A fake page using a business's name and logo is a trade mark problem, a cyber crime and an urgent commercial risk, because the customers who are defrauded blame the brand they thought they were dealing with. The three remedies work together: a takedown request to the platform, a suit for infringement and passing off with an interim injunction, and a criminal complaint against the person who created the page. Each produces a document that supports the others.
Getting the page taken down
Platforms are intermediaries under the information technology rules, and those rules require them to appoint a grievance officer, to acknowledge a complaint within a short period, and to dispose of it within a fixed period. Where a court or a competent authority passes an order, the intermediary must remove the unlawful content within the period prescribed in the rules, which is short.
An emergency takedown request should be made on the platform's own form, in the category it provides for impersonation, with the registration certificate of the trade mark, proof of the business's identity, the uniform resource locators of the fake page, and screenshots. A complaint made through the correct channel is usually acted on within days; one sent to a general support address is not.
Keep every ticket number and every reply. A platform that refuses to act after a proper complaint is itself exposed, and its refusal is a fact to be placed before the court. Log the takedown requests in a single table with the date, the channel and the outcome, because the chronology will be needed in the suit.
The trademark action
Where the business has a registered trade mark, an unauthorised use of the mark in relation to the same or similar goods or services is infringement. Where the mark is unregistered, the remedy is an action for passing off, which requires proof of reputation, misrepresentation and damage. In an online impersonation case the misrepresentation is usually obvious: the page uses the name, the logo and the description, and it solicits orders or payments.
The suit is filed with an application for an interim injunction restraining the defendant from using the mark or any deceptively similar name. Because the defendant may be unidentified, the practice is to sue the persons unknown and to obtain an order that restrains anyone operating the impugned page, which the platform then acts on. An ex parte order is obtained where the applicant satisfies the court of the urgency and, importantly, makes full disclosure of everything known about the page.
Along with the injunction, the plaintiff can seek an order directing the platform to disclose the registration details of the account, which is often the only way to identify the person behind it. The platform will comply with a court order in a way that it will not comply with a private request.
The criminal complaint
Using another's identity on a computer resource to cheat is an offence under the information technology legislation, and the identity theft provision covers the dishonest use of another's electronic signature, password or unique identification feature. The penal law adds cheating, forgery and the use of a forged document, and the trade mark statute punishes the falsification of a mark and its false application to goods.
Where customers paid money to the fake page, the complaint should be framed with their statements and the payment records, because the loss of the customers is the loss that makes out the offence. A complaint that describes only the business's annoyance is weaker than one that attaches the payments made by deceived customers.
The complaint is filed before the magistrate having jurisdiction, ordinarily the place where the business carries on business or where the payments were received, and it may be lodged at the local police station or with the cyber crime cell of the Kolkata Police at the headquarters at Lalbazar. Where the police do not act, the remedies are a written complaint to the superintendent of police and thereafter an application to the magistrate.
The lookalike domain
A domain that copies the business's name with a different extension or a transposed letter is a common companion to the fake page. Where the domain is a country code domain administered under the national registry, a dispute resolution complaint can be filed under the applicable domain dispute policy, which requires the complainant to show that the domain is identical or confusingly similar to a mark in which he has rights, that the registrant has no rights or legitimate interest in it, and that it was registered and is being used in bad faith. For a generic top-level domain, the corresponding policy applies through the approved dispute resolution providers.
The domain complaint is usually faster and cheaper than a court case, and it produces a transfer or cancellation order. It does not produce damages, and it does not identify the registrant where the registration is behind a privacy service, though the provider will release the details on an order.
Reducing the damage to customers
A brand cannot prevent a fake page from appearing, but it can reduce the harm and improve its position. Publish a warning on the official pages and the website, describing the fake page and the fact that it is not authorised; instruct customers to pay only to the official account; and record the steps taken. Where the business learns that a customer paid the fake page, it should help the customer report, because that complaint is evidence in the business's own case.
The business's own takedown record, customer complaints and warning notices form the evidence of the damage that a passing off action requires. In practice, a file with a chronology of harm and a set of customer complaints is what persuades a court to grant an interim injunction quickly.
Kolkata forum and practice
Trade mark and copyright suits are commonly filed on the original side of the Calcutta High Court, which has the rules and the experience for interim injunctions in intellectual property matters; a suit of lower value may go to the City Civil Court at Kolkata. The criminal complaint goes to the magistrate having jurisdiction, or to the cyber crime cell. The domain complaint is filed online with the dispute resolution provider, and the proceedings are documentary.
The three proceedings can run together. The civil suit produces the injunction and the disclosure order, the criminal case produces the identity and the deterrent, and the domain complaint produces the transfer of the address. Our intellectual property practice runs the infringement and passing off action, cyber law handles the complaint, and the defamation notice practice is relevant where the fake page also publishes false statements about the business.
Common questions
Can I sue an unknown person online?
Yes. The suit names the persons unknown who operate the page, and the court can grant an injunction against them and direct the platform to disclose the account details. The disclosure is what turns an unknown defendant into a named one.
Do I need a registered trade mark to act?
No. An action for passing off protects an unregistered mark based on reputation and use. Registration makes the case easier because it supplies a statutory right and a presumption.
How quickly can a page be removed?
The fastest route is often the platform's impersonation form, which can act within days. A court order is the route where the platform refuses or where the page reappears under another name. No one can promise a date, and a party should pursue both.
Is a fake customer care number a separate complaint?
It is the same conduct in a different form, and it is often the most damaging because it takes money from customers directly. It should be included in the criminal complaint with the call records and the payment details.
Act on all three fronts at once, and keep the chronology. If your business is being impersonated, contact the office; the fees for consultation and for court appearances are published.