to resile from. Second, a retraction is possible, but it must be immediate, in writing, addressed to the officer, and supported by a reason — a retraction filed weeks later, after the assessment notice, carries little weight. Third, the person is entitled to a copy of the statement, to read it before signing, and to have corrections made where the record does not reflect what was said.
The practical rule is not to guess. An answer that estimates undisclosed income to bring the questioning to an end creates a demand that will be difficult to displace, and the honest answer to a question about a document is that the accountant will reconcile it.
The assessment that follows
After the search, notices are issued for the years the statute covers, and the assessee is required to furnish returns in response. The assessment is framed on the material found, and the settled rule — after years of litigation — is that in a case where an assessment for a year had already been completed, an addition can be made only on the basis of incriminating material found during the search. A completed assessment cannot be reopened in a search simply because the department now takes a different view of an old transaction.
Where no assessment had been completed, or where the return was pending, the assessment is not so confined, and the officer may examine the whole income for that year. The distinction drives the entire argument in a search case, and the paper book must show, year by year, whether an assessment was pending and what was found.
The assessment has a statutory time limit, which runs from the end of the financial year in which the search took place, and it has been extended by amendments more than once. The order must deal with the explanation offered, and a search assessment that simply aggregates the seized material without analysis is vulnerable in appeal.
Penalty and prosecution, which follow the search
Undisclosed income found in a search attracts a penalty under the specific provision for search cases, which operates in slabs depending on whether the undisclosed income was admitted in the statement and whether the tax was paid. Separate penalties apply for other defaults. Prosecution is available for wilful evasion and for false statements, and the department launches it selectively, usually where the undisclosed income is large or a statement was retracted.
Where the challenge goes
A writ petition before the Calcutta High Court against the search itself is admitted only in narrow circumstances — the absence of the authorisation, a search of premises not covered, or a seizure of documents protected by privilege. The ordinary route is the appeal against the assessment to the Commissioner (Appeals), then the tribunal, and then the High Court on a substantial question of law. The assessee who wants to settle may apply to the Interim Board that has replaced the Settlement Commission, subject to its eligibility conditions and its time limits.
The writ practice handles the challenges to the authorisation and the seizure, the compliance team reconstructs the books and prepares the year-wise reconciliation, and a prosecution is defended through the criminal law practice. The statements and the panchnama are the documents the appeal is built on, and the legal formats page carries the retraction and representation formats.
Can I call my lawyer during the search?
You may inform your lawyer and consult him, but the lawyer is not entitled to be present during the search or to sit in on the recording of a statement. The officers may allow a professional to assist in explaining the books, at their discretion.
Should I sign the statement?
Sign it after reading it, and ask for corrections where it does not record what you said. Refusing to sign does not prevent the officers from recording it, and a signature on an inaccurate statement is worse than an unsigned one with a written note of objection.
Can the department search my residential premises for a business enquiry?
Yes, if the authorisation covers the premises and the officer has reason to believe that books or assets relating to the person are kept there. The authorisation must name the premises.
How long does a search assessment take?
The statute fixes a period running from the end of the financial year of the search, and extensions have been legislated over the years. In practice these assessments take two to three years, and appeals add more.
On the day, the panchnama and the statement are the only documents that will exist. Read both before signing, take a copy of each, and let the reconciliation wait for the accountant rather than for an estimate given at two in the morning.