14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Tax & GST

Section 16(4) credit time limit, and the relaxation

Input tax credit on an invoice for a financial year must be taken before the thirtieth of November of the following year, or before the annual return for that year is filed, whichever is earlier. That is the rule in Section 16(4) of the GST law, and it applies even where the invoice has been received late, even where the supplier has only now uploaded it, and even where the taxpayer had no way of knowing that the credit was available. The gst section 16(4) credit time limit has no provision for condonation in the section itself, and that is what made it harsh.

The harshness was recognised. The annual return for 2017-18 was due years after the transition, the portal did not always show the supplier's invoices, and the supplier's failure to file could deny the buyer a credit that the law intended him to have. The 2024 amendment addressed the position retrospectively, and it is the first thing to check before a demand for a past year is accepted.

The rule, and the two dates

The condition applies to the credit relating to an invoice or a debit note for a financial year. The credit must be taken by the thirtieth of November following that year, or by the date of filing the annual return, whichever is earlier. The annual return is usually filed before the thirtieth of November in any event, and the practical deadline is therefore the thirtieth of November for most taxpayers.

The condition operates on the taking of the credit, not on the receipt of the invoice. A taxpayer who receives the invoice in December of the following year cannot take the credit, and the remedy, where the supplier is compliant, is to ask him to issue a fresh invoice in the current year, if the transaction permits it. That is not always possible, and the credit is then lost.

The other conditions in the same section are cumulative. The taxpayer must be in possession of a tax invoice, must have received the goods or services, must have the invoice furnished in his return, must have received the tax, and must have the details appearing in his auto-populated statement. Section 16(4) sits on top of all of them, and a demand often fails on one of the others even where the time limit is met.

The retrospective relief of 2024

The Finance Act, 2024 inserted new sub-sections into Section 16, with retrospective effect from the first of July 2017, to relieve the lapse for the early years of the GST regime. In substance, the relief allows credit for invoices relating to the financial years 2017-18 to 2020-21 to be taken up to the thirtieth of November 2021, notwithstanding the earlier deadline, provided the credit was not availed and the returns for the period were filed.

The relief comes with conditions that decide most cases. It is not available where the department has already initiated proceedings for recovery of the credit as wrongly availed, and it is not available where the credit was availed and then reversed for a reason other than the time limit. Where the taxpayer has already paid an amount towards such a demand, the provisions deal with the adjustment or the refund.

The practical effect is that a demand for a 2019-20 credit denied only on limitation, for a taxpayer who filed his returns and did not otherwise claim the credit, is answerable. The reply should invoke the retrospective provision, set out the dates, produce the returns and the credit ledger, and ask for the demand to be dropped.

How the order gets issued, and what to check in it

The demand usually arrives in an assessment order for the year, or in a notice proposing reversal. Read the order for the reason given: if the only reason is that the credit was taken after the thirtieth of November, the retrospective relief is directly relevant. If the reason is that the supplier has not filed, the relief does not help, and the answer is the supplier's compliance or the payment to him.

Check whether the credit was in fact taken in the year in question, and whether it was taken through the annual return or through a later return. The ledger is the record, and a mismatch between the order and the ledger is a ground of appeal even before the merits.

Check whether the demand has been computed with interest, and from which date. Interest on an erroneous credit runs from the date of utilisation, not the date of the invoice, and an order that computes it from the invoice date overstates the demand.

The reply and the appeal

  1. Set out the invoice, the date, the supplier, the amount and the period to which it relates.
  2. Produce the ledger showing when the credit was taken, and the returns for the periods concerned.
  3. Invoke the retrospective provision where the year is covered, with the text and the date of effect.
  4. Deal with any other ground in the order — the supplier's filing, the receipt of goods, the matching — separately, because the retrospective relief does not answer those.
  5. Ask for the personal hearing, and put the submissions on record at the hearing.

Where the order is confirmed, the appeal lies to the appellate authority with the pre-deposit, and the grounds should reproduce the reply's reasoning. An appeal that repeats the reply without addressing the order's findings is a weak appeal.

The larger lesson is procedural. The credit should be reconciled monthly, not annually, and the invoices that are missing from the auto-populated statement should be pursued with the supplier in the same quarter. A credit that is taken in time and matched is a credit that does not need a retrospective relief.

Our page on GST and indirect tax covers the returns and the appeal, and corporate compliance covers the monthly reconciliation that prevents the problem.

Common questions

Does the time limit apply to debit notes as well?

Yes. The section refers to an invoice or a debit note, and a debit note issued by the supplier for an upward revision is subject to the same deadline. A credit note reduces the credit, and its treatment is separately provided.

Can the time limit be extended by the department?

No. The date is in the statute, and the retrospective relief was given by an amendment, not by an administrative order. A taxpayer who missed the date for a year outside the relief has no route to condonation within the section.

What if the supplier uploads the invoice after the deadline?

The credit cannot be taken for that year, and the auto-populated statement will not show it in time. The remedy is against the supplier for the tax he has collected, and, where the transaction can be re-invoiced, a fresh invoice in the current period.

Does the relief cover credit that was never claimed at all?

It covers credit that was not availed within the original deadline, and the conditions in the new sub-sections decide whether it can still be availed. Where the credit was never claimed and the period is covered, the route is to claim it within the extended date the provision allows, with the returns already filed.

If a demand has been received for a year between 2017-18 and 2020-21, the retrospective provision is worth checking before anything is paid. Bring the order, the ledger and the returns to a consultation, or read the GST pages and contact the office with the order attached.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422