A notice under Section 201 says that the deductor failed to deduct tax, or deducted it and did not pay it to the government. The consequence is that he is treated as an assessee in default, and the demand is raised on him with interest. The defence is not that the payment was made in good faith; it is that the tax has been paid by the payee, or that the demand is barred by the statutory limit, or that the payment was not subject to deduction at all. Each of those is provable from documents, and each has rescued a deductor from a demand that looked unanswerable.
The section 201 tds default proceedings are usually triggered by the annual statement matching, by the payee's return showing income that the deductor did not report, or by an inspection of the deductor's records. The notice comes with a computation, and the computation is the first thing to test.
What the section does
Where a person who is required to deduct tax fails to deduct, or after deducting fails to pay, he is deemed to be an assessee in default in respect of the tax. The officer may, after giving an opportunity to be heard, pass an order deeming him so, and the order carries the tax and the interest.
The interest has two rates. For a failure to deduct, interest runs at one per cent per month from the date on which the tax was deductible to the date on which it is actually paid. For a failure to pay after deduction, the rate is one and a half per cent per month from the date on which the tax was deducted to the date of payment. An order that applies the higher rate to a non-deduction overstates the demand, and the error is worth correcting.
The consequence extends beyond the demand. The expenditure on which the tax was not deducted may be disallowed in the computation of the deductor's income, to the extent of the statutory percentage, and a penalty may be imposed separately for the failure. The order, the disallowance and the penalty are three proceedings, and each must be answered.
The defence that usually works: the payee has paid
Where the payee has paid the tax and furnished his return, the deductor is not treated as in default, provided he produces the certificate from a chartered accountant in the prescribed form. The certificate confirms that the payee has included the income in his return, has paid the tax, and that no demand is outstanding against him.
The certificate must be obtained from the payee's accountant, and it must be specific. A general letter from the payee saying that he has paid tax is not enough, and the officer will ask for the return, the acknowledgement and the computation. Where the payee is a large supplier, the deductor should write to him at the first notice and ask for the certificate, because the timeline for the reply is short.
Where the payee has not paid, the deductor's position is weaker, but not hopeless. The argument is that the liability to deduct arose only if the payment fell within the charging provision, and that the payment was below the threshold, or was of a nature not covered. That argument turns on the nature of the payment and the contract, not on the payee's conduct.
The limitation, and the date the order must be passed
The statute fixes an outer limit for passing an order deeming a person to be an assessee in default, measured from the end of the financial year in which the payment was made or the credit was given. The period is generous, but it is finite, and an order passed after it is without jurisdiction.
The computation of the period is often disputed. Where the return for the quarter was filed late, where a correction statement was filed, and where the notice was issued in one year and the order in another, the dates must be reconstructed from the acknowledgements. A deductor who produces the acknowledgements can show that the order is barred; a deductor who has lost them cannot.
Keep the quarterly statement acknowledgements, the correction statements and the challans for the full period. They are the proof of the dates on which the limitation depends.
The reply, structured
- Set out the payments, the dates, the payees and the nature of each payment.
- Identify the payments on which deduction was required, and concede the tax on those alone.
- For the rest, set out why deduction was not required: the threshold, the exemption, the character of the payment, the payee's status.
- Attach the chartered accountant's certificates for the payees who have paid, with their returns and challans.
- Deal with the interest computation, the rate, and the date from which it runs.
- Ask for the personal hearing, and record the submissions at the hearing.
Pay the admitted amount with interest before the order where the amount is clear. A payment before the order reduces the interest and shows good faith, and it separates the genuine default from the disputed demand.
Penalty and disallowance, which are separate
The penalty for a failure to deduct is imposed on the same facts, and it is not automatic. The statute requires the officer to be satisfied that the failure was without good and sufficient reason, and a deductor who has a reasonable explanation — a genuine doubt about the applicability of the provision, a dispute about the character of the payment — can resist the penalty even where the tax is confirmed.
The disallowance in the assessment is a third proceeding, and it is answered in the assessment with the same material. Where the tax has been paid by the payee and the certificate is filed, the disallowance should not be made. Where the deductor has paid the tax under the order, the position on disallowance depends on the timing of the payment, and the reply should set out the dates.
Our page on tax practice covers the appeal, and corporate compliance covers the monthly deduction routine that prevents the notice.
The routine that avoids all of this
Most Section 201 demands come from a failure to deduct on a payment that the accounts department did not recognise as covered. Rent above the threshold, professional fees, contract payments, commission, interest other than on specified instruments, and payments to non-residents are the recurring categories. A deduction matrix, reviewed at the time of payment and not at the time of the return, prevents the error.
Second, reconcile the quarterly statements with the books before filing. The statement reports the payments and the deduction; the books record the expense. A reconciliation at the quarter end catches the missed deduction while it can still be corrected with interest, which is far cheaper than the notice.
Third, keep the payee's declaration and, where applicable, the lower deduction certificate. Where the payee has obtained a certificate for a lower rate, the deduction at that rate is lawful, and the certificate must be on the file for the quarter.
Common questions
Is the deductor liable if the payee has already paid tax?
Not if the deductor produces the certificate in the prescribed form confirming the payee's return and payment. That is the statutory relief, and it is the first defence to raise.
Can interest be waived?
Interest is compensatory and is generally not waived, though the period can be corrected where the computation is wrong. A reduction is sometimes granted where the delay was caused by the department's own portal, but it requires evidence of the failure.
What if the notice covers a period for which the records are lost?
Reconstruct from the bank statements, the ledger and the vendor's invoices, and from the payee's own confirmation. A reconstruction is accepted where it is consistent and documented, and the alternative is to accept the department's computation.
Does the demand attract prosecution?
A failure to pay after deduction can attract prosecution in serious cases, particularly where the amount is large and the failure is repeated. A failure to deduct is ordinarily dealt with by the demand and the penalty, not by prosecution.
If a notice has arrived, the certificate from the payee's accountant is the document to obtain first, and the limitation is the second point to check. Bring the notice, the statements and the challans to a consultation, or write to the office with the computation attached.