Sections 66C and 66D of the Information Technology Act, 2000 deal with two offences that look similar and are charged together. Section 66C covers the fraudulent use of another person's electronic signature, password or unique identification feature. Section 66D covers cheating by personation using a computer resource or a communication device. Both carry imprisonment up to three years and a fine that may extend to one lakh rupees.
What Section 66C requires
The offence has three ingredients. First, there must be an electronic signature, a password or another unique identification feature. These are the credentials by which a person is identified in a system: the login credentials of an account, an e-sign facility, a digital signature, an Aadhaar-linked authentication or a one-time password. Second, the feature must belong to another person. Third, it must be used fraudulently or dishonestly.
The point of the section is the misuse of identity, not the deception that follows. A man who obtains a customer's net banking credentials and logs into the account to transfer funds has committed the offence under this section at the moment of login, before the transfer is made. The transfer may be charged separately under the penal code's provisions on cheating, or under the computer offence provisions of the Act, but the identity offence is complete on its own.
The common cases are the OTP fraud, where the fraudster obtains the one-time password by telephoning the account holder and pretending to be from the bank; the SIM swap, where a duplicate SIM is obtained in the victim's name; and the use of a scanned signature or an Aadhaar number to open an account or obtain a loan.
What Section 66D requires
This section covers cheating by personation through a computer resource or a communication device. Personation means pretending to be someone else, and the cheating is the deception that causes a person to deliver property or to be harmed. The deception must be practised using a computer resource or a communication device, which includes a mobile phone, a messaging account, a website, a fake profile and an email address.
The ingredients are therefore the pretence of a false identity, the dishonest inducement, and the delivery of property or the infliction of harm as a result. A fake profile on a social platform that solicits money is the clearest example. A spoofed email from a company's director instructing a payment is another. A fraudulent merchant website that takes payment and delivers nothing is a third, though that case may also be charged under the general provisions on cheating.
Both offences are cognizable and bailable in the ordinary case, and the investigation is conducted by the police. Where the offence is committed in more than one state, the trial can be conducted in a court having jurisdiction over any of the places, and the prosecution can seek the transfer of the case to a single court under the procedural provisions that deal with offences committed in several jurisdictions. How such a prosecution is conducted is described under criminal law.
Charging both, and the overlap with other provisions
The prosecution will usually charge several sections together. The identity offence under Section 66C, the personation offence under Section 66D, the unauthorised access offence under the computer offences provision of the Act, and the cheating and conspiracy provisions of the penal law, which have been re-enacted in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. Where the offence involves a forged document, the forgery provisions are added. Where the offender is a public servant or an intermediary, the Act has its own provisions on breach of confidentiality and on the failure of an intermediary to comply with obligations.
Charging several sections is not enough on its own. Each offence has its own ingredients, and the final report must state the material showing each. A final report that repeats the same facts and lists every section invites an application for discharge on the ground that the ingredients of the specific offences are absent. The other information technology offences that appear alongside them are dealt with under cyber law.
Proving the case
The evidence in these cases is almost entirely electronic, and its admissibility depends on the certificate that the law requires for an electronic record. That certificate should be prepared when the record is collected, not at the trial.
- The transaction records. The bank or wallet statements showing the transfers, with the account holder details and the timestamps.
- The subscriber records. The registration details of the email, the social account and the SIM used, obtained from the provider through a production notice.
- The access logs. The IP addresses and the device identifiers recorded by the platform or the bank, with the timestamps, supported by the certificate.
- The communication. The call records and the messages between the victim and the fraudster, preserved with the metadata.
- The identity documents said to have been used. The Aadhaar, the PAN or the signature, with the victim's proof that he did not authorise the use.
The weak link in most prosecutions is the link between the device and the person. An IP address identifies a connection, not a user, and a mobile number identifies a SIM subscriber, not necessarily the man holding the phone. The prosecution has to build the link through the beneficiary account, the withdrawal location, the CCTV at the ATM, the device seizure, or a co-accused's disclosure. A case that stops at the IP address can be defended.
The defences
Four arguments recur. That the accused was not the user of the device or the account, which is the same as attacking the identification. That the credentials were used with authority, which answers the fraud element under Section 66C. That the transaction was a commercial dispute, where the person who received the money had a genuine supply to make and failed to make it. And that the person acted without knowledge of the fraud, which is answered by the bank trail showing where the money went and what the accused did with his share of it.
A person who lends his account to another, or who receives and forwards money for a commission, is in a difficult position. Courts have treated the onward transfer of unexplained funds as material supporting knowledge, and the burden of explaining the transaction falls on the account holder, who is the only person able to produce the documents. Our page on cyber fraud deals with the practical position of a person whose account receives such a payment.
What a victim should do
- Report to the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal and the financial fraud helpline within hours, so that the beneficiary accounts can be flagged.
- File a complaint with the cyber crime police station, with the transaction references and the screenshots.
- Inform the bank in writing and keep the acknowledgement.
- Preserve the device and the messages, and do not delete the account or the chat history.
- Follow up for the production notices to the platform and the bank, and keep the case number for the recovery application.
Common questions
Can a person be prosecuted under Section 66C if he used his own credentials on someone else's account?
The section speaks of the identity feature of another person. Using one's own credentials to access an account that belongs to someone else is generally charged under the unauthorised access provisions and the penal law, and not under Section 66C. The sections are applied according to the ingredient that fits the facts.
Is a fake social media profile an offence under Section 66D?
Where it is used to deceive and to obtain money or property, yes. A fake profile that is merely an alias, without deception and without a wrongful gain, does not make out the offence. The deception and the inducement are elements that must be proved.
What is the punishment under both sections?
Each carries imprisonment that may extend to three years and a fine that may extend to one lakh rupees. Where the offences are charged with the penal code provisions on cheating, the aggregate sentence is decided on the counts on which the accused is convicted.
Can the case be compounded or settled?
A settlement between the victim and the accused can lead to the compounding of the penal code counts with the court's permission. Offences under the information technology law are not compounded as freely, and the prosecution's consent and the court's approval are required, which is why a settlement usually results in the accused's cooperation in the trial and a lighter sentence rather than an acquittal.
Both sections turn on identity and on deception, and both are proved by records rather than by testimony. A victim who reports quickly gives the police the logs and the account trail; a victim who reports late gives them a story. On the other side, a person who explains his account activity with documents stays a witness, and one who cannot explain it becomes an accused.