14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Family Law

A will without probate: where it works and where not

A will can be perfectly valid and still be unusable without probate in Kolkata, because a Hindu will made within the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court needs probate before any right as executor or legatee can be established under it. Outside that area the position is different. The will without probate question therefore has two answers, and which one applies depends on where the will was made and who made it.

This is not a technicality that a bank will overlook. An executor who walks into a bank with a will and a death certificate will usually be asked for probate or letters of administration, and a registrar asked to mutate property on the strength of a will will usually ask for the same.

The statutory rule

Section 213 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 provides that no right as executor or legatee can be established in any court of justice unless a court of competent jurisdiction has granted probate of the will, or letters of administration with the will annexed. Sub-section (2) restricts that requirement to wills made by a Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh or Jain, and to the territories that were within the jurisdiction of the High Courts at Calcutta, Madras and Bombay at the time the section was enacted.

The effect for Kolkata is that a Hindu will made within the city's original jurisdiction needs probate. For a will made outside that area, probate is not a precondition to establishing a right, and an executor or legatee can rely on the will in a suit and in the revenue office, subject to proving it in the ordinary way.

The distinction is often lost on families who live in Behala or Garia and deal with land in a district. The place where the will was made, and the religion of the testator, decide which rule applies, and the file should record both.

What probate is, and what it decides

Probate is a grant by the court certifying the will and confirming the executor's authority to administer the estate. It is granted in a proceeding in which notice is issued to the persons who would inherit on intestacy, and it becomes conclusive as to the will's due execution and validity once the period for challenge has passed, save for fraud or for a person who was not given notice.

An uncontested probate is decided on affidavits. The propounder proves the death, produces the will, proves its execution through at least one attesting witness where the will is required to be attested, and satisfies the court that the testator had testamentary capacity and executed the will freely.

A contested probate becomes a suit, with a caveat, pleadings, evidence and a judgement. That is the subject of the companion note on resisting a grant.

The forum in Kolkata

Probate of a will of a person who died domiciled in Kolkata, leaving property within the city, is granted by the Calcutta High Court on its original side in its testamentary and intestate jurisdiction. For estates in the districts, the application goes to the District Judge, which in practice means the district court at Alipore or Barasat, and the district delegate for the smaller estates.

The petition is filed with the will, the death certificate, the schedule of assets and their valuation, the names of the heirs and their addresses, and the court fee, which in West Bengal is ad valorem on the value of the estate. The fee is the reason many families delay, and the delay is often a false economy, because the assets remain locked and the disputes grow.

Acting without probate

An executor named in a will can take steps to preserve the estate before probate: he can pay funeral expenses, secure the property, and collect debts that are due. What he should not do is distribute the estate to the legatees and close the file, because a legatee who later finds the will challenged has to return what he received, and the executor is personally liable for a distribution made before the grant.

Banks, registrars, companies and mutual funds have their own requirements. A bank may release a small balance against an indemnity and a no-objection from the heirs, and will insist on probate for a large one. A registrar will ordinarily require probate or letters of administration before mutating land on the strength of a will, because the will has to be proved and the office is not the forum to prove it.

For shares held in dematerialised form, the depository participant's rules govern, and the transmission requires the death certificate, the will and, where the value is above the threshold, probate.

The will that is not probated, and the family that acts on it

Families often distribute an estate on a will without probate, by consent, and the arrangement works until one member changes his mind. At that point the will is disputed in a civil suit, and the party relying on it must prove it, with the attesting witness if he is alive, and the burden is on him.

A probate obtained at the outset avoids that, because the grant is conclusive and the challenge must be made in the probate proceeding, not years later in a partition suit.

What goes wrong

The first failure is treating a registered will as a probated will. Registration proves that the document was deposited, not that it is valid, and it does not substitute for probate within the Calcutta jurisdiction.

The second is an executor who pays the legatees and then discovers a later will. The earlier will was revoked by the later one, and the payments were made under a document that no longer had effect.

The third is a probate petition that omits an heir, which makes the grant vulnerable when the omitted heir applies to revoke it.

Do I always need probate in Kolkata?

For a Hindu will made within the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court, yes, if a right as executor or legatee is to be established. For a will made outside that area, probate is not a statutory precondition, though institutions may still ask for it.

Can a bank release money without probate?

Some banks will release a modest balance against an indemnity and the consent of the heirs, and most will require probate or letters of administration for a substantial balance. The bank's own policy decides, and it is worth asking before the petition is filed.

Does a will need to be registered?

No. Registration is optional, and an unregistered will is valid if it is properly executed and attested. Registration helps prove the document and its date, and it does not dispense with probate where probate is required.

What if the will is contested?

The probate proceeding becomes contentious, a caveat is filed by the person opposing, and the matter is tried as a suit. The propounder must prove due execution, capacity and freedom, and the contest can take years.

Probate is a procedure with a known path, and the decision to file it should be taken early, before the family's positions harden. Our family law practice handles probate and letters of administration on the original side of the Calcutta High Court, and the registration team deals with the mutation that follows the grant. Begin at our contact page.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422