14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Tax & GST

Section 54 and 54F: the conditions that must be met

Capital gains on property can be exempted if the proceeds are put into a house, but the exemption is not a rebate on intention. Section 54 applies to gains on the transfer of a residential house, and Section 54F applies to gains on the transfer of any other asset that is reinvested in a residential house. The conditions are time-bound, the investment must be made in the manner the section prescribes, and a claim that misses a condition is a claim that the assessing officer will disallow in full, not proportionately.

The section 54 54f exemption rules changed again in 2024, with the change in the long-term capital gains rate and the removal of indexation for transfers on or after the twenty-third of July 2024. The conditions for the exemption did not change, but the arithmetic of the gain did, and a computation prepared on the old basis will overstate or understate the exempt amount.

Section 54: a house for a house

The exemption under Section 54 is available to an individual or a Hindu undivided family on the transfer of a residential house, where the gain is invested in the purchase of one residential house in India, or in the construction of one residential house in India. The purchase must be made within one year before or two years after the date of transfer, and the construction must be completed within three years from the date of transfer.

The exemption is the capital gain or the cost of the new house, whichever is lower, and where the cost of the new house is less than the gain, the balance remains taxable. The new house must be in India, and it must be a residential house; a commercial unit does not qualify.

The section allows a relaxation for a taxpayer whose gain does not exceed two crore rupees: two residential houses may be purchased, once in a lifetime, provided the same is not availed again. The cap on the investment for the purpose of the exemption was fixed at ten crore rupees, and the amount above the cap is not counted for the exemption. The two limits operate differently, and both should be checked against the current text.

Section 54F: any asset for a house

The exemption under Section 54F is available on the transfer of any long-term asset other than a residential house — shares, land, commercial property, jewellery — where the net consideration is invested in one residential house in India. The purchase must be within one year before or two years after the transfer, and the construction within three years.

The exemption is proportionate. Where the entire net consideration is invested, the whole gain is exempt; where a part is invested, the exemption is the gain multiplied by the amount invested and divided by the net consideration. The distinction between the gain and the net consideration is where claims are lost: Section 54 compares the investment with the gain, while Section 54F compares it with the consideration.

The section carries a condition that the taxpayer should not own more than one residential house, other than the new one, on the date of transfer of the original asset, and should not purchase another residential house within two years or construct one within three years. A second house acquired within the window defeats the exemption, and the department checks the property records.

The mechanics of claiming

  1. Compute the capital gain, with the cost of acquisition, the improvement and the transfer expenses, and the indexation where it is available.
  2. Identify the exemption and confirm the eligibility: the nature of the asset, the number of houses owned, and the identity of the taxpayer.
  3. Invest within the time allowed, and keep the purchase deed, the construction bills and the completion certificate.
  4. Where the investment is not made before the return is due, deposit the amount in the capital gains accounts scheme before the due date, and use it for the purchase or construction within the period.
  5. Claim the exemption in the return, with the computation and the details of the new asset, and retain the evidence for the assessment.

The deposit in the capital gains accounts scheme is not optional where the money is not yet spent. A claim without the deposit, where the investment is made after the due date, is a claim that will be disallowed, because the section requires the amount to be utilised within the period and the scheme is the mechanism that preserves the claim in the meantime.

Where the claim is lost

The common failures are predictable. The purchase is made in the name of a family member, and the exemption is claimed by the taxpayer who transferred the asset. The construction is not completed within three years, and the exemption is withdrawn. Two houses are purchased where the gain exceeds the two crore limit for the relaxation. A second house is bought within the prohibited period, and the exemption is withdrawn with interest. And the new house is sold within three years, which brings the exempted gain back into charge in the year of sale.

The lock-in on the new house is three years for Section 54 and Section 54F, and a sale within that period reverses the exemption. The reversal is computed on the gain that was exempted, and it is taxed in the year of the sale of the new house. Families that buy and sell within three years often discover the reversal only when the return is processed.

The ownership condition under Section 54F is tested on the date of transfer of the original asset, not on the date of the new purchase. A house inherited after the transfer does not affect the claim, while a house purchased a day before does.

Records to keep, and how long

Keep the sale deed of the original asset, the purchase deed of the new asset, the construction bills and the architect's certificate, the capital gains accounts scheme passbook and the withdrawal records, and the computation. Where the property was inherited, keep the parent's deed and the succession documents, because the cost of acquisition is the previous owner's cost in the case of a gift or inheritance, and the holding period includes the previous owner's period.

Keep them for the period of the assessment and the appeal, and longer if the new house is sold within the lock-in. A claim that is examined six years later needs the bills from six years ago.

Our pages on property registration and property law cover the documents, and tax practice covers the assessment and the appeal.

Common questions

Can both exemptions be claimed in the same year?

No. The two sections apply to different assets, and the same gain cannot be exempted under both. A taxpayer who sells a house claims Section 54; a taxpayer who sells shares or land claims Section 54F.

Is a flat purchased under construction eligible?

Yes, where the construction is completed within three years and the possession is delivered. The payment schedule and the completion certificate are the evidence, and a flat that is still under construction at the end of the period is not eligible.

What if the new house is in a family member's name?

The exemption is available to the taxpayer who transferred the original asset, and the new house must be purchased by him. A purchase in the name of a spouse or a child, funded by the taxpayer, does not ordinarily support the claim, though the position depends on the facts and the source of funds.

Does the exemption apply to a long-term gain taxed at the new rate?

Yes. The exemption operates on the gain, whatever the rate at which the gain is taxed. The rate change of 2024 affects the quantum of the gain and the tax, not the eligibility for the exemption.

A capital gains claim is best planned before the sale, not after the return. If a property is being sold and the reinvestment is not yet decided, bring the computation and the proposed purchase to a consultation, or write to the office before the deposit deadline.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422