14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Corporate & Insolvency

Share transfer: the SH-4, the stamp duty and the board

A transfer of shares in a private company is complete when the board approves it and the company enters the transferee's name in the register of members. The SH-4 instrument of transfer, properly stamped and delivered, is the document that starts the procedure. A buyer who has paid and holds a signed SH-4 but is not in the register is not yet a shareholder, and cannot vote, receive a dividend, or sell.

The instrument: Form SH-4

Form SH-4 is the instrument of transfer prescribed under the Companies Act. It records the transferor, the transferee, the number and distinctive numbers of the shares, the consideration, and the date. Both parties sign it, and it is delivered to the company.

Delivery has to be within sixty days of the date on the instrument. After that, the company may decline to register it, and the parties are left to a fresh instrument or to an application to the tribunal. This deadline is missed constantly, usually because the buyer and seller signed and then waited for a payment that took months.

The instrument must be properly stamped. Stamp duty on a share transfer is charged under the state stamp law on the consideration, and the rate depends on the schedule in force. An instrument that is not stamped, or is under-stamped, will be impounded when produced, and the company's registration on an unstamped instrument is open to challenge.

The board resolution and the company's duty

The board has to approve the transfer. In a private company, the articles almost always contain a restriction: a right of first refusal for the existing members, a requirement of board approval, or a lock-in. The board's power to refuse is real but it is not unlimited — a refusal must be exercised in good faith and in the interest of the company, not to entrench a director.

Once the instrument is delivered, the company must register the transfer or send a notice of refusal within the period the Act prescribes. An unexplained silence does not amount to registration. If the company refuses, the transferee may appeal to the National Company Law Tribunal, and a refusal that is arbitrary is set aside.

The board then passes a resolution approving the transfer, the register of members is updated, and the share certificates are issued to the transferee within the statutory period. For a private company, the certificates have to be issued within two months of the allotment or the transfer, and the company's failure is an offence.

What the transferee must check before paying

Most share transfer disputes are caused by what was not checked. Before paying, a buyer should see:

  • The articles of association, for the transfer restriction and the pre-emptive right.
  • The register of members, to confirm the seller actually holds the shares and how many.
  • The share certificate, and whether it is in the seller's name.
  • The board resolution for the original allotment, and the MCA records for the paid-up capital.
  • A no-objection or waiver from the members who hold a right of first refusal.
  • The company's latest financial statements and its status on the MCA portal.

A buyer who skips the first of these can pay for shares that the articles do not permit him to hold.

Consideration, valuation and tax

A transfer at less than fair market value attracts attention from the tax authorities. For unlisted shares, the fair market value is computed on the prescribed basis, and a transfer below it can be treated as a deemed gift in the hands of the recipient, with the difference taxed. A transfer above the value has its own consequences for the seller's capital gains.

The seller's capital gain is computed from the cost of acquisition, and the holding period decides whether it is long term. The buyer's cost is the price paid, and that becomes the base for the buyer's own gain on a later sale. The valuation report should be obtained before the transfer, not after, because it is the document the assessing officer will ask for.

Where the transfer is between relatives or between a company and its subsidiary, there are specific provisions and exemptions, and the transaction should be structured with them in mind rather than corrected afterwards.

What goes wrong in practice

Four failures account for most of the litigation:

  1. The SH-4 was never delivered. The parties signed, paid, and forgot the company. Years later the buyer discovers he is not a member.
  2. The board never approved. A resolution is recorded in the minutes but never signed, or is passed at a meeting that did not have a quorum.
  3. The register was not updated. The company's MCA filings still show the seller as the shareholder, which matters at the time of a bank loan or a sale of the company.
  4. The stamp duty was not paid. The instrument is impounded, the registration is challenged, and the parties litigate about who should bear the duty.
The register of members is the company's own record of who owns it. A court will look at the register before it looks at anything else.

Transmission, and the difference from transfer

Where a shareholder dies, the shares pass by transmission, not transfer. The legal heirs apply to the company with the death certificate, the succession certificate or the probate, and the company registers them as members. The stamp duty and the SH-4 do not apply, but the company will require the succession document before it acts, and a private company's articles may impose additional conditions.

Where shares are held jointly, the death of one holder is dealt with by the survivor, and the company registers the survivor as the sole holder on proof.

Common questions

Is a share purchase agreement enough?

No. The agreement is the contract between buyer and seller. The SH-4 is the instrument that moves the shares, and the board resolution is what makes the company recognise the move. All three are needed.

Can a private company refuse any transfer?

It can refuse where the articles permit and the refusal is in good faith. It cannot refuse arbitrarily, and the transferee has a remedy before the National Company Law Tribunal.

Who pays the stamp duty?

The parties agree between themselves, and the instrument is not validly registered until the duty is paid. In practice the transferee pays, and the agreement should say so.

Get the articles, the register and the resolution before the money moves. Where the company refuses to register the transfer, the transferee's application to the National Company Law Tribunal must be filed within the period the Act allows. Our corporate law practice handles share transfers and tribunal applications, corporate compliance covers the MCA filings that follow, and shareholder agreements covers the restrictions that should be agreed before a transfer is attempted.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422