14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Corporate & Insolvency

Striking Off a Defunct Company Versus Winding Up

A company that has stopped trading but has no debts, no assets and no litigation can be removed from the register of companies by an application to the Registrar under Section 248 of the Companies Act, 2013. Winding up is the route where there are assets to distribute or creditors to answer, and it is slower and more expensive. A strike off takes months where the paperwork is clean; winding up can take years. The choice is not about preference: it depends on whether the company has liabilities.

The two procedures are not variations of each other

Striking off removes the name from the register. The company ceases to exist as a legal person on the date the Registrar publishes the notice in the Official Gazette. There is no liquidator, no distribution of assets to members, and no process for creditors to prove their claims. That is why the law permits it only where the liabilities have been extinguished.

Winding up is a process for ending a company's existence in an orderly way, realising its assets, paying its creditors and distributing the surplus. Where the ground is the inability to pay debts, that ground is now dealt with under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, before the NCLT. The Companies Act retains other grounds, including the just and equitable ground and persistent default in filing returns, and it retains the voluntary winding up procedure where the directors can make a declaration of solvency.

Removal of name by the Registrar

The Registrar may remove a company's name on two bases. First, on its own motion, where the company has failed to commence business within a year of incorporation, or has not carried on business for two immediately preceding financial years and has not applied for dormant status. Second, on the company's application, where the company has extinguished all its liabilities and either has not commenced operations within a year of incorporation or has ceased business for at least one financial year.

The Registrar's own-motion route begins with a notice to the company and the directors, and it can end in removal if there is no response. Companies discover this too late, usually when they try to open a bank account or bid for a contract and find that the company no longer exists.

The application by the company

  1. Hold a board meeting and pass a resolution to apply, and obtain the shareholders' approval by the requisite majority.
  2. Settle all liabilities: taxes, statutory dues, loans, dues to employees and vendors. The Registrar will look at the records of the income tax and GST departments and at any pending proceeding.
  3. Obtain the documents the rules require: an indemnity bond from the directors, an affidavit, a statement of accounts not older than thirty days, and a declaration that there is no pending litigation.
  4. File the application in the prescribed electronic form with the Registrar, with the prescribed fee.
  5. Respond to any objection, and wait for the Registrar's notice and the publication in the Official Gazette.

The application stands rejected where a prosecution is pending, where there are outstanding statutory dues, or where the directors cannot give a clean indemnity. A company that files a false declaration invites the consequence provided in the Act, and the declaration is a personal statement by each director.

What survives the striking off

The removal of the name does not extinguish the directors' liability. The Act provides expressly that the liability of every director, manager, other officer and member continues and may be enforced as if the company had not been dissolved. A director who believes that striking off the company writes off the company's dues is wrong; the dues may survive against him where he had given a personal guarantee or where a statute makes him liable.

The removal is also no answer to a pending tax proceeding. The income tax department can proceed against the company and, in an appropriate case, treat the company as not genuinely defunct. An assessment completed after the company is dissolved creates a real problem, and it is the reason a company with pending assessments should not apply for removal until they are concluded.

If a company has been struck off and a stakeholder wants it back, the Act allows an application to the Tribunal for restoration of the company's name, within the time the section prescribes. Orders of restoration are passed where the striking off was not justified or where it is just to restore, and the restored company is treated as if it had never been removed for many purposes. The application is heard by the NCLT.

Winding up and liquidation in practice

Where the company has debts it cannot pay, the creditor's route is an application under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code before the NCLT Kolkata bench, which begins a corporate insolvency resolution process. That process aims at resolution rather than liquidation, and liquidation follows only if no resolution plan is approved and the Tribunal orders it.

Where the company is solvent but the members want to end it, voluntary winding up is possible, with a declaration of solvency by the directors supported by an audited statement of the company's position and the approval of the members. The liquidator realises the assets, pays the creditors and distributes the surplus. The procedure is more elaborate than a Section 248 application, and it is the right route where there are assets.

Winding up is also ordered by the Tribunal on grounds such as conduct against the sovereignty and integrity of India, default in filing financial statements or annual returns for five consecutive years, or where the Tribunal is of the opinion that it is just and equitable. The just and equitable ground is a residual remedy, and it is now rarely used for a simple money dispute, since the insolvency process covers that.

Choosing, and the third option

The test is simple. If the company has no assets, no dues and no litigation, apply under Section 248. If it has assets but no creditors, consider voluntary winding up. If it has creditors and cannot pay, the insolvency process is the correct forum, and striking off will be refused.

There is a third option that companies overlook: dormancy. A company that wants to preserve its incorporation and its name can apply for the status of a dormant company, which relieves it of some compliance while keeping the entity alive. That is a sensible choice for a company that has paused its business but expects to restart.

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs portal carries the forms, the fees and the record of the company's filings. Before applying for removal, check the portal for pending prosecutions, the tax portal for outstanding demands, and the bank for a nil-balance confirmation. Our company formation and corporate compliance practices handle the application and the filings, and the insolvency practice covers the proceedings before the NCLT.

Common questions

Can a company with pending GST dues be struck off?

No. The dues must be settled or the application will be rejected. A company that applies without disclosing a demand risks prosecution for a false declaration.

Does striking off cancel the directors' personal guarantees?

No. A guarantee is a separate contract with the lender, and the company's removal has no effect on it. The lender can proceed against the guarantor as before.

Can a struck-off company be revived?

Yes, by an application to the Tribunal for restoration within the time the Act allows. The Tribunal has restored companies where the removal was without proper notice or where assets were discovered afterwards.

Is winding up cheaper than striking off?

No. Winding up involves a liquidator, valuations, notices to creditors and a longer timeline. Striking off is cheaper precisely because it does not resolve claims, which is why it is available only where the claims have already been settled.

Decide on the basis of the balance sheet and the pending files, not on the basis of the fee. If you are unsure whether your company qualifies for removal, contact us; our fees are published on the site.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422