14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Criminal Law

Victim compensation in West Bengal: applying

A victim of a crime in West Bengal can be compensated from a state fund without waiting for the trial to end and without proving the accused's guilt in a civil suit. The scheme is framed under the criminal procedure law, it is administered through the District Legal Services Authority, and the order is passed by the court or by the authority the scheme designates. Victim compensation west bengal therefore is not a claim against the offender; it is an application to the state, and the offender's conviction is helpful but not always necessary.

The scheme matters most in the cases where the offender is unknown, acquitted or insolvent. A family that has lost its earner in a violent crime, a woman who has been assaulted, a child who has been abused — none of them can recover from an accused who has nothing. The state fund is the only source, and it is under-used because the application is not made.

The statutory basis

Section 396 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 requires every state to prepare a scheme for compensation to victims, or to their dependents, who have suffered loss or injury as a result of a crime and who require rehabilitation. The section allows the court, on a recommendation or on its own, to order compensation from the fund, and it allows the state or the district authority to award compensation in cases where the offender is not traced or identified but the victim has suffered loss.

The scheme is notified by the state government, and it sets out the categories of offences, the maximum amount for each, the authority that decides, and the procedure. The scheme in West Bengal is administered at the district level, and the District Legal Services Authority is the body that receives and processes the application.

Two features are worth noting at the start. The compensation is not damages, and it is not intended to make the victim whole; it is a modest subvention. And the application does not require the accused to be convicted, though the stage of the criminal case affects which authority can act.

Who can apply, and for what

The victim, or a dependent where the victim has died or is incapacitated, may apply. Dependents include the spouse, children and parents, and in practice the legal heir certificate or the relationship documents are attached. Where the victim is a child, the application is made by the parent or guardian, and the compensation is ordinarily directed to be kept in a fixed deposit in the child's name.

The scheme covers loss of life, grievous hurt, injury requiring hospitalisation, sexual offences, trafficking, and loss to a person who has suffered because of a crime against the person or property where the loss is significant. The categories and the ceilings are in the scheme, and they are revised from time to time, so the current notification should be checked before an amount is claimed.

Compensation can be sought at different stages: during the trial, on conviction, or where the offender is not traced. The court before which the case is pending can recommend compensation, and the District Legal Services Authority can act on the recommendation. Where no case has been registered, the authority can still consider an application if the crime is established by other material, though the absence of a police record makes the decision harder.

The application, step by step

  1. Obtain the FIR copy, the medical papers and the post-mortem report where there has been a death. These establish the crime and the injury.
  2. Obtain the documents of loss — hospital bills, the death certificate, the income proof of the deceased, the school records of dependent children.
  3. File the application before the District Legal Services Authority for the district, or move the court hearing the case for a recommendation. In Kolkata the authority attached to the City Civil Court complex handles city applications.
  4. Attend the hearing. The authority may call for a report from the police or the probation officer, and may hear the victim or the dependents.
  5. The order is passed, and the amount is disbursed through the authority, sometimes in instalments and sometimes with conditions on how it is to be used.

The application should be supported by an affidavit and by a statement of the expenses incurred. A claim that is itemised is easier to decide than one that asks for a lump sum, and the authority is more willing to act where the bills and the certificates are on the file.

What the court can do during the trial

A magistrate or a sessions judge hearing a criminal case can direct compensation under the criminal procedure law as part of the sentence, in addition to the punishment. That route is quick and does not need a separate application, but it depends on a conviction and on the accused having money. Where the accused is acquitted, the court cannot order compensation against him, though the state scheme remains available.

In a motor accident case, compensation comes from the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal under the motor vehicles law, not from the victim compensation scheme, and the two should not be confused. Our page on motor accident claims covers that separate route, where the compensation is decided on the basis of the loss of dependency and the statutory amounts for funeral expenses and loss of consortium.

Where the crime is one of sexual violence, the scheme provides for interim compensation, and the application can be made before the trial concludes. The court can order interim relief on the application of the victim or the prosecutor, and the interim amount is adjusted against the final award.

The evidence that decides the amount

The authority looks at the nature of the injury, the medical treatment required, the loss of income, the dependents left behind, and the conduct of the victim. A victim who has cooperated with the investigation and has attended the trial is in a better position than one who has not, though the scheme is not a reward for cooperation.

Income is proved by the salary slips, the income tax return, or, for a person in the informal sector, the affidavit of the family and the evidence of the trade. A street vendor's income is not documented, and the authority will accept a reasonable estimate supported by the family's statement and the local circumstances.

The medical evidence is the spine of the claim. The discharge summary, the bills, the disability certificate where there is one, and the opinion of the treating doctor on the duration of treatment should all be on file. A claim for grievous hurt without a medical record is a claim that will be adjourned.

Where the application is refused or delayed

A refusal is usually recorded with a reason — the wrong forum, the absence of an FIR, the failure to produce the medical papers, or the conclusion that the loss does not fall within the scheme. Each of those can be answered if the reason is known. Ask for the order in writing, and for the reason.

Where the authority keeps the file pending for months, a representation to the member secretary of the State Legal Services Authority, and thereafter a writ petition before the Calcutta High Court, are the remedies. A writ in a compensation matter is not the first resort, but it is effective where the delay is unexplained and the victim is in immediate need.

The timeline in these matters is unpredictable, and a family should not treat the application as a substitute for the criminal case or for a civil claim. It is one of several sources, and the others should be pursued in parallel.

Common questions

Does the accused have to be convicted first?

No. The scheme allows compensation where the offender is not traced or identified, and the court can recommend compensation during the trial. A conviction makes the order easier and may allow the court to fix the amount against the accused as well, but it is not a precondition for the state fund.

Can compensation be claimed for property loss?

The scheme is directed mainly at loss of life and personal injury, and property loss is covered only in the categories the scheme lists, and usually at a modest level. For a substantial property loss, the remedy is a civil suit or a claim in the criminal case for restitution of the property seized.

Is the money taxable?

Compensation received for personal injury is generally not treated as income, and the amounts under a state scheme are paid as relief rather than as income. Where the amount is large and the treatment in the assessment year is unclear, the position should be checked with the assessing officer's circulars before the return is filed.

What if the victim dies before the application is decided?

The dependents can continue the application, and the authority can pass the order in their favour. The death certificate and the proof of dependency should be placed on the file as soon as they are available, so that the order is not passed in the name of a person who is no longer alive.

If a crime has left a family without an earner, the compensation application is worth making within weeks, while the medical and police papers are still being collected. Bring the FIR, the medical records and the expense bills to a consultation, or read the criminal law pages and consumer protection material where the loss also involves a service provider. The office can tell you which authority has your district's file.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422