14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Employment & Labour

Standing orders: the certified rules that govern a factory

In an establishment covered by the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1946, the terms of service that matter — shift timings, attendance, leave, the disciplinary procedure, the grounds for termination — are not left to the appointment letter. They are set out in standing orders, drafted by the employer, certified by a public officer after hearing the workmen, and posted where every worker can read them. The standing orders industrial employment regime exists so that a worker knows in advance what the rules are, and so that a dismissal can be tested against a written procedure rather than against the manager's recollection.

This is the first document a labour court asks for in a dismissal case. Where the standing orders are certified and the procedure in them has been followed, the employer's case is straightforward. Where they were never certified, or were certified years ago and never updated, the employer has to justify a termination against the model standing orders and against the principles of natural justice, which is a harder position.

Which establishments are covered

The Act applies to industrial establishments employing the number of workmen prescribed — the threshold in the central Act is one hundred, and it is the number employed on any day. It covers factories, and it covers establishments that the appropriate government has brought within it by notification. In West Bengal the state has its own rules, and the establishments covered include factories and a range of commercial and industrial establishments notified by the state government.

The threshold question matters, because a small unit that grows past it must submit its draft standing orders within six months of becoming covered. Growth by hiring is the usual trigger, and the obligation is the employer's, not the workman's. A workman in a covered establishment whose employer has never submitted a draft is not without a remedy: he can apply to the certifying officer, and the officer can require the employer to act.

What the standing orders must contain

The Schedule to the Act lists the matters that the model standing orders cover, and a certified set must address them:

  • Classification of workmen — permanent, probationer, badli, temporary, casual, apprentice.
  • Manner of intimating the hours of work, shift working, and the closing of sections.
  • Attendance, late arrival, and the procedure for granting leave.
  • Shift working and the notice required before a change of shift.
  • Wage rates and the date of payment, and deductions authorised by law.
  • Termination of employment, and the notice period for each class of workman.
  • Suspension, and the subsistence allowance during suspension.
  • Disciplinary action for misconduct, the acts that constitute misconduct, and the procedure of enquiry.
  • Redress of grievances, and the machinery for it.

An employer may add matters, and many do — safety rules, the use of mobile phones on the shop floor, the consequences of theft or of fighting. What the employer cannot do is certify a rule that is inconsistent with the Act or with any other law, or a rule that is unfair on its face. The certifying officer is required to hear the workmen's representatives before certifying, and to modify a draft that is inconsistent or unreasonable.

The certification process, in order

  1. The employer submits five copies of the draft standing orders, with the prescribed fee, to the certifying officer for the jurisdiction — in West Bengal the labour commissioner's establishment, through the regional office.
  2. The certifying officer sends a notice to the trade union, or to the workmen's representatives where there is no union, inviting objections within the period prescribed by the rules.
  3. A hearing is held. Objections are recorded, and the officer may require the employer to modify a clause.
  4. The officer certifies the standing orders, with or without modifications, and the certified text is binding on the employer and the workmen.
  5. The certified standing orders are posted on the notice board in the establishment, in English and in the language understood by the majority of the workmen.

A party aggrieved by the certification has thirty days from the date of the order to appeal to the appellate authority notified by the state government, and the appeal is heard as a civil court proceeding. Beyond thirty days the order stands, which is why the date on the order must be read carefully before any decision to appeal.

Modification, and the ten-year old set

Standing orders are not permanent. An employer who wants to change a rule — a shift system, the notice period, the list of misconducts — must apply to the certifying officer for modification, and the same procedure of notice, hearing and certification applies. The Act also allows the officer to review a certified set on his own motion, or on an application by the workmen, after the period prescribed by the rules.

The practical problem in old establishments is that the certified set dates from the 1980s and the establishment now runs three shifts, uses contract labour, and has a different product line. The rules are then silent on the situation that actually arises, and a disciplinary action on a matter the standing orders do not list becomes contestable. An employer in that position should modify the standing orders rather than rely on an appointment letter that contradicts them.

Enforcement when the rules are ignored

A dismissal that violates the certified standing orders is a dismissal without jurisdiction in substance, and a labour court can set it aside. The usual grounds are that the enquiry was not held in the manner the standing orders prescribe, that the punishment was disproportionate, or that the misconduct alleged is not one the standing orders list.

Where the employer has failed to certify at all, the workman's case is that the termination was without a valid procedure. The employer will point to the appointment letter and to the model standing orders; the workman will point to the absence of certification and to the statutory duty. Tribunals have taken the view that the model standing orders apply until the establishment's own are certified, which usually helps the workman on notice and on the enquiry.

The forum is the labour court or the industrial tribunal for the district, on a reference from the appropriate government, or the authority under the Shops and Establishments Act where the establishment is a shop. Our page on labour and employment law explains how a reference is obtained, and service law covers the parallel route for government employees.

Common questions

Do standing orders apply to managers and supervisors?

The Act applies to workmen as defined in the Industrial Disputes Act, and a person in a managerial or supervisory capacity above the prescribed wage ceiling is outside that definition. The establishment's own certified standing orders may still cover supervisors by classification, but their enforceability against a manager is limited. The classification clause in the certified set is where the answer lies.

Can an employer dismiss without an enquiry if the standing orders allow it?

Only where the standing orders themselves provide for termination without enquiry in a defined situation, and even then the provision must be reasonable and must be applied to the facts. A clause that gives the manager an unfettered power to dismiss is liable to be struck down as unfair, and the tribunal will require an enquiry in any case where misconduct is alleged.

What is the difference between standing orders and a settlement?

Standing orders are a statutory instrument, certified by a public officer and binding on the establishment. A settlement under the Industrial Disputes Act is an agreement between the employer and the workmen, signed in the course of a dispute, and it binds the parties to it. Where the two conflict, the settlement can improve on the standing orders but cannot take away a statutory right.

Where can a workman see the certified copy?

The establishment must post the certified standing orders on its notice board, and the certifying officer's office maintains the certified copy for the establishment. A workman who is denied a copy can apply to the certifying officer, and the denial is itself a contravention of the Act.

If a dismissal has already happened, the standing orders are the first thing to obtain, because the whole case turns on what procedure they required. Bring the appointment letter, the termination order and the enquiry papers to a consultation, or begin with the contact form and the office will tell you which forum has jurisdiction over your establishment.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422