A gst section 67 search seizure begins with a document and ends with an inventory. The officer must carry a written authorisation from the competent authority, must conduct the search in the presence of two independent witnesses, must prepare a list of the goods seized, and must give the trader a copy of the records prepared. A search that begins without the authorisation, or ends without the inventory, is a search that the trader can challenge, and the challenge is worth making because the material seized is the evidence on which the demand will later be built.
The provision allows a joint commissioner or an authorised officer to inspect the premises, search and seize goods, documents and books, and to require the production of records. It is a power of inspection and seizure, not a power of arrest; the power to arrest is separate and is exercised under different conditions. Confusing the two is what produces the panic that officers sometimes rely on.
The authorisation, and the first thing to ask for
Ask to see the authorisation before anything is opened. It should identify the officer, the premises and the purpose, and it should be signed by the authority competent to issue it. Note the name, the designation and the authorisation number, and ask for a copy. An officer who cannot produce it is not authorised to conduct the search, and the trader should record the refusal in his own notes and in a letter the same day.
The search is to be conducted in the presence of two independent witnesses, preferably from the neighbourhood or the market, and their names and addresses are to be recorded. The witnesses are not participants; their presence is a safeguard, and a mahazar or panchnama signed by them records what was found, where it was found, and in what condition.
Where the search extends to a residential premises or to a locker, the authorisation must cover it, and the procedure is stricter. A trader whose home is searched under an authorisation that names only the business premises should say so at once, in writing.
What may be seized, and what may not
Goods that are liable to confiscation, and books, registers and documents relevant to the proceedings, may be seized. Cash may be seized where the officer has reason to believe it represents the proceeds of a transaction that has evaded tax, but a blanket seizure of cash from the counter without a recorded reason is a common excess. The trader should ask, in writing, for the reason for each seizure.
Documents that are not relevant to the enquiry should not be taken, and the inventory should describe each item so that the trader can identify it later. Where the officer takes the hard disk of a computer or the backup of an accounting system, the inventory should record the serial numbers and the period covered, and the trader should retain a copy of the data if possible.
Seized goods are kept in custody, and the trader can apply for provisional release on payment of the tax and a bond or security. The application should be made promptly, because perishable goods are disposed of and the proceeds held, and a long custody is itself a loss.
The statement recorded during a search
Officers often record a statement of the proprietor or the accountant during the search. The statement is admissible, and a statement given in the fatigue of a long search, without the accounts, is the statement that is later used against the trader. The trader is entitled to have the statement read over, to correct it, and to decline to answer a question that requires him to admit an offence.
The protection against self-incrimination applies, and a statement taken under coercion is not voluntary. The practical course is to answer questions of fact — the address, the nature of the business, the location of the records — and to state, in writing, that the accounts are being seized and that the questions of computation cannot be answered without them.
Where the statement is recorded on several pages, each page should be read and signed only after correction. Do not sign a blank page and do not sign a statement in a language you do not read. Ask for a copy of the statement, and if it is refused, ask the officer to record the request.
The inventory, and the copy that must be given
The inventory is the heart of the record. It should list each item, the quantity, the description, the value as recorded by the officer, and the place from which it was taken. It should be signed by the officer, the witnesses and the trader or his representative, and a copy must be given to the trader. Without the copy, the trader cannot challenge what was taken.
Where the trader disputes an entry, he should write his objection on the inventory itself, next to the entry, and sign it. An objection recorded at the time is evidence. An objection raised six months later in a reply is an afterthought.
Photographs of the premises, the goods and the inventory pages, taken with the date and time visible, are worth the two minutes they take. Where the search continues for hours, keep a note of the time each stage began and ended, and of who was present.
After the search: the notice, the reply and the assessment
The seizure is followed by a notice to the trader, and the material seized is used in the assessment. The reply to the notice should deal with each item in the inventory: what it is, why it was in the premises, and how it is accounted for in the books. Where the officer has computed a turnover from loose sheets or a diary, the reply should deal with the sheets individually, because a general denial invites the inference that the computation stands.
The trader should obtain copies of the seized records for the reply. The law allows the person from whose custody the records were seized to obtain copies, and the request should be made in writing to the officer and, if necessary, to the commissioner. Where copies are refused, the reply can be filed on the basis of the inventory and the trader's own records, with a request for the copies.
The assessment order that follows is appealable, and the grounds should include any procedural defect in the search — the absence of the authorisation, the absence of independent witnesses, the failure to give the inventory, the denial of copies. Procedural defects do not automatically vitiate the assessment, but they affect the weight of the evidence and they are relevant to penalty.
Our page on GST and indirect tax covers the reply and the appeal, and criminal law covers the position where a prosecution is launched.
Common questions
Can a search be conducted at night?
The law does not prohibit a search at night, but the officer must record the reasons and the safeguards apply with greater force. A search that begins at midnight and continues without a mahazar, without witnesses and without food or rest is a search that will be examined closely.
Is a lawyer allowed during the search?
The trader is entitled to have a representative present, and a lawyer or an accountant can attend. The officer may regulate who enters the premises during the search, but a refusal to allow the trader's authorised representative is a matter to record and to raise in the reply and, if necessary, before the High Court.
Can the officer arrest during a search?
The power to arrest is separate from the power to search, and it is exercised only on the conditions the law specifies. A search does not by itself authorise an arrest, and an arrest made without the recorded satisfaction required is vulnerable.
What happens to the seized goods?
They are held in custody until the proceedings end, unless released provisionally on payment and security. Perishable goods are disposed of and the proceeds held. The trader should apply for provisional release early and keep the application and the order.
If a search has just happened, the inventory copy and the authorisation are the two documents to secure, and the statement should be read before it is signed. Bring them to a consultation, or write to the office the same day, because the reply timeline starts at once.