14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Tax & GST

ITAT Kolkata: how an appeal and a hearing run

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal is the second appellate forum for a taxpayer, hearing appeals against orders of the Commissioner (Appeals) and against certain orders passed by the assessing authority. The itat kolkata appeal is filed within sixty days of the order appealed against, in the prescribed form, with the statement of facts and the grounds, and it is heard by a division bench of a judicial member and an accountant member.

The tribunal is the first forum that is not the department. It is independent, it hears both sides in open court, and it decides on the record that the lower authorities built. That last point decides most appeals: the tribunal does not take fresh evidence as a matter of course, so the appeal is only as good as the paper.

Who can appeal, and against what

An assessee can appeal against an order of the Commissioner (Appeals), against an order imposing a penalty, against certain orders under the reassessment provisions, and against orders passed by the authority under the revision power. The department can also appeal, and it does so frequently, which is why a taxpayer who wins before the Commissioner (Appeals) may find the file reopened by the department's appeal.

The appeal has to be against an order that is appealable, and the order has to be a final one on the issue. An intimation under the processing provision, a notice, and an order that merely adjourns are not appealable. Filing an appeal against a non-appealable order produces a dismissal for want of jurisdiction, and the time lost is unrecoverable.

The Kolkata bench hears appeals from West Bengal, Sikkim and the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, and its sittings are allocated among the benches by roster. A case filed in Kolkata stays in Kolkata; there is no transfer to another bench because a party prefers it.

The filing, and the paper that goes with it

The appeal is filed electronically, with the form, the grounds, the statement of facts, the copy of the order appealed against, and the proof of the fee. The fee depends on the assessed income or the tax involved, and the schedule is in the rules.

The grounds of appeal are the heart of the document. Each ground should state the issue, the finding of the lower authority, the reason it is wrong, and the relief sought. A ground that says "the order is bad in law" without more is treated as an argument to be developed, and the bench may decline to admit a ground that was not taken below.

The paper book is what the bench reads: the assessment order, the first appellate order, the return, the audited accounts, the submissions filed, and the documents on which the appellant relies. It should be paginated, with an index, and the relevant pages should be flagged in the grounds. A bench that has to search a five-hundred-page compilation for the one invoice will not be persuaded by it.

The hearing

The case is called, the appellant's representative argues first, then the departmental representative replies, and the appellant has a right of rejoinder. The bench may ask for a particular document, may direct the filing of the case law, and may adjourn. Adjournments are granted but they are not indefinite, and the tribunal's rules discourage repeated requests.

Where the appellant does not appear, the appeal can be dismissed for default, and it can be restored on an application showing sufficient cause. That is a costly way to lose an appeal that was ready, and it happens mostly where the representative changes.

The order is usually pronounced at the end of the hearing or shortly after, and the written order follows. A short order that disposes of the grounds with reasons is the norm; a detailed order is reserved for a substantial question of law or a conflict of decisions.

What the tribunal can do

The tribunal may confirm, reduce, enhance or annul the assessment, may set it aside and remand it for a fresh decision, and may admit additional evidence in limited circumstances where the lower authority refused to admit it or where the evidence was not available then.

A remand is the commonest outcome where the record is incomplete. It resets the issue to the assessing officer with directions, and the taxpayer starts again at the assessment stage with a better record. A remand can be a victory, but it is also a delay of years, and it should be sought deliberately.

The tribunal also has power to grant a stay of the demand while the appeal is pending, on conditions. The application for stay is separate, and it is decided on the financial hardship and the prima facie strength of the case. A stay is not automatic, and an assessee who does not apply may face recovery during the appeal.

Where the matter goes next

An appeal from the tribunal lies to the High Court on a substantial question of law, and the question has to be framed. The Calcutta High Court hears such appeals from this bench, and it does not re-appreciate the evidence.

Within the tribunal, a miscellaneous application lies against an order that contains a mistake apparent from the record, and it is filed within six months. It is not a review of the merits, and an application that repeats the arguments of the appeal is dismissed.

A writ petition lies against an order that is without jurisdiction, and it is not a substitute for the appeal. A review of the assessment record before the appeal is filed is what makes the paper book complete, and a written submission at the assessment stage is what the tribunal reads first.

Common questions

How long does an ITAT appeal take?

There is no reliable estimate. A simple appeal on a documented issue can be heard within a year or so of filing, and a complex one or one that goes to remand can take several years. The hearing date depends on the bench's docket and the roster.

Do I need to pay the demand before filing the appeal?

No, the appeal does not require a pre-deposit, but the demand is recoverable unless a stay is granted. The stay application should be filed with the appeal, and it should set out the hardship and the prima facie case.

Can the tribunal admit a new document?

Additional evidence can be admitted in limited circumstances, generally where the lower authority refused to admit it or where it could not have been produced earlier. The application should explain both, and the tribunal may remand the issue instead of deciding on the new document.

Can I appear without a lawyer?

Yes. An assessee may appear in person or through an authorised representative, including a chartered accountant or an advocate. The tribunal's procedure is less formal than a court's, but the grounds and the paper book still decide the case.

An appeal to the tribunal is an argument on a record that already exists. The grounds frame the question, the paper book answers it, and the hearing is short. Prepare the paper book as if the hearing will last twenty minutes, because it usually does.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422